Elders of Harijan tola suffering from fluorosis have bent backs and cannot walk without stick at Pratapur village in Garhwa.(B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)
Elders of Harijan tola suffering from fluorosis have bent backs and cannot walk without stick at Pratapur village in Garhwa.(B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)

In Jharkhand’s fluorosis-crippled village, ‘hapless’ govt counts bodies

Pratappur, a dalits village, in Garhwa district is highly fluorosis endemic. Around 60 people have died in last five years, seven in the last one and half months and still counting. Every family here has at least one or two member with crippled bones, bent joints, and bed ridden patients with multiple fractures in legs and arms. Bone deformities have transformed some patients into horror movie characters. The government doesn’t have a concrete rehabilitation plan.
By B Vijay Murty | Hindustan Times, Pratappur (garhwa)
UPDATED ON JUN 09, 2016 04:40 PM IST

Ramapati Devi squats on a cot in her thatched hutment - her hands twisted like a malleable wire and legs deformed like oars - staring with her emotionless eyes.

Her husband Ganauri Ram, who has a big lump on his bent back, slowly walks up to her and gives her water.

Unable to speak, she gestures that she wants to lie down but a stiff backbone prevents her from spreading her legs and back straight on the cot. Despite being in severe pain himself, the generous husband places a couple of soiled, tattered pillows around her.

Ramapati is barely 50 but she looks at least 20 years older. Her bone structure is changing with each passing day as she helplessly bears the painful development pleading for death.

“She wants death and so do I. Wondering how long will we have to endure these painful changes in our bodies,” Ram, 55, said gently covering her with a soiled bed sheet before he going back to his chair.

The couple from Jharkhand’s Pratappur village in Garhwa district is suffering from skeletal fluorosis, a disease caused by excessive accumulation of fluoride in bones. Local doctors have given up hope on them and they cannot afford treatment in any other hospital.

A flouride removal filter fitted with a tube well to save villagers from fluorosis needs repair at Pratappur village in Garhwa. (B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)
A flouride removal filter fitted with a tube well to save villagers from fluorosis needs repair at Pratappur village in Garhwa. (B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)

An endemic

Around 220 km north of Jharkhand capital Ranchi, in this village of Dalits death lurks in every family. There are dozens of people with crippled bones and damaged joints, many bedridden with multiple fractures, slowly dying in the absence of treatment.

There are a few families that have lost more than two to three members and the remaining ones too are counting their last days.

Putan Ram, 45, calls himself the most unfortunate person on earth. Five years back his was a happy family of five brothers, their wives and children. He lost four of his brothers in as many years.

His two widowed sisters’-in-law also suffer from skeletal fluorosis and surviving on medicines supplied by local doctors. “All of us are going to die sooner,” he said pointing towards his 10-year-old nephew Ranjit with stunted growth and deformed bones in both his legs.

Koshila Devi suffering from fluorosis is bedridden for last five years legs have given up strength at Pratappur village in Garhwa. (B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)
Koshila Devi suffering from fluorosis is bedridden for last five years legs have given up strength at Pratappur village in Garhwa. (B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)

Several youngsters in their early thirties with decayed teeth look double their age as if afflicted with progeria — a rare genetic condition in which symptoms resembling aspects of ageing are manifested at an early age.

“Prevention is the only solution to check fluorosis deaths,” local civil surgeon Dr T Hembrom said. “We can only give supporting medicines,” he added.

Counting deaths

The list of sufferers is endless but the government is yet to wake up and treat it as a calamity.

In the last five years, Pratappur’s two tolas—Gatiyahi and Harijan—have lost 60 people to fluorosis. Of them, at least seven have died in the last one and half months.

A stop at the village bares the government’s tall claims of bringing the poor and downtrodden, especially the Schedule Caste, to the mainstream. In Pratappur, it has miserably failed to guarantee their right to life.

Elders of Harijan tola suffering from fluorosis have bent backs and cannot walk without stick at Pratappur village in Garhwa. (B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)
Elders of Harijan tola suffering from fluorosis have bent backs and cannot walk without stick at Pratappur village in Garhwa. (B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)

The government here, it seems, is only left to count bodies. No major effort is evident to rescue and rehabilitate the remaining people.

A board by the government’s water and sanitation department standing at the entrance of Harijan Tola advices people not to consume water from tube wells affected by fluoride.

Villagers, however, complained they have nowhere to go to fetch water when the government has failed to make alternative arrangements as the entire area has a high fluoride concentration in groundwater.

An ambitious effort to provide piped drinking water to this village from a nearby river lies in limbo for the last three decades.

“A piped water supply project is underway to reach clean drinking water to the people,” Garhwa deputy commissioner Dr Neha Arora said conceding that the situation was alarming. She added land has been earmarked for setting up of a water treatment plant in the affected village.

Husband of skeletal fluorosis patient Rampatia Devi offering water at Pratappur village in Garhwa. (B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)
Husband of skeletal fluorosis patient Rampatia Devi offering water at Pratappur village in Garhwa. (B Vijay Murty/ Hindustan Times)

Hindustan Times first highlighted Pratappur residents’ plight in August 2011.

After the intervention of the then Union rural development minister Jairam Ramesh, a five-member team from New Delhi’s Fluorosis Research and Rural Development Department (FRRDD) travelled to Pratappur. The team, led by executive director AK Susheela, suggested several measures to save people from the crippling disease and eventual deaths.

Five years hence, HT revisited the village and found that none of the suggestions made by the team have been implemented. Only one tube well in the entire village was fitted with a fluoride removal filter but that too had stopped functioning.

“I am aware of the problem persisting in Pratappur and have raised the issue in the assembly quite a few times,” BJP legislator, Dr Dipu Charan Ram, said assuring to take up the matter with the government again.

In Jharkhand’s fluorosis-crippled village, ‘hapless’ govt counts bodies
In Jharkhand’s fluorosis-crippled village, ‘hapless’ govt counts bodies
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Activist Saket Gokhale had sought consent, a condition precedent for initiating criminal contempt proceedings, of the top-most law officer to initiate the case against the former CJI who had reportedly said at an event that the judiciary is "ramshackled" and it is quite unlikely for a person to get a timely verdict.(PTI)
Activist Saket Gokhale had sought consent, a condition precedent for initiating criminal contempt proceedings, of the top-most law officer to initiate the case against the former CJI who had reportedly said at an event that the judiciary is "ramshackled" and it is quite unlikely for a person to get a timely verdict.(PTI)

Venugopal refuses to give mandate to contempt proceedings against ex- CJI Gogoi

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 04:00 PM IST
Venugopal said though ex-CJI's statements were strong, but they reflected his views on the ills of the judiciary.
Close
NHAI will resume toll collection on national highways from April 20
NHAI will resume toll collection on national highways from April 20

Gadkari announces new expressway, Travel from Delhi to Dehradun in 2 hours

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Deepali Sharma, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:55 PM IST
The Delhi-Dehradun Economic Corridor will offer new connectivity to the holy site of Haridwar in Uttarakhand.
Close
Keeping up with Airmeet's performance driven culture, the ISO certification is a testament of the company's devotion to continually enhance their product. In order to become ISO 27001:2013 compliant, the firm had to undergo a series of extensive audits, pre-audit assessments and reviews.
Keeping up with Airmeet's performance driven culture, the ISO certification is a testament of the company's devotion to continually enhance their product. In order to become ISO 27001:2013 compliant, the firm had to undergo a series of extensive audits, pre-audit assessments and reviews.

Airmeet becomes ISO certified, maintains high standard info security management

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:39 PM IST
ISO 27001:2013 specifies the requirements for establishing, implementing, maintaining, and continually improving an information security management system within the organization's context.
Close
A health worker wearing a PPE kit collects a swab sample of an old lady for the COVID-19 test as she arrives at Dadar railway station, in Mumbai on Friday. (ANI Photo)
A health worker wearing a PPE kit collects a swab sample of an old lady for the COVID-19 test as she arrives at Dadar railway station, in Mumbai on Friday. (ANI Photo)

Covid spike in Mumbai: FIR against marriage halls; 120 buildings remain sealed

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:43 PM IST
Though Mumbai has been reporting over 1,000 cases daily, according to the authorities, the situation is not out of control yet as the recovery rate is also high at 93 per cent.
Close
File photo of Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal (HT Prrint).
File photo of Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal (HT Prrint).

‘People want to know’: Kejriwal vs Gujarat BJP chief on civic election results

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Karan Manral, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:19 PM IST
Arvind Kejriwal, who held a road show in Surat on Friday, finds himself in a Twitter war of words with Gujarat BJP chief and Lok Sabha MP, CR Paatil.
Close
Satej Patil also said these regulations need to be opposed strongly as they infringe the privacy of individuals and free speech given by the Constitution.(Twitter/@satejp)
Satej Patil also said these regulations need to be opposed strongly as they infringe the privacy of individuals and free speech given by the Constitution.(Twitter/@satejp)

Maha minister says Centre's new regulation for digital platforms 'dictatorial'

PTI, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:11 PM IST
The Minister of State for IT Satej Patil said "This move by the Centre needs to be fought tooth and nail. Such dictatorial regulations will not be accepted by the people of this democratic country."
Close
Army sources said the unprovoked ceasefire violation by Pakistan in Tangdhar sector, which was an attempt to push in terrorists into India under covering fire.(Hindustan Times/representative image)
Army sources said the unprovoked ceasefire violation by Pakistan in Tangdhar sector, which was an attempt to push in terrorists into India under covering fire.(Hindustan Times/representative image)

Ceasefire to have no bearing on counter-terrorism operations: Lt Gen

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:11 PM IST
Without naming China and Pakistan, he said Indian Army has maintained its domination on its borders with the neighbouring countries and helped in maintaining peace in the hinterland.
Close
The accused who were absconding were arrested Saturday morning.(Representational Photo/HT Archives.)
The accused who were absconding were arrested Saturday morning.(Representational Photo/HT Archives.)

Telangana’s Siddipet tense after alleged slaughter of cows, police arrest 8 men

PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:08 PM IST
  • A court in Siddipet sent the eight accused to 14 days in judicial custody.
Close
People walk on a snow-covered road at Ahlan village in South Kashmir. (File photo)
People walk on a snow-covered road at Ahlan village in South Kashmir. (File photo)

Fresh snowfall in Kashmir brings back cold wave-like conditions

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:06 PM IST
Fresh snowfall was reported from most parts of Kashmir, including Srinagar, the summer capital of Jammu and Kashmir, the officials said.
Close
IAF chief RKS Bhadauria gifted a legacy Alouette III helicopter to the Bangladesh Air Force (PTI Photo) (PTI)
IAF chief RKS Bhadauria gifted a legacy Alouette III helicopter to the Bangladesh Air Force (PTI Photo) (PTI)

IAF gifts 1971 war helicopter to Bangladesh, gets F-86 fighter as return gift

ANI, Dhaka
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:05 PM IST
  • The exchange of aircraft took place in Dhaka during the four day trip of Bhadauria to Bangladesh
Close
One reason for high prices of petrol and diesel is central and state levies. (HT Photo)
One reason for high prices of petrol and diesel is central and state levies. (HT Photo)

Petrol, diesel prices hiked again, 16th time this month

By Rajeev Jayaswal, Hindustan Times, Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:45 PM IST
Domestic fuel retailers raised petrol and diesel rates on Saturday even as international crude oil prices fell on Friday because of firming dollar.
Close
The states showing a surge are Telangana, Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Punjab, Jammu and Kashmir and West Bengal. (PTI)
The states showing a surge are Telangana, Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Punjab, Jammu and Kashmir and West Bengal. (PTI)

Cabinet secretary to hold review meeting with 8 states, UTs

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:39 PM IST
The ministry said 85.75 per cent of 16,488 new cases registered in a span of 24 hours are from six states and UTs.
Close
Fishermen pull a long net after fishing in the Bay of Bengal at Jodugulla Palem Beach, in Visakhapatnam on Thursday. (ANI Photo)
Fishermen pull a long net after fishing in the Bay of Bengal at Jodugulla Palem Beach, in Visakhapatnam on Thursday. (ANI Photo)

Fishing hartal hits coastal belt in Kerala

PTI, Thiruvananthapuram
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:34 PM IST
Various pro-Congress outfits, under the banner of Matsya Mekhala Samrakshana Samithi, called for the hartal in the coastal belt.
Close
India’s Permanent Representative to the UN Ambassador T S Tirumurti.(PTI File Photo)
India’s Permanent Representative to the UN Ambassador T S Tirumurti.(PTI File Photo)

India has highest stake in Rohingyas' return to Myanmar: India at UNGA

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:34 PM IST
Myanmar doesn’t recognise Rohingya as an ethnic group and insists that they are Bangladeshi migrants living illegally in the country.
Close
In written response to a question in Lok Sabha earlier this month, Union Minister of State for Home G Kishan Reddy said a total of 10,752 cases of ceasefire violations have taken place along India's border with Pakistan in the last three years, in which 72 security personnel and 70 civilians were killed.(AP)
In written response to a question in Lok Sabha earlier this month, Union Minister of State for Home G Kishan Reddy said a total of 10,752 cases of ceasefire violations have taken place along India's border with Pakistan in the last three years, in which 72 security personnel and 70 civilians were killed.(AP)

J&K border residents thank PM Modi, Khan for ceasefire agreement

ANI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:32 PM IST
Several residents around the tumultuous area have suffered due to tensions between the two countries, and many have lost limbs, eyes, and other body parts.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP