Since the Diwali visit by Prime Minister Narendra Modi last October till Eid this July, hopes rose high in Jammu and Kashmir each time there was an occasion for announcement of a relief package.
And each time, hopes drowned and barely survived, just like people did last September, when the state was devastated by the worst floods in more than a century.
A year has passed since the deluge claimed over 300 lives, damaged over 2.6 lakh structures, including homes, and washed away crores of rupees worth roads, bridges and communication network, but there is still that sinking feeling in the Valley, which bore the brunt of the floods.
The trauma revisits people every time the skies open up. Many have not been able to rebuild their damaged homes and its economy is counting its piling up losses after a second year of slump in business and tourism.
A soldier carries a toddler as evacuated families alight from an Indian Air Force Mi-17 helicopter flying a rescue sortie in the Rajouri district during 2014 floods. HT File Photo
New Delhi has so far doled out the relief in bits and pieces, giving the opposition parties and the separatist groups a perfect recipe to stoke the anger of Kashmiris, many of whom say the handling of the situation by both the Modi government at Centre and the Mufti regime in Srinagar has reinforced the "feeling of alienation".
Local dailies and separatist groups are also drawing comparisons of the two Kashmirs – that how Pakistan-occupied Kashmir is being rebuilt by international aid after an earthquake, while this one was “neither allowed any international aid nor did Government of India provide any to rebuild homes and livelihoods”.
A call for observing September 7 as Black Day by the Kashmir Economic Alliance (KEA), an umbrella body of trade unions, private schools, besides other sectors like tourism, transport, agriculture and construction, got support from both opposition National Conference and the separatist groups.
The J&K High Court, hearing a public interest litigation, has also questioned the delay, and asked the Centre to spell out its relief policy by September 10.
Chief minister Mufti Mohammad Sayeed’s government, on his part, is sending distress signals for a face-saver to ally BJP.
Deputy CM Nirmal Singh told reporters in Srinagar on Saturday that Centre would soon sanction a “big package” for rehabilitation of the people affected in the floods and it would be bigger than the `44,000 crore that was sought by the previous government led by Omar Abdullah.
For now, however, the state’s coffers are as they were — empty.'Kashmir being punished'
Agirl being rescued by the army during the 2014 floods. HT Photo
At a joint press conference in June this year, Union ministers Arun Jaitley and Rajnath Singh had put the total of funds released to flood-affected J&K at Rs 5039 crore.
While releasing Rs 2437 crore, Jaitley said Rs 1,602 crore had already been released under the State Disaster Relief Fund and the National Disaster Relief Fund, besides a special project assistance of Rs 1,000 crore having been announced by the PM during his Diwali visit to the state.
Out of the Rs 1602 crore, however, Rs 500 crore were deducted to settle the bill of the defence ministry, for rescuing more than two lakh people, including tourists and non-Kashmiri labourers, and air-dropping food, water and medicines during “Operation Megh Rahat”. That left the civil society and trade groups fuming.
“Kashmir is being punished for giving a mandate against the BJP. But the PDP tied up with the BJP to form the government, selling us the promise of getting more funds for relief and development,” says Showkat Chaudhary of the Kashmir Economic Alliance.What was promised
People shifting to safer places during 2014 floods. HT File Photo
Of the estimated 2.03 lakh houses damaged in the floods, first instalment of relief under the PM Relief Fund went to 16,748 fully damaged houses.
Later in February, Prime Minister Modi announced Rs 426 crore to compensate `1.87 lakh severely and partially-damaged pucca and kutcha houses.
Relief of Rs 50,000 and Rs 25,000 was announced for severely and partially-damaged pucca houses respectively, and Rs 10,000 and Rs 5,000 for kutcha houses likewise. The assessment of the damage was verified by the patwaris.
Residents in the worst-hit localities claim that they have got Rs 1 lakh from PM relief fund and `25,000 from the state fund to rebuild fully-damaged concrete houses.
But a majority of homes fall in severely and partially-damaged categories have so far received payout of `3,800 and another Rs 1,500 for damaged possessions.
Likewise, industry was promised two-year moratorium on bank loan interest and soft loans. “Forget the two-year moratorium, one year is already gone. The next year, we will have to shut shop,” says Mohammad Sadiq Bakal, president of Kashmir Traders and Manufacturers’ Federation.
Lost in numbers
A lady along with her child salvages usable items from her destroyed house during 2014 flashfloods hit in a Jammu village. HT File Photo
Behind the delay in Centre announcing the relief package is also how the state pegged its losses.
Consultations between trade, industry and civil society groups had pegged the losses at Rs 100,000 crore. The then Omar Abdullah government had pruned it to a “realistic” Rs 4,000 crore.
When the PDP-BJP government brokered an alliance in March this year, it found even the Rs 44,000-crore demand difficult to defend as it also reportedly included the Rs 10,000 crore fiscal deficit of the state. Waheed-ur-Rehman Parra, political advisor to the CM, claims nothing came the state’s way since the new government took over.
“We got Rs 1,100 crore as an initial package, which was announced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi when he visited Kashmir during the floods. It was later followed by Rs 1,300 crore. Nothing has come for rehabilitation after that,” he said, his claims at variance with that of ally BJP.
Parra, however, blames the former government, saying their package proposal lacked explanations about utilisation and accountability. The Mufti government claims the Centre needed to know where the money will be spent.
To beat the previous regime in the numbers game, the state government has now proposed a “well-conceived” Rs 1.2 lakh crore (one lakh twenty thousand crore) package to the Modi government.
“We are hopeful something will come now. We have given a proposal which talks about specifics — in terms of what needs to be spent on roads, previous liabilities and infrastructure. It is a plan which will be executed over the next three to four years,” Parra adds.
But cabinet minister Altaf Bukhari, who also belongs to the PDP, is not sure when the money will come. “There might be an announcement but we do not know when,” he says.Economy sinking
A girl being rescued by locals. HT File Photo
Bakal says the Valley’s economy is sinking after two back-to-back years of poor business.
“People are not buying things but selling gold to repair homes. The tourism sector has been badly hit. Traders are in for double whammy. The banks are breathing through our necks for paying interest on loans and insurance companies are delaying payments. Most small traders had no insurance cover,” adds Bakal.
The federation also alleges that the cheques given to some traders at a function in Srinagar went to those affiliated to the PDP.
Kashmir residents looking for a safer place during 2014 floods . (AFP Photo)
Many Kashmiris have been refusing the cheques of the state government, calling the amount “paltry and an insult”. Nazir Ahmad Shah, a resident of a mixed Hindu-Muslim neighbourhood on the exchange road in Lal Chowk, says he returned the Rs 3,800 relief he got for his three-storey heritage house.
“The market value of my house is worth crores. Not even a door can be made with Rs 3,800,” says an angry Shah.
Army cautious about celebrating
Amid the anger, the defence forces of the country which had led the flood rescue and relief operations from the front, are observing a muted anniversary of Operation Megh Rahat.
“The over publicity of our efforts both in Kashmir and Nepal backfired. We are now cautious and do not want to highlight the Operation,” sources in Army said. For now, a coffee table book on what the army did and a video on Operation Megh Rahat is all that it has to showcase besides a new gallery dedicated to the operation in its museum at Badami Bagh Cantonment area.