HindustanTimes Thu,25 Dec 2014

Social Media

China's Weibo poses danger for new leaders
November 01, 2012
First Published: 12:49 IST(1/11/2012)
Last Updated: 12:50 IST(2/11/2012)
The logo of Sina Corp's Chinese microblog website ''Weibo'' is seen on a screen in this photo illustration taken in Beijing. Credit: Reuters/Stringer

As China prepares for a generational power shift in the next two weeks, a similar shift is happening online that is testing the limits and displaying the evolution of China's legions of state-directed censors.

Since its launch three years ago, Weibo, China's version of Twitter, has become the country's water cooler, a place where nearly 300 million Internet users opine on everything from Korean soap operas to China's latest political intrigue.

It has posed a unique challenge for Chinese Communist Party leaders whose overarching goal is to maintain tight political and social control, while at the same time wanting to give their citizens a conduit to blow off steam.

"One of the key challenges for the new leadership will be whether they can establish credibility through new governing mechanisms," said Tony Saich, a professor of international affairs at Harvard Kennedy School in Massachusetts.

"How are they going to deal with a wired, globally connected, urban middle class that is probably less likely over time to be treated like children?"

Part of the solution is also the problem: Weibo.

Last Friday, senior officials from China's Jiangxi province triggered an avalanche of online criticism when they showed up hours late for a commercial flight from Guangzhou. The other passengers were convinced the plane was delayed simply to accommodate the officials, and they were furious.

Government censors let the online anger flow, and the incident was typical of the Weibo exposes that have often revealed details of low level officials' wealth, corruption or abuse of power.

Yet that same day, the New York Times ran a lengthy article on Premier Wen Jiabao family's wealth, which lit up Twitter internationally but hardly made it on to Weibo. All references to the article, direct and obscure, were quickly blocked.

By letting certain types of party criticism flourish on Weibo and even become "trending topics" while censoring even obscure references to others, Chinese authorities have tried to create an illusion of a rowdy online public square.

"Everything going on online, including Weibo, is not happening randomly. It is very much part of a plan," said a China-based American who goes by the alias Martin Johnson. Johnson founded and, websites that monitor China Internet censorship.

"The reason why Weibo exists is because the party allowed it to. The party thinks it can use Weibo to its advantage."

Clocking the watch

A microblogger who goes by the name Huazong has become the so called "watch watchdog" on Weibo. Since July 2011, he has collected photos of officials who wear expensive wristwatches despite earning relatively modest government salaries and posted them online.

Huazong's latest victim is a safety official from the northern Shaanxi province, Yang Dacai, who was removed from his position in September after Weibo users dug up photos and counted more than 10 luxury watches sitting on his wrist on different occasions.

"I have exposed dozens of officials' watches before and haven't gotten any direct threats," Huazong told Reuters TV.

"Some officials have asked why I am doing this and I tell them it is to promote the establishment of an officials' property declaration system," he said.

The freedom Weibo users have to excavate dirt on provincial and county-level officials stands in stark contrast to the muzzle they wear when wanting to discuss the nation's top leaders, whose names, nicknames and weird permutations of their names are blocked on the website.

"In China you can criticise and conduct investigative reports on officials who are lower than the county level, but you cannot criticise the top leaders," said Zhang Zhian, a journalism professor Guangzhou's Sun Yat-sen University.

Part of the reason for the dichotomy is rooted in the geography of power in China: edicts on what to censor are issued from the central government in Beijing. This means provincial officials have less say over what gets cut from China's boisterous Weibo.

"If a party secretary is criticized, it is hard for them to go all the way to Beijing and say 'please delete everything on Weibo about me'," said Xiao Qiang, an adjunct professor at UC Berkeley who founded news website China Digital Times that keeps an updated list of banned words on Weibo.

"If it is just local and does not implicate someone higher up...(the censors) often will let it go. On the other hand, they do make very swift judgments on information they see as challenging the legitimacy of the party," Xiao said.

The censorship, most analysts say, doesn't appear to bother the average Weibo user very much. Industry data has shown that the majority of users on the platform use it for entertainment and not for political or social activism.

"Do I think the Chinese are turned off by the censorship on Weibo? No," said Michael Clendenin, founder of technology consultancy RedTech Advisors. "The average Chinese person is not naive. They know what is happening and choose to participate."

Are you ready for sparta?

Even though discussion of top political leaders and the taboo Ts - Tiananmen, Taiwan and Tibet - are removed from Weibo, debate about political issues exists in code on the platform, making China's Internet freer than before.

While references to the once-in-a-decade political transition, which begins on November 8, are strictly monitored, Internet surfers trying to elude government censors use code words, like "sparta", which has become shorthand for the upcoming Party Congress. Sparta in Mandarin, "si ba da", sounds like the colloquial reference to the 18th party congress, "shi ba da", which is censored on Weibo.

"My Internet speed is becoming slower and slower, is this because of the approaching 'sparta' or is it the end of the world," said one Weibo user. It is common for Beijing to increase Internet monitoring in the lead-up to marquee political events, experts said, often causing Internet speeds to slow significantly.

The continuous cat-and-mouse game, some Internet industry executives say, is actually vital to the stability and development of China, because it gives the Communist Party real-time feedback on policies and a method to take stock of the public mood.

"Social media cannot be said to be 'tightly controlled'," said one high-level Chinese Internet executive, who declined to be named due to the sensitivity of the topic. "It is infinitely more open than the Internet, which is infinitely more open than print media. 'Tightly controlled' may be used only if you are comparing against democratic countries."

When a significantly freer Internet in China will come about is anyone's guess, but most industry experts interviewed expect some loosening after the Party Congress.

That loosening, should it come, will be for an overtly political reason, analysts believe: at the outset of its tenure, the new leadership may want to project an image of being more open to political reform, including freer speech, than the old guard.

Weibo users, in turn, are certain to quickly test just how much freedom the new leadership is willing to tolerate.

comment Note: By posting your comments here you agree to the terms and conditions of
blog comments powered by Disqus
Bharat Ratna for Atal Bihari Vajpayee: Take a quick look at his political journey
Former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee and educationist Madan Mohan Malviya were on Wednesday chosen for the country's highest civilian award Bharat Ratna. The saffron icon started off as the political secretary of Shyama Prasad Mookherjee, the founder of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh before becoming the eleventh Prime Minister of India, first for 13 days in 1996 and then from 1998 to 2004.

Vajpayee remained a member of parliament for 47 years, elected 11 times to the Lok Sabha, and twice to the Rajya Sabha. Here's a look at his extraordinary politial journey.

Omar Abdullah post-resigning: Waiting to see what alliances emerge in J&K
Omar Abdullah met Jammu & Kashmir Governor Narinder Nath Vohra and submitted his resignation from the post of chief minister of the state on Wednesday. He said that he submitted his resignation accepting people’s verdict in the assembly elections. Abdullah said that he is waiting to see what other combinations of political parties emerge from this Assembly election, although he refuted claims of any talks with other parties for a coalition government.

Further, he said that it is not the responsibility of National Conference to take responsibility of who forms the government in the state.

Anurag Kashyap: Ugly enjoys a big advantage, thanks to PK
Anurag Kashyap talks about why his upcoming film 'Ugly' has a big advantage because of PK. He reflects on how the films story came about through his personal struggles from being a father. Talking about India being a country of easily offended people he talks of the struggle filmmakers face due to that and the  Censor board of India.
Assam attack: Govt is taking this threat very seriously, says CM Tarun Gogoi
Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi, speaking over the Bodo militant attack, on Wednesday said that the Government of India is taking the attack very seriously. He added that the Centre is providing the state with necessary assistance. He further stated that the target of such an attack is to spread disturbance in Assam and the government will make efforts to curb these threats.
Assam: Bodo militants gun down at least 50 adivasis, curfew imposed
Bodo militants gunned down at least 50 adivasis and injured several others in orchestrated attacks across the Sonitpur and Kokrajhar districts of Assam on Tuesday evening, the police said. The attackers belonged to the anti-talks National Democratic Front of Bodoland (Songbijit) faction. All the victims were adivasis, who along with migrant Muslims have been the target of sectarian violence in areas sought under the Bodo tribal rule.

Following the attacks, several adivasi organisations called for a shutdown on Wednesday. Adivasis, categorized as ‘tea tribe’ in Assam, were brought by the British from central India to work as tea plantation workers more than 150 years ago.

Sony pictures confirms limited release of 'The Interview' for Christmas
"The Interview" was put back into theaters Tuesday when Sony Pictures Entertainment announced a limited Christmas Day theatrical release for the comedy that provoked an international incident with North Korea. For Sony, the decision was the culmination of a gradual about-face: After initially saying it had no plans to release the movie, the company began softening its position after it was broadly criticized.

Sony Entertainment CEO Michael Lynton that Seth Rogen's North Korea farce "will be in a number of theaters" beginning Thursday. He said Sony also is continuing its efforts to release the film on more platforms and in more theaters.

Elections Special: Three generations of Kashmir on politics and aspirations


Three generations from Kashmir voice out their experiences with the Indian military, lost dreams and hopes for the future. The video also demonstrates how the troubled state of politics in Jammu and Kashmir has impacted the citizens. But, their resolution for a better future has kept them strong in these times of turmoil.

The nature of problems has also changed through the years, as the youngest generation speaks on issues like unemployment and development taking centre stage for the Kashmiri youth. These voices help understand the issues that are considered important to the voter in Jammu and Kashmir. The results for the assembly elections, that have been announced today, indicate a hung assembly for the valley.

Sanjay Dutt granted 14-day furlough by Yerwada Jail
Actor Sanjay Dutt, who is currently serving a sentence in Pune's Yerawada jail after being convicted for illegal possession of arms in the 1993 serial blasts case, was granted a 14-day furlough on Dec 23.

"Around two months ago, the actor had applied for furlough. We have sent the application with the required recommendations to the office of the DIG (prisons). Dutt had taken furlough around a year ago and is eligible for the same this year too," a prison official told HT in the first week of December. The 14-day furlough can be extended by two weeks, officials added.

Caught on camera: Two bike-borne youth throw acid on woman doctor in Delhi
Two unidentified bike-borne assailants threw acid on a 30-year-old woman doctor on Tuesday morning in West Delhi's Rajouri Garden area. According to the police, the incident took place around 9:30am in Rajouri Garden market when the woman had left home and was on her way to a hospital in the same area where she worked.

The attackers have not been identified so far and efforts are on to trace them. Police has registered a case in this regard and CCTV footage of the area is being scanned to identify the attackers. Investigators also questioning her friends and colleagues to determine whether she had any personal enmity or somebody held a grudge against her.

Amit Shah: BJP set to form govt in Jharkhand, all options are open in J&K
BJP Chief Amit Shah congratulated party workers after the party made gains in the Jharkhand and J&K assembly polls. He stated that BJP has achieved a comprehensive victory in Jharkhand and is all set to form a stable government in the state. As far as Jammu and Kashmir is concerned, he said the election results prove that BJP is a relevant player in J&K and that all options are open to form a popular government.

Amit Shah also stated that voters had rejected Congress, and BJP is on its way to realise the dream of Congress-free India.

J&K results: Mehbooba Mufti says mandate below expectations, will take time to form govt
The results for Jammu and Kashmir assembly elections appeared to be pointing towards a hung assembly with PDP emerging as the single largest party which won in 24 seats is leading in 4. Speaking on the occasion, PDP chief Mehbooba Mufti said they are not completely satisfied with the mandate and will will continue exploring possibilities before forming a government. "We are not in a hurry to cobble up numbers. Will explore possibilities to give a credible govt," said Mehbooba.

Meanwhile, BJP also made gains by winning 25 seats and was ahead on 2, all in Jammu. However, BJP failed to make inroads in the Valley.

BJP set to form govt in Jharkhand, celebrations begin
Massive celebrations began in Jharkhand as it became clear that the Bharatiya Janata Party will be a major gainer in JMM-ruled Jharkhand shortly after the counting of votes polled in assembly polls began on Tuesday. The trends clearly show that the BJP is heading towards absolute majority in the state.

Meanwhile, reacting over the victory, BJP leaders said that People have voted in Jharkhand against violence and voted for good governance.

#BoycottPK: Shiv Sena seek ban on Aamir Khan's latest, says it hurts Hindu sentiments
Shiv Sena held a protest to demand ban for Bollywood actor Aamir Khan's newly released film 'PK', saying it hurts the sentiments of Hindu community by mocking gods. A member of Shiv Sena, Rajeev Tandon while protesting in Ludhiana city of Punjab, said Hindu organisations want the movie to be banned from playing in theatres.

