Can’t reject railway accident claim on grounds of victim’s negligence: Bombay HC

The Bombay high court reversed an order of the Nagpur Railway Accident Claims Tribunal, which rejected the claim of a victim’s family on the grounds that the man died due to his own negligent act in trying to alight from a running train
The Bombay high court said that the liability of the Railways is based on a ‘no fault theory’. (File Photo)
The Bombay high court said that the liability of the Railways is based on a ‘no fault theory’. (File Photo)
Updated on May 14, 2022 11:04 AM IST
Copy Link

MUMBAI: Railway accident claims cannot be rejected on the grounds of negligence of the deceased, the Bombay high court observed while allowing the claim of a victim’s family.

“The liability of Railways is based on ‘no fault theory’,” said the single judge bench of justice MS Karnik while allowing the accident claim filed by family members of one Roshanlal Tembhare, who died in a railway accident at Amgaon railway station in Gondia district of Vidarbha region.

“The principle of contributory negligence cannot be invoked in such case,” the court said in the April 28 order which became available on Friday.

The court reversed the January 23, 2019 order of the Nagpur Railway Accident Claims Tribunal, rejecting the family’s claim on the grounds that the man died due to his own negligent act in trying to alight from a running train.

The incident in question took place on November 22, 2017, when Roshanlal Tembhare was travelling from Raipur to Gondia by Howrah–Mumbai mail and died due to fall from the running train at Amgaon railway station.

After the family of the deceased filed the accident claim, the railways claimed that the deceased died due to his own negligence and examined the guard of the train in support of their claim.

The guard claimed that he had seen the deceased jumping from the running train as the train slowed down at Amgaon railway station, though the train had no scheduled halt there.

The tribunal accepted the railway’s stand and held that it was not an untoward accident, as the man died due to fall while making unsuccessful attempt to jump from the running train which had no scheduled stoppage at Amgaon Railway Station.

Justice Karnik reversed the verdict and directed the South East Central Railway to deposit with the tribunal a compensation of 8 lakh to be paid to the family of the deceased – 4 lakh to the parents of the deceased and 4 lakh to his minor daughter.

The single judge bench said it was not the Railways’ case that this is a case of suicide or attempt to commit suicide. “At the highest, it is a case of the deceased trying to de-board a train which had slowed down at the railway station resulting in his death which will have to be regarded as an ‘untoward incident’ entitling the victim to the compensation,” said the court. “The case will not fall under the proviso to Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989 (which lays down exceptional situations in which compensation is not payable to railway accident victims or their family members), merely on the plea of negligence of the victim as a contributory factor.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Wife, paramour arrested for husband’s murder

    Wife, paramour arrested for husband’s murder

    Mumbai: A 32-year-old woman, resident of Shivaji Nagar, and hthe accused Najeera Khan'sparamour was arrested in Govandi on Sunday for allegedly killing the woman's husband after he discovered their affair. According to the police, the two stabbed the woman's husband, identified as Jamil Khan aka Shamsher, (33), with a kitchen knife after he caught them. Police officers said that the accused Najeera Khan had married the victim a few years back and had a two-year-old son.

  • Haryana municipal corporation elections for urban bodies to be held on June 19.

    Haryana urban body election dates announced: Check full schedule

    Elections to the 93 urban bodies of Haryana municipal corporation are set to take place on June 19, the state election commission announced on Monday. The polls will begin at 7am and continue till 6pm. Haryana Election Commissioner Dhanpat Singh, in a press conference, announced the dates and said a notice listing the details for the municipal corporation elections will be issued on May 24.

  • Samajwadi party MLAs shout slogans during the speech of Governor Anandiben Patel on the first day of the Uttar Pradesh Budget Session in the State Assembly in Lucknow, on Monday. (Deepak Gupta/ HT Photo)

    ‘Go back’ slogans greet UP governor as she lists Yogi govt’s achievements

    LUCKNOW: 'Go back' slogans greeted UP governor Anandiben Patel as she listed the Yogi Adityanath government's (2.0) achievements on the development and law and order front, in her address to a joint sitting of the two houses in the state assembly hall, marking the opening of the budget session of the state legislature here on Monday.

  • According to a statement from the PMC water department, the civic administration would undertake maintenance and repair work at Parvati, Cantonment, SNDT, Warje and Holkar bridge water treatment plants. (REPRESENTATIVE IMAGE)

    Water supply to be cut off in most parts of Pune city on Thursday

    PUNE Most parts of the city will have no water supply on Thursday, May 26, as the Pune Municipal Corporation has decided to undertake urgent repair and maintenance works at various pumping stations. The supply would be restored on Friday. According to a statement from the PMC water department, the civic administration would undertake maintenance and repair work at Parvati, Cantonment, SNDT, Warje and Holkar bridge water treatment plants.

  • DCW team inspects four MCD schools, calls them 'horror houses'.

    'Horror house’: DCW chief on Delhi civic body-run schools

    The Delhi Commission for Women conducted a surprise check of civic body-run schools in the national capital to look into safety and security measures in place for girl students in wake of recent reports of molestation. DCW chairperson Swati Maliwal, who led the team, called the condition of some of these schools “pathetic, unsafe and deeply disturbing”.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, May 23, 2022