Advertisement

HindustanTimes Sat,27 Dec 2014
Draping elephant statues based on weak reasoning
Varghese K George, Hindustan Times
New Delhi, January 12, 2012
First Published: 00:50 IST(12/1/2012)
Last Updated: 11:40 IST(12/1/2012)

Searching for, and covering all elephant statues that have been built at “government expense” must have been an unprecedented task for officials in Uttar Pradesh.

The Election Commission’s (EC) directive followed its conclusion that such statues built at “government expense” cannot be allowed to “influence the minds of the electors, disturbing the level playing field.” It said the decision was “in the interest of free and fair election,” and ordered them all draped.

The order borders on what the Madras high court had once warned against —“hysterically giving vent to its own assumed, unlimited statute and powers”—if one examines its assumptions and implications.

In October 2010, the EC rejected pleas for disqualifying Mayawati and Bahujan Samajwadi Party (BSP) from elections; and disallowing BSP to use elephant as election symbol. The petition said such statues of elephants and chief minister Mayawati constructed by the UP government would benefit the BSP. The EC then said expenditure by an elected government was not within the purview, more so when there was no election. While refusing to take away the elephant symbol from BSP, the commission promised to revisit the issue after announcing election and to ensure “level playing field.” On January 8, the EC ordered to cover all statues since they could “influence the minds of electors,” at “government expenses.”

All governments continuously try to influence the electors using various measures. In a comparable context, the Madras high court had observed: “if such a submission is accepted and taken to its logical end,  the  EC can  issue directive  disapproving  any of the policy decision of a particular government… on  the ground  that  ultimately where the election would be held… there may not be free and fair election as  the  opinion  of the public  may be swayed… We are not convinced.” 

Most government schemes are named in order to gain popularity, “to influence the mind of electors.” The Centre’s Jawaharlal Nehru Urban Renewal Mission or Vajpayee Aryogyasree Scheme for below poverty line (BPL) people by the Karnataka government are just two examples.

At a practical level, if the logic  that ‘influencing minds at government expense’, is extended, that too specifically linking it to one election symbol, it will lead to bizarre situations.  What happens to hand pumps (RLD symbol) built at government expense? What if a government official waves his ‘hand’—the Congress symbol? What happens to lotus (BJP symbol) in government-owned ponds? And do we also hide all those elephants in the zoos?

EC’s current order also draws from its own 2009 directive that is equally problematic. It said “photographs of political functionaries, who have deep influence on the minds of electors…” should be removed from government offices.

While it explicitly listed the images of those to be removed —prime minister, chief ministers, ministers and other political functionaries—the EC exempted “images of national leaders, and prominent historical personalities of the past.” Now, which category does Indira Gandhi or Kanshi Ram fall?

EC’s unflinching efforts to raise the rigour of its oversight of elections have multiplied common man’s faith in democracy in recent years. All the more the reason for the EC to guard against overreach.


comment Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of www.hindustantimes.com
blog comments powered by Disqus

Advertisement

YOUR STATE, YOUR SPEAK

Stop playing the caste card in elections

election campaign rally
Whenever there is election in the country, caste appears to the fore as a factor to inter-play in the whole electioneering.
Advertisement
hys

Do you think Samajwadi Party can live up to its promises in UP?

Samajwadi Party has claimed a majority in 403-member Uttar Pradesh assembly.

poll

Advertisement
Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved