Advertisement

HindustanTimes Wed,23 Jul 2014

Home and foreign ministries spar over Italian marines' case

PTI  New Delhi, April 03, 2013
First Published: 21:58 IST(3/4/2013) | Last Updated: 23:42 IST(3/4/2013)

Confusion prevailed on Wednesday over who will probe the killing of two Kerala fishermen allegedly by two Italian marines and what charges will be slapped against the accused as external affairs ministry and home ministry expressed conflicting views over it.

Advertisement

While the home ministry has been maintaining that the case has been handed over to NIA following the Supreme Court's ruling that Kerala government has no jurisdiction to prosecute the marines, the external affairs ministry said "no formal notification" on who will probe the matter has been issued so far.

Official spokesperson of MEA Syed Akbaruddin said "there is no formal decision on which investigating agency will conduct the probe. No formal notification has been issued so far".

According to home ministry officials, they have not yet received the exact text of the communication given by New Delhi to Rome giving clarification on the death sentences given to the murder accused.

MHA officials said if any assurance has been given to Italy that prosecutors will not press for death sentence against the marines, Massimiliano Lattore and Salvatore Girone, it will be duly honoured.

Officials said if any assurance was given to Italy on not providing death sentence, then the marines could be tried under Section 302 (murder) of the Indian Penal Code or IPC Section 304 (culpable homicide not amounting to murder).

Since the case is not a rarest of rare case, even after murder conviction of the marines under Section 302, they will not be given capital punishment.

In that case, the Suppression of Unlawful Acts Against Safety of Maritime Navigation and Fixed Platforms on Continental Shelf Act 2002 will not be slapped against the marines under which offence of murder is punishable with death sentence. 

There is also no clarity whether NIA will have to conduct the probe from the beginning or if it can take over the case from Kerala Police as the Supreme Court has not clarified on it.

Because of all this confusion, no case has been registered by NIA yet.

The apex court had on January 18 said the marines onboard the merchant ship 'Enrica Lexie', accused of shooting dead the two fishermen in February last year, be shifted to Delhi and beunder the 'custody' of the Supreme Court till the Centre constitutes a special court to hold their trial.

"The incident of firing from the Italian vessel on the Indian vessel having occurred within the Contiguous Zone, the Union of India is entitled to prosecute the two Italian marines under the criminal justice system prevalent in the country," the bench had said.

Commenting on the delay in constitution of the special court to try the marines, Akbaruddin said the court has to be "unique which does not follow a pattern previously and therefore, we have to be cautious and careful and act with circumspection" as it was open to various legal interpretation and questioning.

He also said it has to be established after a "rigorous and well-thought" process.


Advertisement
more from New Delhi

Corrupt judge charge: BJP seeks answer from former PM

BJP on Tuesday asked former PrimeMinister Manmohan Singh and the Congress to answer allegations of "improper compromises" by three ex-CJIs during UPA rule, saying the matter was "unfortunate".

Advertisement
Most Popular
Advertisement
Advertisement
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved