HindustanTimes Tue,16 Sep 2014

India’s stance on Israel: foreign policy fumble or mere pragmatism?

Zia Haq, Hindustan Times  New Delhi, July 18, 2014
First Published: 01:31 IST(18/7/2014) | Last Updated: 03:12 IST(18/7/2014)

Although it’s not quite the end of India’s old-school love of Palestine, the NDA’s move to block a discussion in Parliament on the Gaza offensive is a signal it won’t allow Israel-bashing anymore, much less tolerate it.

However, the NDA’s staunch support of Israel at home stands in contrast to a more measured stance in Brazil. The Fortaleza declaration at BRICS summit, which PM Narendra Modi signed along with other leaders, censures Israel on many counts.

Does it represent a foreign policy fumble?

“When the PM has signed the declaration condemning the attack on Gaza, then why is the government shying away for a discussion in Parliament?” senior Left MP, Sitaram Yechury asked, as did other parties.

Read: ISIS on mind, govt cautious on Gaza

Read: Rajya Sabha jam as ministers differ over Gaza debate

The Fortaleza declaration, circulated as an official release by India, says things Israel would not like to hear. It opposed Israel’s “continuous expansion” of settlements in Palestine, calling for solution based on the 1967 borders. It sought East Jerusalem as the future Palestine capital. More significantly, it endorses “intra-Palestinian unity, including the formation of a national unity government”, which refers to Hamas and Palestine government unity.

Foreign policy experts say the document proves that there has been no radical change. “At this stage, government is right not to take sides. But I don’t see any fundamental change in our support for Palestine,” says Lalit Mansingh, a former Indian envoy.

Yet, under the radar, India’s ties have grown deeper with Israel under different governments, centering around defence and security. The UPA government was more discreet about relations, although it ignored concerns of Muslims and Left groupings. The present right-wing government has no such obligations to sound apologetic when it comes to Israel.

Read: Israeli tanks shelling Gaza rehab hospital: director

Full coverage: Gaza under attack

more from India

India-China ties: Crouching dragon, hidden tiger

India and China are unlikely to play up differences over their disputed border and will instead focus on boosting economic ties to give a new direction to relations between two of Asia's largest economies during Chinese President Xi Jinping's visit beginning Wednesday. Here's a look at the highs and lows in ties between the neighbours.

Most Popular
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved