How can govt justify taxing EPF when corporates get huge exemptions? | union-budget | Hindustan Times
Today in New Delhi, India
Feb 26, 2017-Sunday
-°C
New Delhi
  • Humidity
    -
  • Wind
    -

How can govt justify taxing EPF when corporates get huge exemptions?

union budget Updated: Mar 02, 2016 09:00 IST
AK Padmanabhan
AK Padmanabhan
Hindustan Times
EPF

This government seems to have preconceived ideas against the provident fund (PF) and the employee’s security insurance (ESI) schemes. These are the very schemes that the government of India, until now, used to put before the whole world as exemplary social security schemes for workers.

This government seems to have preconceived ideas against the provident fund (PF) and the employee’s security insurance (ESI) schemes. These are the very schemes that the government of India, until now, used to put before the whole world as exemplary social security schemes for workers.

Read more: Jaitley’s proposal to tax EPF is wrong, morally and in principle

In last year’s budget, finance minister Arun Jaitley announced that the government wanted to give options to provident fund subscribers to move into the national pension scheme (NPS). He also said people insured under the ESI scheme would have the option to shift to other insurance schemes available in the market.

This was opposed by workers and all central trade unions protested against the proposals as well, and, till today, the government has not been able to implement the schemes.

Read more: After backlash, govt hints at rollback of tax on EPF withdrawals

The finance minister has now come out with a proposal to tax 60% of the corpus of the PF at the time of withdrawal.

This, according to the government, is being done to put the PF scheme on par with the NPS and other pension plans.

This is purely unjust and unwarranted.

Read more: Mr Jaitley, taxing retirals is betrayal of middle class

These savings of industrial workers are being actively utilised by the gover nment in development activities as a large chunk of the corpus is deposited in government securities.

And, it is also a fact that at least some of the workers are under the income tax net.

The government needs to withdraw the announcement made in the budget immediately.

Read more: #epfnotax: Petition to withdraw EPF tax gets 4,631 signatures on day 1

I don’t want to go into what the revenue secretary said on Tuesday — that 60% of the interest earned on the PF amount will be taxed and not the principle amount; he is confusing people.

The finance minister needs to make an unequivocal statement a g ainst his decision to put speculation to rest.

Poor workers are being taxed by a government that is giving huge exemptions to corporates in the country. It is also announcing lakhs of crores of rupees as foregone tax.

In such a scenario, how can the gover nment justify its move?

(The author is the President of Citu. Views expressed are personal)