‘Injuries not possible with golf club, scalpel’

  • Peeyush Khandelwal, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
  • |
  • Updated: Jun 25, 2013 23:53 IST

Contradicting the prosecution’s claim, a defence witness in the Aarushi-Hemraj double-murder case on Tuesday told a Ghaziabad court that the injuries on the victims could not have been inflicted with golf sticks or a surgical scalpel.

Senior forensic expert Dr RK Sharma gave his opinion after examination of post-mortem reports of both victims, testimonies of two doctors who conducted the post-mortems and photographs taken from the scene of crime.

Sharma told the court that injuries inflicted by golf sticks would leave a “depressed fracture” and the impact would press the bone. “In both post-mortem reports, there is no mention of depressed-fracture. Hemraj’s post-mortem report indicates a 8x2cm injury mark which is not possible with a golf stick,” Sharma said.

“Aarushi Talwar’s post-mortem report indicates only fracture but there is no mention of depressed fracture...So Aarushi’s injury is not possible with a golf stick,” he said. On the slit throats of both victims, Sharma said it could not have been a scalpel because the injuries “were deep and extensive...(it) is not possible through use of blade number 15 of a scalpel”.

Sharma said blade number 10 is generally used for murders. “Generally, injuries inflicted by a scalpel have a slashed pattern...throat injuries of both victims don’t show a slash pattern but both have deep cuts, which are possible by a heavy, sharp-edged and round-type murder weapon,” Sharma said.

Earlier, prosecution witness Sunil Dohre, who conducted Aarushi’s post-mortem, had stated that the injuries on her body could have been caused by a golf stick and a small surgical weapon.

Likewise, Naresh Raj, who conducted Hemraj’s post-mortem, had stated that his neck injury could be the result of a hard sharp-edged item, possibly a surgical scalpel. He had stated the head injuries could be because of some hard item like a golf stick.

Fourteen-year old Aarushi was killed at her Noida residence on the intervening night of May 15-16, 2008. The body of their domestic help Hemraj was found on the terrace a day later. The CBI wanted to close the case but the trial court summoned her parents Rajesh Talwar and Nupur Talwar as accused in the case.


also read

Crime branch refuses to take up Sunanda case

blog comments powered by Disqus