Quitting Olympics an ‘overreaction’: Zika experts on McIlroy’s Rio pullout

  • AFP, Paris
  • Updated: Jun 23, 2016 02:52 IST
Rory McIlroy became the latest athlete to withdraw from the Rio Olympics over fears about the Zika virus. (AFP Photo)

Only pregnant women and people planning a family need fear Zika, disease experts said on Wednesday after golfer Rory McIlroy became the latest athlete to withdraw from the Rio Olympics over virus fears.

The mosquito-borne virus, which can also be transmitted via sex, is thought to cause a form of severe brain damage, called microcephaly, in babies.

It has also been linked to rare adult-onset neurological problems such as Guillain-Barre Syndrome, which can result in paralysis and death.

Read | Golfer Rory McIlroy withdraws from Rio Olympics over Zika virus threat

Should Rio-bound Olympians and sports fans be concerned? We asked the experts.

Who needs to be concerned about Zika?

Women who are pregnant or planning a baby imminently, as the virus targets the foetus in the womb, said Cardiff University infectious diseases expert Andrew Freedman.

Men who contract the virus in Brazil can pass it on to their partners through sex, so would need to use condoms for several months after their return.

Unless McIlroy and his wife were planning a baby, “I feel the decision to withdraw from the Games is an overreaction,” said Freedman.

Is there a risk to the athletes themselves?

In most people, the Zika virus causes mild disease -- many never even notice the symptoms. Those who do fall ill, usually with a rash and flu-like symptoms, recover within days.

“Rarely, complications such as Guillain-Barre syndrome may occur,” said Jimmy Whitworth, a professor of international public health at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine.

But he called for “perspective”.

“The most credible estimates suggest no more than 10-20 infections with Zika among the half a million athletes and visitors going to Brazil for the Olympics.”

The World Health Organisation said last week there was a “very low risk” of Zika spreading further internationally as a result of the Games.

Olympics host Brazil has seen 1.5 million people infected, and nearly 1,300 babies born with abnormally small heads and brains since the outbreak started last year.

What precautions can be taken?

For most people, the main thing is to protect oneself against mosquito bites by covering up and using a good insect repellent, said the experts.

But pregnant women should not travel to Rio at all.

Those considering a baby, who do not fall ill, should delay conception for two months after their return as a precaution, said Whitworth.

“In the unlikely event of a woman or her partner getting infected with Zika, they should delay pregnancy for six months, by which time all traces of Zika infection will have been cleared from the body.”

Is the decision to withdraw scientifically sound?

A: The chances of contracting Zika on a golf course are very low, said Whitworth, as infecting mosquitoes live mostly around houses and rarely venture more than 50 metres (160 feet) from their breeding sites.

“Obviously I don’t know the reasons for this (McIlroy’s) decision, but it does strike me as being extreme,” added virology professor Jonathan Ball of the University of Nottingham.

But Peter Barlow, an infection expert at Edinburgh Napier University, said the long-term effects of Zika are poorly understood.

“It is completely understandable that an elite athlete such as Rory McIlroy is putting his own and his family’s health first in this instance, particularly if he has plans to start a family in the near future.”

also read

The forgotten story of kabaddi’s tryst with Hitler, the Olympics
Show comments