Dinesh Trivedi (C) gestures as he arrives at Parliament flanked by minister of state for railway Muniyappa ((L) as they are surrounded by media representatives in New Delhi.Indian Railways Minister Dinesh Trivedi presents the railway budget for the fiscal year to March 2012-13 in Parliament. AFP Photo/Raveendran
"The increase in passenger fares was overdue, expected and welcome but more initiative and reform was required in the freight segment," said NR Bhanumurthy, professor at National Institute of Public Finance and Policy
. "There is a huge volatility in financial markets, so I am not very sure if they would be able to borrow Rs. 15,000 crore from the markets. Alternately, they should have explored the PPP (public-private partnership) route more intensely. Overall, it is a missed opportunity as far as reforms is concerned."
The budget digs into recommendations made by various committees including one by technocrat Sam Pitroda. The outlay has been raised to Rs. 60,100 crore while the investment plan for the 12th Five-Year Plan has seen a quantum jump from Rs. 192,000 crore to Rs. 735,000 crore.
But not enough attention has been devoted to freight earnings, which contributes to the bulk of the Railways' earnings. The Railways carried 970 million tonnes of freight in 2011-12, missing the target of 995 mt.
"The budgeted freight earnings (growth) target for next fiscal at 30.2% may be difficult to achieve.....the share of freight in total railway earnings has declined from more than 80% in 1950-51 to 66% in 2011-12," said Rajiv Kumar, secretary-general, FICCI. "The finances of the Railways in the current fiscal may not be in ideal shape. Receipts-over- expenditure (surplus) has been revised downwards from Rs. 5,158 crore to Rs. 1,492 crore. This shows a sharp deterioration in railway finances, which is not healthy."
The Indian Railways' network is spread over 64,000 km, with 12,000 passenger and 7,000 freight trains each day from 7,083 stations that ferry 23 million travellers and 2.7 million tonnes of goods daily. With a turnover of Rs. 106,000 crore, it is world's third largest railway network and one of the largest employers worldwide.
"The rail budget is a missed opportunity in a big way," said Ajay Mittal, chairman, Arshiya International Ltd. "On a scale of 10, it scores a 2."