HindustanTimes Tue,16 Sep 2014

'Govt attacks clean CAG, but defends tainted CVC'

Vikas Pathak, Hindustan Times  New Delhi, January 18, 2011
First Published: 23:59 IST(18/1/2011) | Last Updated: 01:14 IST(19/1/2011)

The NDA has mounted its attack on the government for defending the appointment of PJ Thomas as the Central Vigilance Commissioner (CVC).


The government had said the decision was its prerogative and was a majority judgment of the selection panel comprising the Prime Minister, Home Minister and Leader of the Opposition.

"The government is saying that it was a 2:1 majority decision. Then why is the Opposition leader there, for the Opposition will be in a perpetual minority given the composition of the panel," NDA convenor and JD(U) chief Sharad Yadav told HT. "Then how will the CVC be autonomous and impartial? Do they call the Opposition leader for a cup of tea? The appointment of this CVC is illegal and he must resign."

BJP chief spokesperson Ravi Shankar Prasad was no less scathing: "It is a strange situation that the government is defending a tainted CVC and unleashing an aggressive attack on an upright CAG. But in the process the credibility of both institutions is being weakened."

He cited a department of personnel and public grievances circular of 1992 to state that at the time of promotion of an official, whether he had a disciplinary process or criminal proceedings pending against him was taken into account.

"We ask the Prime Minister, when even a small appointment is done with due diligence, why was this not followed while appointing the top anti-corruption watchdog? What is the compulsion for defending a tainted CVC?" Prasad asked. "And Sonia ji should reply why she lays down five bullet points against corruption for Congressmen but none for the CVC's appointment?"

He also asked why the government was reluctant to reveal the names of Indians with black money stashed abroad, and had not shared the names with the SC on condition of secrecy.

more from New Delhi

Whodunit: Removing HT market copies to win ‘morning challenge’?

As the strongest and the largest read newspaper of Delhi NCR, HT is used to facing challenges from various quarters. But, over the last few days, HT has been confronting a peculiar challenge: readers complaining about copies not reaching them.

Most Popular
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved