Pilgrims blame poor management for haj stampede, toll reaches 769
The death toll from the Thursday’s stampede in Mina near Mecca rose to 769 on Saturday while Saudi Arabia deployed large numbers of security reinforcements as pilgrims performed the final rituals of a haj marred by double tragedy.world Updated: Sep 27, 2015 09:09 IST
The death toll from the Thursday’s stampede in Mina near Mecca rose to 769 on Saturday while Saudi Arabia deployed large numbers of security reinforcements as pilgrims performed the final rituals of a haj marred by double tragedy.
The kingdom’s leaders have ordered an inquiry into the disaster -- the deadliest to strike the annual Muslim pilgrimage in a quarter-century -- and a “revision” of its organisation, with the deaths raising tensions with regional rival Iran as well.
Dozens of emergency workers were seen on one level of Jamarat Bridge, a five-storey structure in Mina where pilgrims ritually stone the devil, and on which hundreds of thousands were converging when Thursday’s stampede occurred nearby. Many more patrolled the network of roads leading to the structure, which resembles a parking garage.
The interior ministry has said it assigned 100,000 police to secure the haj and manage crowds. But pilgrims blamed the stampede on police road closures and poor management of the throng, during searing temperatures.
“People were trying to manoeuvre to the front for safety but police were saying ‘Go back! Go back!’,” said Nigerian Abbas Tijani, who escaped with injuries.
“Everybody was trying to survive,” he said from his hospital bed. “People were stepped on by people.”
In all, 769 people were killed and 934 others were wounded, according to health minister Khaled al-Falih.
Criticism has been particularly strident from Saudi Arabia’s regional rival Iran, 136 of whose nationals were among the dead.
“It is not only incompetence, but a crime,” Iranian Attorney General Ebrahim Raeisi said, while President Hassan Rouhani used an address to the United Nations on Saturday to call for an investigation.
Iranian foreign minister Mohammad Javad Zarif also took Riyadh to task, saying “unfortunately, we have not seen enough cooperation” up until now. Culture minister Ali Janati is to head a delegation to Saudi Arabia to follow up on 344 Iranians Tehran says are missing, but state news agency IRNA said his team still has not received visas.
Saudi Arabia firmly rejected Iran’s criticism on Saturday, saying the Islamic republic “shouldn’t play politics with a tragedy”.
“I would hope Iranian leaders would be more sensible and more thoughtful with regards to those who perished in this tragedy, and wait until we see the results of the investigation,” said foreign minister Adel al-Jubeir.
The disaster was the second deadly accident to mar the haj. A massive construction crane collapsed on the Grand Mosque in the nearby holy city of Mecca days beforehand, killing 109 people, many of them pilgrims.
Undeterred Saturday, pilgrims in Mina still flooded the area to perform the ritual stoning for a third time, on the last day of the haj which this year drew about two million people. They also stood in prayer.
Most began leaving on Saturday, returning to Mecca where many performed the tawaf -- where they circumambulate the Kaaba in the middle of the sacred site at the Grand Mosque -- watched on by heavy security.
‘Fate and destiny’
Abdullah al-Sheikh, chairman of the Shura Council, which advises the government, stressed that pilgrims must stick to “the rules and regulations taken by the security personnel”.
That echoed comments on Friday by health minister Falih, who faulted the worshippers for the tragedy, saying that if “the pilgrims had followed instructions, this type of accident could have been avoided”.
Saudi Arabia’s top religious leader, Sheikh Abdul Aziz al-Sheikh, told Crown Prince Mohammed bin Nayef that the incident was beyond human control. “You are not responsible for what happened,” official news agency SPA quoted Sheikh as telling him. “Fate and destiny are inevitable.”
Authorities have yet to provide a breakdown of the nationalities of pilgrims killed in the stampede, as the difficult process of identification continues.
Around 250 deaths in total have been officially confirmed by foreign officials, largely from African and Asian countries.
For years, the haj was marred by stampedes and fires, but it had been largely incident-free for nine years after safety improvements and billions of dollars worth of infrastructure investment.
The haj is one of the five pillars of Islam, and every able-bodied Muslim who can afford it is expected to perform it at least once in a lifetime.