Several electoral studies of voting behaviour show that there is no credible evidence for the idea of a monolithic Muslim vote bank.(Sunil Ghosh / Hindustan Times)
Several electoral studies of voting behaviour show that there is no credible evidence for the idea of a monolithic Muslim vote bank.(Sunil Ghosh / Hindustan Times)

Idea of Muslims as a monolithic vote bank helped BJP consolidate Hindu vote | Opinion

The idea of a monolithic Muslim vote bank must be discarded. It is time to recognise that Muslim voters, just like all other communities and castes, are more concerned about employment, price rise, corruption and other economic issues than they are about purely communal or caste identities.
By Jawid Laiq
UPDATED ON MAR 18, 2017 07:29 AM IST

A humble weaver of silk sarees in Varanasi, a wealthy exporter of Mirzapur carpets, a glass blower bursting his lungs in Firozabad, a leather tanner in Kanpur, a woman zari embroiderer slaving away for a pittance in Lucknow, a sugarcane farmer in Saharanpur, a burnisher of brass artefacts in Moradabad, an unemployed youth in Bahraich — may all be Muslims by birth but they are also individuals with independent political opinions, often unconnected with their religious identity. They are part of the vast and varied tapestry of the country’s highest populated state. This polyglot collection of individuals is far too often lumped together as a Muslim vote bank that unitedly goes to the polls to elect a pre-determined party or candidate.

Several electoral studies of voting behaviour, including a recent detailed analysis in the Economic and Political Weekly on ‘How Muslims Vote in Uttar Pradesh’, clearly show that the idea of a monolithic Muslim vote bank “is just a misguided opinion without any credible evidence”. Repeated opinion polls also show that Muslim voters, along with all other communities and castes, are more concerned about employment, price rise, corruption and other economic issues than they are about purely communal or caste identities. I can vouch for this, as during my recent electoral foray in UP, I found voters increasingly resentful about being asked about their caste or community identity. Such a question seemed to be disrespectful of their existence as individuals with distinct views.

Yet, all the major political parties in the UP election chose to either revile (BJP) or woo (BSP, Samajwadi-Congress) Muslims as an assumed vote bank. They specifically targeted the 73 constituencies where Muslims form over 30% of the electorate and another 70 constituencies where Muslims constitute 20% to 30%. In a state where Hindus form 79.7% of the population and Muslims 19.3%, according to the 2011 census; these political formations and the media have over-played the electoral role of Muslims.

With the election results on Saturday morning showing an overwhelming majority of seats going to the BJP out of the UP Assembly’s total of 403 seats, it has become apparent that Muslims have voted in a fragmented manner and not as a bloc. Mayawati’s BSP fielded 99 Muslim candidates and the Samajwadi Party 56 Muslim candidates in the election. This over-representation of Muslims has not only confused Muslim voters but also consolidated the Hindu vote in favour of the BJP, regardless of caste. As a result, only a handful of Muslims have been elected to the new UP Assembly while 69 Muslims MLAs were elected in 2012, the highest since the country’s independence.

In Kairana constituency, despite the consolidation of Hindu votes due to the widely believed false rumours that Hindus were being forcibly evicted from the area, the SP has won thanks to the 63% of Muslim voters.

The Muslims have clearly not voted for the BJP as they fear that party and the Sangh Parivar which has, since 2014, repeatedly made false accusations against Muslims on issues like love jihad, cow slaughter, forced conversion, forced migration of Hindus, etc. In return, the BJP has totally ignored Muslims and did not field a single Muslim candidate in the UP election. As for the BSP, despite its forceful push to get Muslim votes, the Samajwadi-Congress alliance has remained ahead of the BSP among Muslims.

Now that Prime Minister Modi has had a historic triumph in UP, it is about time he included Muslims in his “sabka sath sabka vikas” development programme, so that Muslims may vote for him in the 2019 national election.

Jawid Laiq is a political commentator who has been covering nationwide elections since 1977. The views expressed are personal.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Although the TMC and the BJP, the main contenders in the bi-polar election, have been planning to hold rallies at the Brigade Grounds in Kolkata, it is the Left that managed to organise the first one. (PHOTO: CPI(M)),
Although the TMC and the BJP, the main contenders in the bi-polar election, have been planning to hold rallies at the Brigade Grounds in Kolkata, it is the Left that managed to organise the first one. (PHOTO: CPI(M)),

CPI(M) holds coalition rally in Kolkata amid differences between allies

PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 10:59 PM IST
  • Traffic came to a halt in parts of Kolkata as more than 3,00,000 people attended the rally at Kolkata’s Brigade Parade Ground, the biggest open ground in the city and located in the sprawling Maidan.
Close
Supporters during Left-Congress and Indian Secular Front (ISF) joint rally, ahead of West Bengal assembly polls, at Brigade Parade Ground, in Kolkata,(PTI)
Supporters during Left-Congress and Indian Secular Front (ISF) joint rally, ahead of West Bengal assembly polls, at Brigade Parade Ground, in Kolkata,(PTI)

Brigade rally: Massive gathering at Left-Cong-ISF rally in Bengal | 10 points

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Nilavro Ghosh, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 08:17 PM IST
Supporters gathered by the lakhs to support the alliance. The introduction of the ISF has turned the election from a bi-partisan battle to a triangular face-off involving the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the ruling Trinamool Congress (TMC) and the Left-Congress-ISF alliance.
Close
Bodoland People’s Front president Hagrama Mohilary, Assam Congress president Ripun Bora and other members of the anti-BJP ‘grand alliance’ in Guwahati on Sunday. (HT PHOTO)
Bodoland People’s Front president Hagrama Mohilary, Assam Congress president Ripun Bora and other members of the anti-BJP ‘grand alliance’ in Guwahati on Sunday. (HT PHOTO)

BPF’s split with ally BJP in Assam may be a boost for Congress-led alliance

PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 07:26 PM IST
  • Relations between BJP and BPF soured in early 2020 when BTC, which was under the latter’s rule was placed under Governor’s rule at the end of the council’s five-year term as election couldn’t be held due to the Covid-19 pandemic and the prevailing restrictions.
Close
The ISF joining the Left-Congress alliance has given it an edge in the West Bengal election. (AP Photo/Bikas Das)(AP)
The ISF joining the Left-Congress alliance has given it an edge in the West Bengal election. (AP Photo/Bikas Das)(AP)

People will teach Mamata a lesson in assembly polls for her arrogance: ISF chief

PTI, Kolkata
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 06:15 PM IST
The ISF, floated by influential Muslim cleric of Hooghly district's Furfura Sharif last month, is against the politics of appeasement.
Close
In the southern state ahead of its Assembly elections, Rahul Gandhi earlier interacted with the professors at St Xavier’s College in Tirunelveli.(ANI)
In the southern state ahead of its Assembly elections, Rahul Gandhi earlier interacted with the professors at St Xavier’s College in Tirunelveli.(ANI)

Rahul Gandhi invokes K Kamaraj, talks about the kind of leader Tamil Nadu wants

Written by Prashasti Singh, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 05:46 PM IST
"Economists had said that mid-day meals would be a bad idea, but Kamaraj ji listened to the people and brought in the scheme. Tamil Nadu showed direction to India as the scheme was later introduced across the country. That's the kind of leader we want," he said while addressing a rally in Tenkasi.
Close
 Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan and CPI leader Binoy Viswam (left) during the coclusion of the southern leg of the LDF's Vikasana Munnetta Jataha in Thiruvananthapuram.(PTI)
Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan and CPI leader Binoy Viswam (left) during the coclusion of the southern leg of the LDF's Vikasana Munnetta Jataha in Thiruvananthapuram.(PTI)

Kerala polls: LDF releases its election campaign slogan

ANI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 05:12 PM IST
CPI (M) Kerala State secretary A Vijayaraghan handed over the tagline for the campaign to Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan in a function at the party headquarters.
Close
Chhattisgarh chief minister Bhupesh Baghel.(File photo)
Chhattisgarh chief minister Bhupesh Baghel.(File photo)

India needs to be saved from BJP, Bengal from TMC, says Chattisgarh CM

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 04:16 PM IST
"Both the BJP and TMC are trying to divide the people. The country has to be saved from one and Bengal has to be rescued from the other," he said, addressing the mega rally of the Left-Congress and newly-formed Indian Secular Front (ISF) at the Brigade Parade Ground.
Close
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said he counted on the people's support to defeat the BJP.(ANI Photo)
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said he counted on the people's support to defeat the BJP.(ANI Photo)

Rahul Gandhi dubs PM Modi a 'formidable enemy,' vows to defeat him

Posted by Prashasti Singh | PTI, Tirunelveli
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 04:11 PM IST
During an interaction titled 'Educators Meet' at the St Xavier College here, Gandhi, touring southern Tamil Nadu for the second day as part of his second leg of campaign for the April 6 assembly polls, also said he counted on the people's support to defeat the BJP.
Close
Nine companies have been deployed in Madurai and its adjoining areas following the announcement of the Assembly elections in Tamil Nadu.(ANI/ Representative photo)
Nine companies have been deployed in Madurai and its adjoining areas following the announcement of the Assembly elections in Tamil Nadu.(ANI/ Representative photo)

Tamil Nadu: First BSF contingent arrives in Madurai ahead of polls

ANI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 03:43 PM IST
The BSF personnel were taken for a Covid-19 test immediately after they arrived at the Madurai Railway Station from Assam. They were later sent in different groups to Tenkasi, Tuticorin and Nagercoil districts for election security.
Close
Babul Supriyo admitted that the post should not have gone from his official page, but said it was a trending meme. He did not create it.(PTI)
Babul Supriyo admitted that the post should not have gone from his official page, but said it was a trending meme. He did not create it.(PTI)

'I have two daughters': Babul Supriyo after backlash for 'sexist' post on Mamata

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 03:26 PM IST
Accepting that the post should not have been shared from his account, the BJP minister said he would not learn the definition of 'misogyny' from TMC, Left or the Congress.
Close
Bodoland People's Front (BPF) leader Pramila Rani Brahma (ANI)
Bodoland People's Front (BPF) leader Pramila Rani Brahma (ANI)

‘Insulted us a lot’: BPF hits out at Assam BJP leader, day after leaving NDA

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Karan Manral, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 02:24 PM IST
Bodoland People's Front leader Pramila Rani Brahma accused BJP’s Ranjit Das of ‘insulting us a lot.’ On Saturday, BPF chief Hagrama Mohilary announced that the party is leaving the NDA, and joining the Congress-led ‘Mahajath’ (grand alliance).
Close
Union home minister Amit Shah in Karaikal, Puducherry (ANI)
Union home minister Amit Shah in Karaikal, Puducherry (ANI)

‘A liar was made CM’: Amit Shah targets Narayanasamy, Cong in Puducherry

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Karan Manral, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 02:01 PM IST
The Union home minister also joined PM Narendra Modi and several central leaders in taking a jibe at Congress leader Rahul Gandhi over his comments on fisheries ministry.
Close
The elections in four states and a union territory will take place in April-May.(AFP File Photo)
The elections in four states and a union territory will take place in April-May.(AFP File Photo)

ABP-C-Voter opinion poll predicts edge for TMC in West Bengal

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 12:02 PM IST
The Election Commission announced Assembly election schedule a few days ago. West Bengal will see an eight-phased election.
Close
Madhya Pradesh chief minister Shivraj Singh Chauhan addresses a rally during his 'Jan Arashirvad Yatra' in Jabalpur on October 25.(PTI Photo)
Madhya Pradesh chief minister Shivraj Singh Chauhan addresses a rally during his 'Jan Arashirvad Yatra' in Jabalpur on October 25.(PTI Photo)

May 2 Didi Gayi, BJP Aayi: Shivraj Singh coins new slogan ahead of Bengal polls

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 11:13 AM IST
The BJP has expressed confidence it will gain a majority with over 200 seats in West Bengal.
Close
Elections are being held in 8,235 seats in local bodies in Gujarat. (PTI File photo )
Elections are being held in 8,235 seats in local bodies in Gujarat. (PTI File photo )

Voting underway for local bodies polls in Gujarat

PTI, Ahmedabad
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 10:21 AM IST
Elections are being held in 8,235 seats, where the BJP has fielded 8,161 candidates, the Congress-7,778, the Aam Aadmi Party-2,090, among others, said the SEC.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP