Why Parsis chose electric crematoriums? Because vultures are no more

  • AFP, Mumbai
  • Updated: Jun 07, 2016 14:01 IST
In this photo taken on May 10, 2016, a Parsi mourner (C) supports her parents as they leave after attending a funeral service of a member of the community at a prayer hall in Mumbai. (AFP)

Kaikobad Rustomfram always thought that when he died vultures would feast on his corpse, as is Zoroastrian tradition. But then the scavenging birds disappeared from India’s skies.

The 90-year-old was cremated last month instead of receiving a sky burial, one of a growing number of Parsis opting to use a new prayer hall in Mumbai that is changing the ancient community’s funeral customs.

Rustomfram’s wife, Khorshed, who died in January aged 82, also chose cremation at the ten-month-old facility, which conservative Zoroastrians oppose, in the centre of India’s bustling financial capital.

“They wanted to be cremated ever since they learnt that the traditional way of disposing of the dead wasn’t working because there were no vultures,” their daughter, Hutokshi Rustomfram, told AFP.

In this photo taken on May 10, 2016, a Parsi couple enters an electric crematorium to attend the last rites of a member of the community at a prayer hall in Mumbai. (AFP)

Zoroastrians believe in the god Ahura Mazda and follow the teachings of the ancient Prophet Zoroaster. They worship in ‘fire temples’, believing fire to be a symbol of god’s purity.

Known as Parsis, Zoroastrians first arrived in India more than 1,000 years ago after fleeing persecution in Persia.

They became one of India’s wealthiest communities, boasting a number of famed industrialists including the Tata family synonymous with the financial rise of Mumbai.

For centuries the community, which is dwindling at such a rapid rate that its future existence is now under threat, have laid their dead out at the city’s Towers of Silence.

Ravenous vultures would devour the flesh of the body within an hour, leaving the bones to dry in the sun before being placed in a well, an efficient disposal system believed to purify the deceased.

But India’s vulture population began to drastically decline in the early 1990s and was virtually wiped out by the mid noughties owing to Diclofenac, an anti-inflammatory drug used to treat cattle.

Birds which gorged on dead animals that had recently been administered the medicine died of kidney failure, resulting in the disappearance of around 99 percent of India’s total vulture population.

In this photo taken on May 10, 2016, mourners arrive for a funeral service at a Parsi prayer hall in Mumbai. (AFP)

- Toxic drug -

India banned the veterinary painkiller in 2006 but the damage to Zoroastrian sky burials had already been done, with claims that bodies were piling up at the tower in Mumbai’s plush Malabar Hill district.

“Kites and crows just pecked at the bodies. Those birds did nothing at all,” Dinshaw Tamboly, a former trustee of Mumbai’s leading Parsi organisation the Bombay Parsi Punchayet, told AFP.

“They would lie rotting in the heat for six to eight months. The pallbearers were complaining about the stench,” added the 71-year-old.

Two Parsis a day die on average in Mumbai. Across India, where most Zoroastrians live, their numbers have halved since 1940 to around 60,000.

With numbers dwindling, the community is split over how best to preserve their religion and culture, including the most appropriate way to dispose of the dead.

In this photo taken on May 10, 2016, mourners arrive for a funeral service at a Parsi prayer hall in Mumbai. (AFP)

Tamboly was one of several reformists to advocate that Parsi priests should be allowed to officiate at cremations.

After several years, space at an existing crematorium was granted by Mumbai’s civic local authority and a large private donation was received, allowing the hall to open in September last year.

Tamboly says the number of cremations at the centre, situated in the Worli area, are “steadily increasing” from four in the first month to an average of between eight and ten currently.

At Kaikobad Rustomfram’s funeral service two Parsi priests, clad entirely in white chant prayers from the sacred Zoroastrian text Avesta for an hour as around 80 mourners look on in the spotless hall.

“My father got a great sense of satisfaction that the prayers were performed in a suitably dignified and reverential manner here for my mother,” Rustomfram, 59, explained.

“It’s not a nice thought to think that your loved one’s body is lying there like that in a heap. My parents felt they should adapt to the times,” she added.

The strength of feeling runs equally deep amongst traditionalists.

In this photo taken on May 10, 2016, friends and family members take part in a funeral procession of a member of the Parsi community at a prayer hall in Mumbai. (AFP)

- Cremations ‘wrong’ -

Khojeste Mistree, an orthodox scholar, insists the sky burials still “work effectively, although slightly slower” without the vultures, and denies that there’s a stench emanating from the Towers of Silence.

He also points out that a “massive majority” still favour traditional decomposition. The numbers being cremated are rising significantly but it’s still a fraction of the small but influential community.

Jehangir Patel, editor of community magazine “Parsiana”, told AFP that cremations now accounted for around 15 percent of funerals in Mumbai’s community of an estimated 45,000 Parsis -- up from 6 percent before the prayer hall opened.

Mistree says that leaving corpses open to the skies is the only option because Zoroastrians believe dead bodies to be impure.

In this photo taken on May 10, 2016, a Parsi priest conducts a funeral service at a prayer hall in Mumbai. (AFP)

“Zoroastrians are extremely eco-conscious so the body cannot be burnt because that’s desecrating fire,” he told AFP.

“It cannot be buried because that’s polluting the earth and it cannot be drowned because that’s sullying the waters.

“Those who want to take the cremation route can certainly do it. But from a religious point of view clearly it’s wrong,” Mistree added.

For reformists such as 71-year-old Naval Surty and his wife, who have already told their two children that they wish to be cremated, they are merely being practical.

“If the vultures were still here then things would be different, but now this is the best way to let the body pass,” he told AFP.

In this photo taken on May 10, 2016, Parsi priest Pervez Dhanidaduna, 56, rests before a funeral service at a Parsi prayer hall in Mumbai. (AFP)

also read

The whole issue was treated like a joke: Kangana won’t endorse HP tourism
Show comments