Janani Suraksha Yojana: Cash alone not enough in India birth services, says research
Money is not a sufficient incentive for pregnant women in India to take up free institutional delivery services, according to new research by a team of researchers, who examined the Indian government’s Janani Suraksha Yojana (JSY).
Less than 50% of the women eligible take up the cash incentive scheme, the research by experts in the United Kingdom, Australia and India published in the journal Social Science & Medicine says. There are more significant factors such as familial support and transport challenges, it adds.
The research identifies several obstacles in the uptake of the JSY, including poor quality of care and infrastructure at institutions, lack of a caretaker at home to look after other children, trust in the skills of traditional birth attendants over the need for medical care, and the notion of childbirth as a ‘natural event’ requiring no institutional delivery care.
The research found that, overall, the use of maternal healthcare facilities is largely driven by the community health workers known as ASHAs (Accredited Social Health Activists), whose support services and efforts to generate awareness of the benefits of facility-based childbirth were major enabling factors in the accessing of delivery care.
Lead author Sukumar Vellakkal, said: “The study findings highlight the importance of improving the support services of the community health workers for effectively linking people with health facilities, rather than depending on market-based approaches such as conditional cash transfers.
“Equally important is to address critical gaps around quality of care at the public primary healthcare facilities.”
Co-author Jasmine Fledderjohann of Lancaster University added: “Targeting pregnant women with cash incentives misses the importance of socio-cultural context of childbearing in motivating decisions about delivery care.
“Childbearing is a family process, and respondents in our study highlighted the substantial role of spouses and mothers-in-law in shaping delivery decisions. One reason the ASHAs are so effective may be that they understand family influences on this decision, and aim to address concerns raised by spouses and in-laws as well by women themselves.”
The researchers found that there was also a strong belief that institutional delivery care facilities were only for cases in which there were birth complications.
Enter your email to get our daily newsletter in your inbox
- The IAF contingent arrived in Colombo on February 27. The Suryakiran Aerobatic Team had taken part in the SLAF’s golden jubilee celebrations two decades ago.
- At least eight policemen were injured in the two-hour mayhem that began around 9.30 am.
- Bharat Biotech developed the country’s first indigenous vaccine, Covaxin, in partnership with ICMR.
- The military is expected to make a presentation to the PM on the situation along the borders and progress made towards the creation of theatre commands.
- Maharashtra minister Nawab Malik has alleged that the raids on Anurag Kashyap and Tapsee Pannu were an attempt to suppress the voice of those who speak against the central government.
- Khandu said, he had recently asked the chief secretary to compile details of such reserve forests and send a proposal to the Centre with a request to use such forest land for carrying out development work.
- Five jawans were taking part in a night firing practice when the incident took place.
- Santosh is planning to set up a Green India Foundation to take up the tree plantation programme extensively and also spread it to other parts of the country.
- the Tibetan government-in-exile, had asked the Centre and the Kangra district medical officer to vaccinate the Dalai Lama and those working around him at the earliest,
- The focus on the upper caste, according to party leaders, is mainly to draw them closer to the party by letting them know the inclusive development that chief minister Nitish Kumar has been able to usher in over the last one and half decades.