Bollywood filmmaker Rajkumar Hirani's 'PK' presents a social cause that has recently been doing the rounds - religion and the commercialisation of it. Meanwhile, lawyer Ranjana Agnihotri who also filed public interest litigation (PIL) against the film, said the filmmakers have hurt the sentiments of the Hindu community.

Kashmir Elections: How the floods in Kashmir will affect my vote
Jammu and Kashmir battled the worst floods in 60 years, just three months ago. And now, they face a difficult task of electing their new government, as the Jammu & Kashmir Assembly Elections enters its final leg. But, these flood victims are still writ with anger as they blame the administration for turning a blind eye towards them.

Their helplessness and lack of interest in these elections is evident through these stories that emerge after three months from the Kashmir Capital, Srinagar.

Arvind Kejriwal: Promise not to resign as chief minister again, if elected
Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) Chief Arvind Kejriwal said he would not resign as chief minister of Delhi, if elected to power, as he had done earlier this year. Hitting out at ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), Kejriwal said that the party failed to fulfill the promises it made during parliamentary polls in April-May. The elections are likely to be held early next year as no party is in position to form the government.
Forgotten victims of 2004 Tsunami: Mother finds daughter's body after 10 years
Ten years after the catastrophic 2004 Asian tsunami, a mother in Myanmar is living the pain a second time. She recently found out that her daughter's body - which she thought was lost at sea - has lain unclaimed for years in a Thailand grave. And not just her, more than 400 unclaimed bodies awaiting loved ones who never came. These are the lost, the forgotten victims for whom the past has not been laid to rest.

In Myanmar, even though Aye Pu is too poor to bring her daughter's body back to her homeland, she hopes to arrange a cremation and Buddhist rites in Thailand. She says, "The healing can finally begin."

Baby elephant gets separated from herd, goes on attacking spree
Five elephants fell into the well while out grazing in the Sansol village near the Simlipal Jungle of Mayurbhanj district. Four of them managed to leave after being rescued, but one baby elephant was left behind. The villagers then rescued the baby elephant from a paddy field after he was separated from its herd.

People were also seen clicking selfies and group photographs with the baby elephant, while the young one was in search of its herd. The baby elephant is now under treatment and responding well.

Sarita Devi reacts: Happy that I can participate in Olympics, thank Sachin Tendulkar for support
Boxer Sarita Devi thanked the Sports Minister, Boxing India, SAI, Sachin Tendulkar and the entire nation for supporting her. Even as the International Boxing Federation AIBA has imposed one year ban on Sarita as she refused to accept her bronze medal in the Asian Games which took place in Incheon this year, the boxer expressed happiness that she would get a chance to participate in the Olympics.

Sarita will be eligible to return to action by November 2015, in time for the women's Olympic qualifiers for the Rio Games in 2016. The world boxing body also handed down two-year bans, ending Oct 1, 2016 to the 29-year-old boxer's husband Thoiba Singh.

Peshawar attack aftermath: Devastation inside school reveals shocking tales
The full devastation of a Taliban attack on a Pakistani school that left 142 people, mostly children, dead was revealed on Wednesday.Walls inside the Peshawar school were pockmarked with bullet holes while the floors were streaked with blood. Torn notebooks, pieces of clothing and children's shoes were scattered about. After the attackers entered the school, they made their way into the main auditorium where many students had gathered for an event, military spokesman Major General Asim Bajwa told reporters during a media tour of the school.

The militants then made their way to the auditorium's stage and started shooting at random. As students tried to flee for the doors, they were gunned down. Overnight, the body of the school principal, Tahira Qazi, was also found among the debris from the rampage.

Exclusive: Prasoon Joshi pays a moving tribute to Peshawar victims through this poem
Noted lyricist Prasoon Joshi has penned a poem exclusively for Hindustan Times to pay homage to the Peshawar massacre victims. He has also done a rendition of the poem in his voice.

Taliban attacked a school in the Pakistani city of Peshawar, which killed 132 students and nine staff members. The attack took place on Tuesday when Taliban gunmen broke into a military-run high school attended by more than 1,100 people, many of them children of army personnel, and opened fire witnesses said.

more »

Top Stories

Copyright © 2014 HT Media Limited. All Rights Reserved