Surfer Review: Siddhartha Chaturvedi
Kaminey..by far is not the best movie Vishal has made. Let's accept this. It lacked. It lacked the grip to hold people.entertainment Updated: Aug 19, 2009 15:27 IST
Hindustan Times invited Facebook users to submit their reviews on Vishal Bharadwaj's Kaminey. Thanks for the tremendous response. Here's one of the five selected reviews, that clearly stood apart.
Kaminey..by far is not the best movie Vishal has made. Let's accept this. It lacked. It lacked the grip to hold people. Though the film recovered well post intermission, but by then it was too late.
Shahid has sure come out as a winner more than the movie. Let us also accept it was a below average script turned into something watchable by Vishal.
Music is always the high point of this genius but this film's music is nowhere near Omkara. Dhan ta na is a copy of Black eyed peas. Fatak is a good track. Though like every other music director, he also had to opt for Mohit Chauhan. Problem with Mohit is...whenever he sings... all songs sound the same.
Somewhere down the line, the music director has lost his identity and has composed tracks that suit Mohit's voice. Overall, I am dissatisfied with the movie. Expected something much better than... just the...F...FFFFss