Advertisement

HindustanTimes Wed,03 Sep 2014

CVC on thin ice as SC grills Centre

HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times  New Delhi, January 28, 2011
First Published: 00:13 IST(28/1/2011) | Last Updated: 01:23 IST(28/1/2011)

The continuation of Central Vigilance Commissioner (CVC) P J Thomas in office became more tenuous as Supreme Court raised further doubts about the process of his appointment.

Among other things, the SC has questioned if the decision to appoint Thomas would not get vitiated by the fact that a pending corruption charge sheet against him was not placed before the appointing panel headed by the prime minister.

The Kerala government had sanctioned his prosecution on the basis of that chargesheet.

"It's better if he (the CVC) resigns," a senior government functionary admitted. When the case had flared up in November 2010 Thomas had offered to quit but ultimately did not. Thomas was not available for comment.

To a specific query from a bench headed by Chief Justice SH Kapadia, Attorney General G E Vahanvati said: "It's a matter of fact that the material pertaining to the chargesheet and sanction for his prosecution… was not before the committee. Only the bio-data of the three candidates was placed before it. Since there are no minutes of the meeting, it would be difficult to say whether the aspect of corruption case was discussed or not."

The leader of opposition (Sushma Swaraj) had simply written a note 'I disagree", he told the court after placing the records before the court.

Swaraj has said that she will file an affidavit in court challenging the government.

"The government is speaking one untruth after another," she said.

The Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) is responsible for placing the files pertaining to each candidate before the high-powered committee.

Surprised at the revelation, the bench asked if the high-powered committee's decision, in absence of such crucial facts, vitiated the appointment-making procedure.

The AG answered in the negative.

"No, it does not. Thomas had got CVC clearance before his appointment at the Centre," Vahanvati said.

Vahanvati, however, said: "If your Lordships feel otherwise, then perhaps we need to reconsider this (the appointment procedure.)"

SC also asked the government to explain how candidates for the post were short-listed and eliminated.


Advertisement
more from New Delhi

Out of form AAP to work out hierarchy, train volunteers

The Aam Aadmi Party is now aiming at getting its organisational structure right. Topmost things on its list of priorities are developing a power hierarchy and the registration as well as training of its volunteer force. Party chief Arvind Kejriwal’s direct interaction with his cadre is next.
Advertisement
Most Popular
Advertisement
Advertisement
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved