HindustanTimes Mon,20 Oct 2014

Was Pandher's sentence the rarest of rare?

IANS  New Delhi, February 13, 2009
First Published: 22:17 IST(13/2/2009) | Last Updated: 12:20 IST(14/2/2009)
The death sentence to Moninder Singh Pandher and his domestic help Surendra Koli has led to a legal debate with some saying they were opposed to capital punishment on principle while others said this was the copybook "rarest of rare" case warranting the gallows.


As news came in of a Ghaziabad court giving capital punishment to the two for the rape, murder and cannibalisation of 14-year-old Rimpa Haldar, lawyers debated the issue. It is the first verdict in the Nithari killings, in which the body parts of 19 children and young women were found behind Pandher's bungalow in suburban Noida in December 2006.

"I am in principle against death sentences. Here, if it is in the Indian Penal Code (IPC) - then the two must deserve it. At least Koli certainly deserved it, regarding Pandher, I am doubtful," Soli J. Sorabjee, former solicitor general of India, told IANS.

The CBI in its chargesheet in the gruesome murder of Haldar in May 2007 had exonerated 55-year-old Pandher of abduction, rape and murder saying he was not in the country at the time. Two months later, however, the court reprimanded the investigating agency and Pandher was made co-accused with Koli, 38.

Leading lawyer R.K. Naseem maintained that capital punishment was for the rarest of cases - and the Nithari killings did not qualify yet.

more from New Delhi

Delhi Metro may come to ITO a year early; safety trials kick off in December

Delhi Metro is set to beat its deadline for extending the Central Secretariat-Mandi House line to ITO by a year, a move that will bring relief to thousands of commuters who battle daily gridlocks on one of the city’s busiest stretches.
Most Popular
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved