A worrisome slide in Army’s status

During the British regime, military officers were given their rightful place in the warrant of precedence in accordance with their length of service. This was primarily in recognition of the responsibility that they shouldered and for their innate accountability as also to inject pride into their profession.
By Col Pritam Bhullar (Retd)
UPDATED ON JUL 19, 2015 09:45 AM IST

During the British regime, military officers were given their rightful place in the warrant of precedence in accordance with their length of service. This was primarily in recognition of the responsibility that they shouldered and for their innate accountability as also to inject pride into their profession.

The perpetual fall in the status of the Army started after Partition in 1947 in Nehru era and was impregnated by the unreasonable fears of the Army staging a coup. The Army continues to be a victim of this inborn phobia.

At the time of Partition, the Commander-in-Chief was number two in the order of precedence; number one being the Viceroy. After the 1947-1948 war, service chiefs were made junior to judges of the Supreme Court. They were made junior to cabinet secretary after the 1962 war and junior to Attorney-General after the 1965 war.

After the 1971 war, they were made junior to Comptroller and Auditor General. Though the decorative rank of Field Marshal was created after the 1971 war, no special status was conferred on it. It is often said in the services that after every war, the status of the defence forces has plummeted to a new low. Today, the service chiefs are shown at 13th position in the warrant of precedence.

The fall in the status has affected all ranks in the services. In many states, a deputy commissioner with seven to eight years of service is equated with a brigadier who gets this rank after 25 years of service. While the IAS and IPS officers keep going up in status, the armed forces officers’ status keeps ebbing.

As for the IPS, an SP who used to wear the badges of rank of a Captain during the British time, started wearing the rank of a lieutenant colonel long ago. In the Central Warrant of Precedence, 1937, an IG police is equated with a brigadier. Similarly, an ICS officer holding a deputy commissioner’s appointment in a district with a fairly long service was equated to a lieutenant colonel but now an IAS officer has climbed up to equate himself with a brigadier. In certain states, IAS and IPS officers with five to six years of service have been given a status higher than colonels and brigadiers. Almost all IAS and IPS officers after 15 to 20 years of service reach a level that only a microscopic minority in the defence forces can reach, that too, after a stiff selection and not with less than 25 to 30 years of service. Lowering of military officers’ status has been adversely affecting their morale. This pinch riles them more when they have to work side by side with the civilian officers.


STATUS HIGHER IN WEST

In western democracies, the status of armed forces is much higher than what we have in India. For they have a firm conviction that those who safeguard the very existence and territorial integrity of the country deserve a much higher status than most others. Another belief prevailing there is that the military men should come from among the best human material.

In communist countries, the defence services rank next to the party. The party and the armed forces are closely integrated. They encourage military personnel to become party members and many senior posts in the services are reserved for the party members. Thus the services are considered to be a privileged body. Besides, the defence ministers there mostly come from the armed forces.

In India, the armed forces are not given their due recognition because of the fear psychosis among our politicians that a strong army will not augur well for them, thanks to the repeated military coups in our neighbourhood. The fear is totally unfounded. No sinister meanings should be read into giving a higher status to the defence forces, for they being multi-religious and multi-ethnic can never take a cue from our neighbour. About 68 years of our post-Independence era has proved this beyond any doubt.

While dealing with the services, the political leadership in this country wholly depends on the bureaucracy. This is why, unlike in the olden days, the military top brass is kept out of the decision-making loop these days. The fate of the defence forces entirely lies in the hands of the bureaucrats who have taken full advantage of the political hierarchy’s bias towards the Army. Being in effective control of the levers of governance, they have used their power to systematically downgrade the military and erode its status.

It must be understood that the Army has a vital role to play in safeguarding the integrity and security of the country. Besides, when all other organisations, including the police and paramilitary forces, fail to measure up to their tasks, it is the Army that becomes the last resort of the government. It is, therefore, imperative to remove the unhealthy equation between the Army and the civil services by restoring the former its lost status.

(The writer, a retired colonel, is a Chandigarh-based commentator on defence matters. The views expressed are personal)

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Farmers in front of the Red Fort and hoist the Khalsa flag during the protest against the Centre’s farm laws on Republic Day. (Reuters file photo)
Farmers in front of the Red Fort and hoist the Khalsa flag during the protest against the Centre’s farm laws on Republic Day. (Reuters file photo)

Deep Sidhu surfaces on FB, objects to being called traitor

PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 10:03 AM IST
In live video at 2am on Thursday, actor-turned-activist says farmer leaders calling him gaddar for derailing the agitation are doing govt’s bidding; rather, they should have backed Red Fort protesters.
Close
Damaged security screening stations at Red Fort, a day after the violence in the Capital. (Sanchit Khanna/HT PHOTO)
Damaged security screening stations at Red Fort, a day after the violence in the Capital. (Sanchit Khanna/HT PHOTO)

Actor, ex-gangster at centre of farmers’ ire

By HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times, Chandigarh
UPDATED ON JAN 28, 2021 05:36 AM IST
  • The farmers accused the two of taking control of the Sanyukt Kisan Morcha stage on Monday evening, and pushing farmers to march onto the Outer Ring Road rather than the route decided with the police.
Close
Out of a total target of 4,895, so far only 2,464 persons have been vaccinated in Chandigarh. (HT FILE PHOTO)
Out of a total target of 4,895, so far only 2,464 persons have been vaccinated in Chandigarh. (HT FILE PHOTO)

Improper staff utilisation a concern during vax drive in Chandigarh

By Amanjeet Singh Salyal, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 12:32 AM IST
Due to poor response, staff capacity is not being fully utilised; health dept’s request to increase number of beneficiaries turned down by Centre
Close
Panjab University to hold MPhil, PhD entrance tests on March 7
Panjab University to hold MPhil, PhD entrance tests on March 7

Panjab University to hold MPhil, PhD entrance tests on March 7

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 12:20 AM IST
After putting it on hold last year due to the pandemic, Panjab University (PU) has decided to conduct entrance tests for MPhil and PhD programmes on March 7 in physical mode
Close
Since the MC took over the event in 2012, this is the first time it has been cancelled. (HT file photo)
Since the MC took over the event in 2012, this is the first time it has been cancelled. (HT file photo)

No Rose Festival in Chandigarh this year

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 12:17 AM IST
The decision was taken in the MC’s General House meeting where most of the councillors raised their concern over the event, which generally draws huge crowds
Close
Farmers remove tents from a protest site at the Ghazipur border on Wednesday.(Sakib Ali/HT Photos)
Farmers remove tents from a protest site at the Ghazipur border on Wednesday.(Sakib Ali/HT Photos)

Punjab villages sombre after clash, still back stir

By Navrajdeep Singh, Avtar Singh, Mohit Khanna, Anil Sharma, Hindustan Times, Tarn Taran/patiala/sangrur/ludhiana
UPDATED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:28 AM IST
Across Punjab’s hinterlands — especially in the home villages of senior farm leaders — there was disappointment over the violence that farm protesters unleashed when they broke through barricades, clashed violently with police, ran riot on the Capital’s streets and stormed the Red Fort, hoisting the Nishan Sahib, the flag of the Sikhs, on its ramparts.
Close
851 vaccinated against Covid in Chandigarh tricity
851 vaccinated against Covid in Chandigarh tricity

851 vaccinated against Covid in Chandigarh tricity

By HT Correspondents, Chandigarh/mohali/panchkula
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 10:54 PM IST
Meanwhile, the tricity recorded 77 fresh Covid-19 cases on Wednesday while a lone death was reported from Mohali
Close
Rajni Bector, 80, is an alumna of Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana. (Gurpreet Singh/HT)
Rajni Bector, 80, is an alumna of Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana. (Gurpreet Singh/HT)

My phone hasn’t stopped ringing, says Rajni Bector after winning Padma Shri

By Aneesha Sareen Kumar, Ludhiana
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 10:52 PM IST
Ever since the news of her being honoured with the Padma Shri broke, Rajni Bector’s phone hasn’t stopped ringing
Close
Ten teams have been constituted to cull 25,000 birds at Evergreen poultry farm.
Ten teams have been constituted to cull 25,000 birds at Evergreen poultry farm.

Bird flu confirmed at third poultry farm in Dera Bassi

By HT Correspondent, Mohali
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 10:51 PM IST
The samples had tested posted at the Northern Regional Disease Diagnostic Laboratory (NRDDL), Jalandhar, last week, following which they had been forwarded to the Bhopal lab
Close
Auto driver, 2 aides rob woman passenger at knifepoint in Chandigarh
Auto driver, 2 aides rob woman passenger at knifepoint in Chandigarh

Auto driver, 2 aides rob woman passenger at knifepoint in Chandigarh

By HT Correspondent, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 10:48 PM IST
An auto-rickshaw driver and two others have been booked for robbing a woman passenger at knifepoint near the Chandigarh-Mohali border on Wednesday
Close
CHB plans to cut property reserve prices by 10%
CHB plans to cut property reserve prices by 10%

CHB plans to cut property reserve prices by 10%

By Munieshwer A Sagar, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 10:46 PM IST
Stating that the economic scenario hasn’t changed since the 2019 auction, CEO said the cut was suggested by the CHB committee on reserve price
Close
The Punjab government had filed two review petitions with the NGT, saying the state had taken remedial measures and was willing to spend <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>50 crore on landscaping Buddha Nullah in Ludhiana. The tribunal observed that taking future steps is not a ground for not paying compensation for the damage already caused. (Representative image.)
The Punjab government had filed two review petitions with the NGT, saying the state had taken remedial measures and was willing to spend 50 crore on landscaping Buddha Nullah in Ludhiana. The tribunal observed that taking future steps is not a ground for not paying compensation for the damage already caused. (Representative image.)

NGT directs Punjab to deposit 50 cr with CPCB immediately

By Gagandeep Jassowal
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 03:28 PM IST
Tribunal rejects state govt’s review plea and asks it to deposit amount with Central Pollution Control Board forthwith for eco-restoration of the Sutlej and Beas rivers.
Close
Actor Deep Sidhu. (File photo)
Actor Deep Sidhu. (File photo)

Tractor rally violence: Sunny Deol distances himself from Deep Sidhu

By Anil Sharma
UPDATED ON JAN 27, 2021 11:39 AM IST
Sidhu is a Punjabi film actor-turned-activist who allegedly led a mob of protesting farmers that stormed the Red Fort and hoisted a flag there on Tuesday
Close
Farmers on a sit-in protest against new farm laws, at Lehra Bega toll plaza in Bathinda, Punjab. (Sanjeev Kumar/Hindustan Times)
Farmers on a sit-in protest against new farm laws, at Lehra Bega toll plaza in Bathinda, Punjab. (Sanjeev Kumar/Hindustan Times)

Farmers voice disappointment, anger in Punjab and Haryana

By Aneesha Sareen, Neeraj Mohan, Hindustan Times, Amritsar/ludhiana/ Karnal/ Rohtak
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 04:09 AM IST
  • Even farmers, who were earlier excited about the tractor rally and spent the day glued to their phones and television sets, said the violence on the streets of Delhi and outside the Red Fort weakened the movement.
Close
Gurmeet Singh Kular, Ludhiana based-entrepreneur and president of Federation of Industrial and Commercial Organization (FICO) at his cycle parts unit in Ludhiana (Gurpreet Singh/Hindustan Times)
Gurmeet Singh Kular, Ludhiana based-entrepreneur and president of Federation of Industrial and Commercial Organization (FICO) at his cycle parts unit in Ludhiana (Gurpreet Singh/Hindustan Times)

‘Centre should simplify taxes, support MSMEs’: FICO Prez

By Aneesha Sareen, Hindustan Times, Ludhiana
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 01:14 AM IST
  • In pre-Covid times, I worked with 240 workers. 140 of these left and didn't return. I am managing with only 100 workers, says Kular
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP