HindustanTimes Fri,31 Oct 2014

PGI doctors publish study on ‘effectiveness’ of defunct unit

Vishav Bharti, Hindustan Times  Chandigarh, July 28, 2014
First Published: 10:54 IST(28/7/2014) | Last Updated: 10:59 IST(28/7/2014)

A study in how to doctor a research report and get it published. A team of doctors at the Pharmacology department of the Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER), Chandigarh, published a study, ostensibly conducted in 2013, on the effectiveness of a wing in their department, at a time when the institute was actually lying defunct.

What’s worse, Delhi-based Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research also thought it fit to publish the study.

Two resident doctors, Dr Pugazhenthan Thangaraju, Dr Harmanjit Singh and professor and head of the PGI’s department of pharmacology Dr Amitava Chakrvarty published a short study titled ‘Short communication: Drug Information Unit as an effective tool for promoting rational drug use’.

The study was apparently based on the number of calls received at Drug Information Unit (DIU), a wing at the pharmacology department that answers queries of doctors over phone on whether the drugs they prescribe could have an adverse reaction on patients. The study claimed that a junior resident doctor manning the DIU received 56 calls a month, and also listed the department-wise number of calls.

Information available with HT shows that the DIU had been defunct since the retirement of former head of the pharmacology department, Dr P Pandhi, in 2012.
The phone connection designated for the office had not been functioning for more than a year and was revived only in May this year, when Dr Arvind Rajwanshi, the cytology (study of cells) department head, was given additional charge of the department.

“When I took over as head of the department, I directed that the system be revived,” said Dr Rajwanshi. Since the revival of the DIU, it has been getting 8-10 calls a month. The corresponding author of the study, Dr Harmanjit Singh, could not be contacted as he did not take calls.

comment Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of
blog comments powered by Disqus
more from Chandigarh

New Delhi, 1984. New York, 2014.

In my parent’s bedroom is a framed photo that seems a bit out of place. The small image has an aged yellow tint and displays my father at the young age of 24, standing proudly atop the GB Pant Hospital in New Delhi, India. He looks just as I do now. Tall, skinny, his not-yet full beard kept neatly on the sides of his jaw as he sports a clean pair of glasses and a neat turban matching his shirt. That year (1984), my father was in his medical residency pursuing a specialty in anesthesiology. His eyes shine of dreams of the success that would come from his hard work in the future. However, what could not be captured in the photograph is what my father had seen in that year, 1984. Writes Manmeet Singh Gujral
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved