HindustanTimes Thu,24 Jul 2014

Prisoners good conduct Act challenged in HC

HT Correspondent , Hindustan Times  Chandigarh, July 20, 2013
First Published: 19:32 IST(20/7/2013) | Last Updated: 19:33 IST(20/7/2013)

Civil rights organisation People's Union of Civil Liberties (PUCL), Punjab and Chandigarh chapters, has challenged the Haryana Prisoners Good Conduct Amendment Act, 2012, in the Punjab and Haryana high court on the ground that it prohibits hardcore criminals from being released on temporary parole or furlough.


Taking up a public interest litigation, a division bench, comprising chief justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul and justice Augustine George Masih, while issuing notice of motion to the Haryana government has directed it to file its reply before September 16.

The petitioner's counsel submitted that barring prisoners from being considered for temporary release merely on the basis of an offence committed by them is arbitrary and, hence, unconstitutional. The court was informed that temporary release was essential for the reformation of a person into a law-abiding citizen and for his or her adjustment post-release.

The petitioner relied on a Delhi high court judgment of 2012 in 'Dinesh Kumar versus State of Delhi' case where the court had held unconstitutional similar provisions regarding furlough and temporary release pertaining to Delhi, as they barred prisoners merely on the ground that they had committed certain offences.

As per the newly inserted Section 2(aa) in the Haryana's Act, definition of hardcore prisoners include those who had been convicted of dacoity, robbery, kidnapping, ransom, murder with rape, serial killing, contract killing, murder or attempt to murder for ransom or extortion, causing grievous hurt, death or waging or attempting war against the government of India, buying or selling minor for purposes of prostitution or rape with a woman below 16 years of age. These hardcore criminals have been barred from being released temporarily on parole or furlough.

more from India

SGPC is for all India, Modi govt is with us: Badal

For long locked in intractable legal disputes over sharing of river waters and territorial claims, Punjab and Haryana are now sparring on politico-religious turf. And, the slugfest is only getting vicious and complicated by the day, raising the fears of religious frenzy that consumed Punjab in the dark 1980s. Vehemently opposed to Haryana’s move to set up a separate gurdwara panel, Punjab chief minister Parkash Singh Badal believes that the Amritsar-based SGPC’s supremacy must be maintained at all costs. He is even ready to step down as CM, if required, to scuttle the Congress’ ‘poll-oriented’ step. On the other hand, Haryana CM Bhupinder Singh Hooda vociferously defends the passing of a law by the state assembly to form a separate gurdwara management committee. He sees no impropriety at all.
Most Popular
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved