can take as lump sum, is tax free. The remaining needs to get annuitized or go into buying a pension product that gives periodic income.
Let’s first understand the basic structure of a pension plan.
The latest ULPPs
Design: ULPPs come with a lock-in period of five years. So even if you wish to surrender or terminate your policy within five years, you will get your money back only after the lock-in period gets over.
In order to discourage surrender and partial withdrawals, the guidelines dictate that you need to buy either a single-premium pension policy or annuitize a portion of the corpus (even surrender value) from the same insurer. You will need to annuitize at least two-thirds of the corpus.
Cost: ULPPs need to conform to the same cost caps to which Ulips do. Just like Ulips, the reduction in yield, difference between gross yield and net yield, can’t exceed 4 percentage points in the fifth year, coming down to 2.25% in the 15th year and thereafter.
Even on surrender, ULPPs can’t charge more than R6,000 as surrender or discontinuance charge and this is applicable only in the first four years.
Investment: The investment pattern of these products has altered too. Earlier, your investment in ULPPs was market-linked. But now Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDA) has mandated a minimum non-zero positive return of premiums that will be given on maturity or to the beneficiary in case of the policyholder’s death.
The trade-off: The element of guarantee comes with two major setbacks. You can no longer get a pure equity-linked investment and it is likely that insurers will charge you extra for offering the guarantee. “The guidelines have mandated a capital guarantee which will make it very difficult for the insurers to offer pure equity-linked options,” said Rituraj Bhattacharya, head (product development and market management), Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance. “Also, even as insurers invest in debt, it isn’t completely risk-free, so in that sense they will still need to account for a capital guarantee. For this, the insurer may charge extra to the policyholder.”
Keep in mind that the charge on guarantee is currently excluded from costs caps. This means when you see the illustration of the product, you are most likely to get a published net return which does not factor in costs such as guarantee and mortality costs. So if you are comparing, look at the fund value and not the net return.
The two plans
Pension Super Plus: The maximum exposure to equity in this HDFC Life plan is 60%. (see graphic for details)
Pension Super Plus charges a guarantee charge of 0.4% of the fund value. Additionally it also has a mortality cost.
Shubh Retirement: There are three investment options to choose from this ICICI Prudential Life plan: Aggressive investment option caps equity exposure at 75%, moderate investment option caps equity exposure at 50% and the conservative investment option caps it at 25%. The policy promises higher of the fund value or minimum guaranteed benefit on maturity as well as death of the policyholder.
The guaranteed benefit under this plan varies depending upon your investment option, premium paying term and policy term. For instance, if a 35 year old invests R1 lakh every year for a premium paying term of 10 years for a policy term of 30 years, the maximum under the plan, he will get an assured maturity benefit of R10.1 lakh at the end of 30 years or a maximum death benefit of R10.1 lakh in case of death. Through a conservative investment option, these guarantees would increase to R19 lakh as the guaranteed maturity benefit and maximum assured death benefit.
Shubh Retirement in comparison charges only a guarantee charge of 0.5%.
What should you do?
These plans may not appeal to aggressive investors since they are not purely equity-linked. Even conservative investors should put some thought before buying these since the plans are expensive and the guarantees they offer are not much to write home about. If you want to save for retirement, capital protection is not very high on the agenda and if you are willing to take little or no exposure to equities, consider investing in the National Pension System (NPS), which is a cost-effective option. The only disadvantage with NPS currently is that on maturity, the corpus, 60% that you can keep as lump sum, is not tax-free. However, this is likely to get rectified soon.