‘Super’ ministers may disrupt power balance, say experts

  • Prashant Jha, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
  • Updated: May 27, 2014 01:34 IST
Supporters-attend-Narendra-Modi-s-rally-at-Kothi-Meena-Bazar-ground-in-Agra-Uttar-Pradesh-HT-Photo

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s decision to merge ministries to make it more ‘organic’, and increase coordination between different departments could enable faster decision-making and lead to efficiency.

But according to informed observers, it runs the risk of centralizing power, making the bureaucracy excessively powerful and disrupting the ‘balance’ between different interests in governance.

In a statement on Sunday night, Modi’s office explained the rationale of his decision, and said it was in line with his policy of ‘maximum governance, minimum government’.

One cabinet minister would head a cluster of ministries working in complementary sectors, top layers of government would be downsized, and the focus would be on ‘integrated and inter-connected nature’ of governance.

Shekhar Singh, who has lectured civil servants for close to two decades, saw Modi’s move as an attempt to replicate state-model of governance — where the CM is all powerful and ministries fall in line — at the centre — where decisions have traditionally been arrived at after internal tensions between different ministries.

“In the short-term, it will enable swift decisions, but in the medium and long-term, it removes the balance that comes from internal friction, which is necessary for a complex and diverse economy and society.”

Singh added that given the weak status Ministers of State enjoy, and the increased burden on the shoulders of a few cabinet ministers, this will result in the increased power of bureaucrats. “And finally, if ministries with contradictory interests are lumped together, the dominant economic and infrastructure-related ministries will prevail. The weaker ministries like environment and social justice will get washed away.”

Partha Mukhopadhyay, a senior fellow at the Centre for Policy Research, believes the idea of mega-ministries may have come as a reaction to the perception that there wasn’t enough governance in the UPA regime.

“Certain ministries are related to transport — be it roads or shipping or railways or civil aviation — but they all have different regulatory and policy challenges.”

On the other hand, a Ministry of Urban Development and Panchayati Raj could be subsumed under a Ministry of Local Government.

The key, Mukhopadhyay suggested, is running a ‘well-coordinated government’.

From Around the Web
Sponsored by Revcontent

also read

Mandsaur: Women allege assault over beef was at Bajrang Dal’s behest, 4 held
Show comments

Steps to disable Ad Blocker on your browser


In order to serve content on our website, we rely on advertising revenue which helps us to ensure that we continue to serve high quality unbiased journalism. From our end, we will aim to show clean and unobtrusive ads to provide you with a great browsing experience.

Request to please follow the steps below and once done, please refresh your page.


For Chrome and Ad BlockPlus users

1.Press the ‘ABP’ icon in your toolbar at top right of this page

2. Click on ‘Enabled on this site’; this should now change to ‘Disabled on this site’


chrome



For Chrome and Ad Block users

1.Press the ‘AdBlock’ icon in your toolbar

2.Select the option ‘Don’t run on pages on this domain’ and then click ‘exclude’ on the pop up


chrome

Steps to disable Ad Blocker on your browser


In order to serve content on our website, we rely on advertising revenue which helps us to ensure that we continue to serve high quality unbiased journalism. From our end, we will aim to show clean and unobtrusive ads to provide you with a great browsing experience.

Request to please follow the steps below and once done, please refresh your page.


For Mozilla and AdBlock Plus (ABP) users

1.Press the ‘ABP’ icon in your toolbar

2.Select the option ‘Disable on hindustantimes.com’


chrome

Steps to disable Ad Blocker on your browser


In order to serve content on our website, we rely on advertising revenue which helps us to ensure that we continue to serve high quality unbiased journalism. From our end, we will aim to show clean and unobtrusive ads to provide you with a great browsing experience.

Request to please follow the steps below and once done, please refresh your page.


For Internet Explorer and AdBlock Plus users

1.Press the ‘AdBlock Plus’ icon in your status bar at the bottom of the screen

2.Select the option ‘Disable on hindustantimes.com’


chrome

Steps to disable Ad Blocker on your browser


In order to serve content on our website, we rely on advertising revenue which helps us to ensure that we continue to serve high quality unbiased journalism. From our end, we will aim to show clean and unobtrusive ads to provide you with a great browsing experience.

Request to please follow the steps below and once done, please refresh your page.


For Safari and AdBlock users

1.Press the ‘AdBlock’ icon in your toolbar

2.Select the option ‘Don't run pages on this domain’ and then click 'exclude'


chrome