With the target for making India open defecation free (ODF) by 2019, states are tripping over themselves to meet the deadline.(HT File)
With the target for making India open defecation free (ODF) by 2019, states are tripping over themselves to meet the deadline.(HT File)

With stiff target for building toilets under Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, states are flouting citizens’ rights

With the target for making India open defecation free (ODF) by 2019 under the Swachh Bharat Mission-Gramin (SBM-G) programme, states are tripping over themselves to meet the deadline, even at the cost of violating citizens’ right to food or privacy.
By KumKum Dasgupta | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON APR 03, 2017 01:39 PM IST

For people in rural India, defecating in the open is no more a “pleasure activity”.

These days, it is fraught with challenges: One could find the details of his morning ritual narrated like a cricket match commentary.

Or people could be denied ration and government documents for failing to build a toilet at home.

With the target for making India open defecation free (ODF) by 2019 under the Swachh Bharat Mission-Gramin (SBM-G) programme, states are tripping over themselves to meet the deadline, even at the cost of violating citizens’ right to food or privacy.

This mad rush to build toilets and end open defecation is also putting the long-term sustainability of the Centre’s flagship programme at peril, allege activists.

“In Indore, temple loudspeakers were used to narrate a commentary when someone went out to defecate in the open. Kids were asked to whistle … even photographs of people defecating in the open being interrupted by strangers offering flowers did rounds on social media,” said Nikhil Srivastav, research and policy manager, Research Institute for Compassionate Economics (R.I.C.E).

In Rajasthan’s Ajmer district, the administration has formed citizens’ groups to blow whistles if they spot anyone defecating in the open.

According to a local Hindi daily, Sawai Madhopur collector KC Verma has directed ration shops to stop giving people grains if they don’t build toilets.

“This flouts the National Food Security Act, 2013,” said Dr Indira Khurana, a water and sanitation expert. However, when HT contacted Verma, he said he was misquoted in the report.

In Maharashtra’s Solapur, the administration has resorted to public shaming to curb open defecation.

Those failing to use a toilet would find their name on a list in the town square or a local paper. Repeat offenders would find a musical band chasing them home or could be locked up for two hours by the police.

Chhattisgarh’s Balod district, however, takes the cake: In Kapasi village, which was declared the first ODF village in Balod, CCTVs have been installed to stop people from open defecation.

In South Sikkim, people are denied government documents including OBC/ death/birth certificates, if they don’t build toilets.

“We put two types of pressure— one positive and the other negative. Positive pressure was put through campaigns and social messaging. Negative pressure was applied by restricting and denying government benefits to those who haven’t constructed toilets or haven’t given up ODF,” Rajkumar Yadav, district collector, South Sikkim, told HT.

Last week, a 70-year old man in Tuticorin, filed a case in the Madras High Court, stating that his village has denied work under the rural employment guarantee scheme because he failed to build a toilet. “The district official’s action violates Article 21 (right to life) of the Constitution,” he said in his petition.

“While threatening citizens may enable officials to participate in the ODF race, ODF will only be achieved and sustained when people demand facilities,” activists told HT.

“Pressure has to be put on people to end socially deviant behaviour. But before that happens, two things have to be done: One, there are enough toilets and second, the community is on board,” said Meeta Rajiv Lochan, former director, municipal administration, Maharashtra.

One of the reasons why users are not demanding toilets is that the message about the importance of latrine use is not reaching people. “The SBM allocates only 3% of the total budget to Information, Education and Communication (IEC). Worse, that money is not being spent,” explained Diane Coffey, executive director, R.I.C.E.

R.I.C.E. has been conducting a phone survey, which applies similar techniques used by Gallup poll, in Delhi and Uttar Pradesh, on whether the sanitation message is reaching people. “In 2016, 2,708 people answered questions. One question asked respondents whether they have heard of the SBM: 62% of people in Delhi claimed to have heard of the SBM, similar to 63% of urban UP. The figure was 45% in rural UP,” Coffey told HT.

To people who said they had heard of the SBM, R.I.C.E. asked: What do you think the SBM does? Very few people included among their responses the idea that the SBM had anything to do with toilets or latrines: 5% in Delhi, 6% in urban UP, and only 4% of rural UP.

“Among over 700 women interviewed in UP, not a single one without education beyond secondary school mentioned that the SBM includes a goal about toilets or latrines,” said Coffey. The other problem is that the payment mechanism for toilets is also slow.

An analysis of public data by Accountability Initiative, SBM-G guidelines require 8% of allocations to be utilised for IEC. However, in FY 2016-17, till 10 January 2017, only 1% of total expenditure had been spent IEC activities.

“The huge gap in the percentage spent between construction of toilets and communication for behaviour change indicate disconnect between SBM guidelines and implementation. Behaviour change takes time. So there needs to be a strong focus on diverse, localised, multiple and repeated modes of communication. This is missing now,” said Dr Khurana.

Akshay Kumar Rout, Officer on Special Duty (OSD), SBM, however, denied that coercive measures are being used to meet the 2019 deadline. “The Centre does not approve of any coercive measures. The programme has moved from toilet building to ensuring behaviour change,” he told HT.

He, however, agreed that some states need training on better usage of IEC funds. “We are piloting new programmes to spread message about the link between health and improved sanitation,” Rout said.

kumkum.dasgupta@hindustantimes.com

@kumkumdasgupta

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
The ambulance collided with a truck early Tuesday morning(Representational photo/Getty Images)
The ambulance collided with a truck early Tuesday morning(Representational photo/Getty Images)

Five killed as ambulance rams into truck in UP’s Bhadoi

PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 06:42 PM IST
  • The victims were carrying the body of a person from Asansol in West Bengal to Chittorgarh in Rajasthan when the accident took place.
Close
"Centre's responsibility was to keep law & order in control but they failed,” Sharad Pawar said.(HT Photo)
"Centre's responsibility was to keep law & order in control but they failed,” Sharad Pawar said.(HT Photo)

'Centre's responsibility to maintain law and order, it failed': Sharad Pawar

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Srivatsan K C
UPDATED ON JAN 26, 2021 06:46 PM IST
“Nobody will support whatever happened today but the reason behind it cannot be ignored either. Govt should act maturely & take the right decision,” Pawar said.
Close
Tractor with two farmers overturns at Delhi-Noida border on Tuesday. (ANI photo)
Tractor with two farmers overturns at Delhi-Noida border on Tuesday. (ANI photo)

At least 19 in hospital after violence at tractor rally in Delhi

By Anonna Dutt | Edited by Sparshita Saxena
UPDATED ON JAN 26, 2021 06:38 PM IST
  • Six people were rushed to the emergency department at Ram Manohar Lohia (RML) Hospital.
Close
Students from the government college of nursing hold Indian national flags to celebrate the Republic Day, in Chennai. (AP)
Students from the government college of nursing hold Indian national flags to celebrate the Republic Day, in Chennai. (AP)

Airports Authority of India celebrates 72nd Republic Day with fervour

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 06:16 PM IST
"On the 72nd #RepublicDay. celebrations, Arvind Singh, Chairman, #AAI unfurled the flag at Delhi Air Traffic Services Complex in presence of AAI Board Members, @aaiRedNR and other senior AAI officials," the AAI tweeted.
Close
A medical worker (R) inoculates a medical staff with a Covid-19 coronavirus vaccine.(AP)
A medical worker (R) inoculates a medical staff with a Covid-19 coronavirus vaccine.(AP)

Karnataka's war on Covid commendable: Governor Vajubhai Vala

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 06:15 PM IST
Vala said India took the pandemic as a challenge and became self-reliant in manufacturing PPE kits and ventilators in a big way.
Close
Amid the chaos, the police had to resort to firing tear gas shells and use water cannons to stop the farmers from entering central Delhi.(Anushree Fadnavis / REUTERS)
Amid the chaos, the police had to resort to firing tear gas shells and use water cannons to stop the farmers from entering central Delhi.(Anushree Fadnavis / REUTERS)

Violence at tractor rally: Who said what

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Ayshee Bhaduri, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 05:59 PM IST
  • “We strongly condemn the violence seen in today's protest. It is regrettable that the Central govt allowed the situation to deteriorate to such an extent. The movement has been peaceful for the last two months” remarked Aam Aadmi Party on Tuesday's incident
Close
Union home minister Amit Shah (PTI)
Union home minister Amit Shah (PTI)

Amit Shah orders deployment of additional paramilitary forces in Delhi

Written by Prashasti Singh, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 26, 2021 06:42 PM IST
Union home secretary Ajay Bhalla met Shah and briefed him about the prevailing situation in the national capital and the steps being taken by the Delhi Police to maintain peace, an official told news agency PTI.
Close
Farmers participate in tractor rally, during their ongoing protest against Centre's farm reform laws, near Nangloi in New Delhi on Tuesday.(PTI Photo)
Farmers participate in tractor rally, during their ongoing protest against Centre's farm reform laws, near Nangloi in New Delhi on Tuesday.(PTI Photo)

Farmers in Nangloi break police barricades, march towards Red Fort

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 05:28 PM IST
Some police personnel had to sit on the road in Nangloi to block the movement of farmers' tractor rally.
Close
Radhe Shyam Barle (Sourced)
Radhe Shyam Barle (Sourced)

Barle gets Padma Shri for promotion of Chhattisgarh’s folk dance form

UPDATED ON JAN 26, 2021 05:37 PM IST
A resident of Chhattisgarh’s Durg, Radhe Shyam Barle has been associated with the state’s Panthi folk dance since his childhood
Close
Punjab chief minister Amarinder Singh talking to media in New Delhi.(ANI)
Punjab chief minister Amarinder Singh talking to media in New Delhi.(ANI)

'Violence by some elements unacceptable', says Punjab CM Amarinder Singh

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
UPDATED ON JAN 26, 2021 06:34 PM IST
Thousands of protesting farmers clashed with police in several areas of Delhi and stormed the historic Red Fort after breaking through barricades at different border points of the national capital on Tuesday.
Close
Satyaram Reang. (HT Photo)
Satyaram Reang. (HT Photo)

Republic Day: Tripura’s Satyaram Reang gets Padma Shri award

By Priyanka Deb Barman
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 05:22 PM IST
A Hojagiri dancer, Reang, 78, has been instrumental in the promotion and preservation of the dance performed by standing on an earthen pitcher
Close
The cumulative forest land that is to be diverted for the three projects inside the protected area is 163.43ha while the cumulative forest land required for such projects outside the protected area is believed to be another 200ha of forest land. (HT Photo)
The cumulative forest land that is to be diverted for the three projects inside the protected area is 163.43ha while the cumulative forest land required for such projects outside the protected area is believed to be another 200ha of forest land. (HT Photo)

Goa infra projects: Members of wildlife board allege incorrect minutes

By Gerard de Souza
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 05:14 PM IST
Some members of the board said that the projects were not “unanimously” passed and that the minutes have not reflected the objections they had raised
Close
Prem Chand Sharma. (Sourced)
Prem Chand Sharma. (Sourced)

Uttarakhand farmer gets Padma award for innovations in agriculture

PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 05:09 PM IST
Prem Chand Sharma has been focusing to diversify farming in the state by growing high-quality fruits, vegetables, and grains organically
Close
Opposition MAs during a protest inside the Goa assembly on Monday(HT PHOTO)
Opposition MAs during a protest inside the Goa assembly on Monday(HT PHOTO)

Goa CM, Leader of Opposition spar over 'unparliamentary protest' in Assembly

By Gerard de Souza
PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 05:04 PM IST
  • Opposition members in the Goa assembly had staged a silent protest during the Governor's address on Monday
Close
Biren Kumar Basak(HT Photo )
Biren Kumar Basak(HT Photo )

Meet Biren Kumar Basak, from selling sarees to winning Padma Shri

PUBLISHED ON JAN 26, 2021 04:59 PM IST
Some of his clients are chief minister Mamata Banerjee, Sourav Ganguly, noted classical musician Ustad Amjad Ali Khan, Asha Bhosle, Lata Mangeshkar, among others.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP