Two New York City police officers were acquitted on Thursday of raping a drunken woman they had been called to help but were convicted of official misconduct.
Officers Franklin Mata and Kenneth Moreno look stunned after hearing the verdict.
They were called to help the woman get
out of a taxi in 2008. The woman testified that she passed out and awoke to being raped in her apartment.
Moreno told jurors that he lay alongside her in her bed for a while but that they didn't have sex.
Mata was accused of acting as a lookout. He said he was napping in the living room while the others were in the bedroom.
During the trial, prosecutors told a stunning story of police misconduct and a perverse abuse of power. The officers acknowledged a number of missteps â€” including Moreno making a bogus 911 call â€” but said that they weren't crimes and that the rape allegation was a product of the woman's muddled memory.
Mata, 29, and Moreno, 43, have been suspended until a police department review after their trial.
The officers were each convicted of three official misconduct charges, all misdemeanors, for going back to the woman's apartment three times after the initial call without telling dispatchers or superiors where they were. They face possible sentences from no jail time to a year in jail on each.
Besides the rape acquittal, they were acquitted of other charges including burglary and falsifying business records.
The woman, a fashion product developer who's now 29, had gotten very drunk while out with friends celebrating her impending promotion and move to California. A cab driver called police for help getting her out of his taxi around 1 a.m. on Dec. 7, 2008.
The officers didn't tell dispatchers where they were as they repeatedly returned to her apartment â€” to check on her at her request, they said. Indeed, Moreno, a police officer for 17 years, admitted he invented an excuse for one of the visits by calling 911 with a phony report of a homeless man sleeping in a nearby building's lobby.
Her blood-alcohol level was three or more times the legal limit for driving, and she acknowledged during days of testimony that her memory of the night was spotty.
But she said that she acutely remembered the rape, and that other vivid snippets â€” police radio chatter, flashlights, the same man's voice urging her to drink water in her bathroom and later asking her if she wanted him to stay in her bedroom â€” made her certain that her attacker was an officer.
"I couldn't believe that two officers who had been called to help me had, instead, raped me," said the woman, who has sued the city seeking $57 million over the incident.
After consulting prosecutors, she secretly recorded a conversation with Moreno a few days later. He alternately denied they had sex and seemed to admit it, particularly by saying twice that he'd used a condom when she asked him.
Moreno told jurors he was just "telling her what she wanted to hear" because she had suggested she'd go into the stationhouse where he worked and make a scene.
No DNA evidence was collected in the case, and experts debated whether an internal mark found during an examination of the woman could be interpreted as a sign of rape.
Moreno said he was only trying to console and counsel the woman about drinking during his series of visits, as he shared his own struggle with alcoholism some years before, killed a cockroach in her bathroom, made plans to have breakfast with her and sang to her a verse of Bon Jovi's "Livin' on a Prayer."
On the last visit, Moreno said, he suddenly found himself fending off drunken advances from the woman.
"I told her, 'There's another time for this. Not tonight.' ... I kind of had her by the shoulders, and I said, 'We're not doing this,'" he told jurors.
But, he said, he wound up in her bed after she fell and got stuck between her bed and a wall and needed to be freed. He said he stayed there with his arms around her for a time, out of sympathy, but kept his uniform on and didn't have sex with her.
Mata, a police officer for about five years, acknowledged during his testimony that he couldn't be sure what had happened between the two while he was snoozing on the woman's sofa. But he said he didn't believe Moreno had raped the woman because "Ken wouldn't do something like that."
He was charged with rape under state legal principles that hold an alleged accessory as responsible for a crime as the main defendant.
© Copyright © 2013 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved.