Tabloid

Media access to images of semi-clad Justin Bieber blocked for now

  • Reuters, Miami
  • |
  • Updated: Feb 21, 2014 12:01 IST
  • Justin Bieber

    Baby hitmaker Justin Bieber is ready with his third album Believe. Its first single Boyfriend has got good reviews.

  • Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber's debut single, One Time, was released in 2009 and charted in the top thirty in several international markets.

  • Justin Bieber

    His debut album, the seven-track EP My World, followed in November 2009 and was soon certified platinum in the United States. He became the first ...

  • Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber's first full-length studio album, My World 2.0, was released in March 2010. It debuted at number one or within the top ten in ...

  • Justin Bieber

    It was preceded by the worldwide top-ten single, Baby. The music video of Baby is currently ranked as the most viewed and most discussed YouTube ...

  • Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber released his second studio album, Under the Mistletoe in November 2011, which debuted at number one on the Billboard 200.

  • Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber has received Artist of the Year award at the 2010 American Music Awards and has been nominated for Best New Artist and Best ...

  • Justin Bieber

    In late 2011, Justin Bieber began recording his third studio album, Believe. The album will also feature Kanye West and Drake.

  • Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez

A Miami judge on Thursday temporarily blocked media access to any more video images of a semi-clad Justin Bieber filmed while the teenage pop singer was in police custody last month after his arrest for driving under the influence.

The police station footage included clips of Bieber giving a urine sample behind a low wall.

Miami-Dade County judge William Altfield ordered that about 10 hours of police surveillance video not be released until he has been able to review them in his chambers.

"Do you believe that the public has the right to see Justin Bieber urinating?" the judge asked attorneys representing several large media companies seeking access to the video under Florida's broad public records law.

"I don't think the public has a right to see his penis," replied Scott Ponce, an attorney for the Miami Herald and CBS.

"I believe the public has a right to see him standing behind a wall doing what we know is urinating," he added, noting that Bieber's urine test was part of the evidence in the DUI case.


One of the 'naked' pictures which were tweeted by Justin Bieber. Media companies are citing images like this to press their case

At issue are four short clips of Bieber urinating at the police station.
If Bieber's genitalia are visible in the videos, authorities should release the clips after blacking out his private parts, he argued.

Attorneys representing Bieber disagreed.

"I find the argument to be insulting and demeaning of the court... to just fuzz out the private parts," replied Howard Srebnick, one of Bieber's attorneys.

Judge Altfield said he would review the video and announce his decision at a March 4 hearing. He also postponed Bieber's March 3 DUI trial until March 17.

Bieber, 19, was charged with driving under the influence, resisting arrest and using an expired license after Miami Beach police say they caught him drag racing on January 23. He has pleaded not guilty to the charges and did not attend the hearing on Thursday.

Besides a small amount of alcohol, he had marijuana and prescription medication for anxiety in his system at the time of his arrest, according to the state attorney's office.

One video showing Bieber being patted down by a Miami Beach police officer was released to the media in early February, prompting his attorneys to file a motion to prevent any more such images from being released.

"While in custody at the Miami Beach police station, the defendant was captured on videotape in various states of undress which show intimate personal parts of the defendant's body," according to the motion filed earlier this month in Miami-Dade County Court.

The motion said the Florida constitution and state law protected such images from being publicly disclosed. Releasing video from Bieber's brief time in custody would cause "irreparable harm," the teen's lawyers say.

Attorneys for several major media companies, including CNN, the Orlando Sentinel and the Associated Press, deny Bieber has the right to privacy under Florida's Public Records Act, according to court documents.

Under Florida law, all evidence including photos and videos became public record once they are handed to the defense.

"Florida courts have long recognised that government records are presumptively open, and that the Public Records Act is to be construed liberally in favor of access," Deanna Shullman, an attorney representing the media, said in court documents.

Florida courts "reject the notion that simply alleging embarrassment alone is sufficient grounds to trump Public Records Act disclosure mandates," Shullman wrote.

Herald and CBS attorney Ponce pointed to Bieber's own website, which he said included a photo of Bieber urinating and exposing his bare behind, as well as another image of the performer urinating in a mop bucket at a New York restaurant.

Bieber, whose private life has taken a seemingly tumultuous turn in the past year, was also charged last week with assaulting a limousine driver in Toronto in December.

 

also read

Just in trouble: All that you need to know about Justin Bieber

blog comments powered by Disqus