HindustanTimes Sat,20 Dec 2014

Digvijaya takes a dig at judiciary

Nagendar Sharma, Hindustan Times  New Delhi, May 13, 2013
First Published: 15:02 IST(13/5/2013) | Last Updated: 17:11 IST(26/7/2013)

Congress leader Digvijaya Singh on Monday questioned the Supreme Court's criticism of the CBI, triggering a political debate on whether judges should make oral comments against other institutions while hearing cases in open courts.

Singh's comments brought the focus back on the bill to discipline erring judges, which is pending in the Rajya Sabha.

The bill titled - Judicial Standards and Accountability Bill, which was passed by the Lok Sabha on March 30 last year and is now pending before the Rajya Sabha,includes a clause, which debars judges from making oral comments against other constitutional authorities in open courts.

Responding to the Supreme Court having called the CBI a "caged parrot", Singh said such a description by the judiciary amounted to belittling important institutions.

"I have never belittled the judiciary. But then my only request to the judiciary is that the off-the-cuff observations unfortunately create headlines, and at the same time the person against whom such remarks are made does not get the opportunity to appeal against these observations," Singh said.

"If the SC feels the heart of the coalgate report was changed by the law minister (Ashwani Kumar), then it should pass a judicial order. Observations do not fix responsibility," he said.

BJP slammed Singh for what it termed "blaming" the country's top court.  "If the CBI's morale has been downgraded, it is only because of its rank abuse by the government.

The CBI was deliberately not allowed to take up a fair investigation," said party leader Ravi Shankar Prasad.

CPI leader D Raja too said, "Leaders like Digvijay should understand that no constitutional body should be attacked."

However, both BJP and Left were represented in  the parliamentary standing committee on law and justice, which in its report in November 2011, had included the clause to treat unwarranted oral comments by judges against other authorities as judicial misbehavior.

more from New Delhi

Delhi: Schools on alert after Peshawar

The terror attack that killed over 130 students in Pakistan’s Peshawar has jolted city schools into taking all possible measures to tighten security in and around their campus. Many schools reported a drop in attendance after the attack.
Most Popular
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved