Farmers such as Faljibhai Nagjibhai Bauliya (right) and his brother Laxmanbhai of Haibatpur village fear being dispossessed of their land because of the discrepancy in the records. Here, they are pictured holding up documents that prove the land belonged to their father; (below) Farmers whose fields are the site for the Dholera international airport.(Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)
Farmers such as Faljibhai Nagjibhai Bauliya (right) and his brother Laxmanbhai of Haibatpur village fear being dispossessed of their land because of the discrepancy in the records. Here, they are pictured holding up documents that prove the land belonged to their father; (below) Farmers whose fields are the site for the Dholera international airport.(Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)

Land pooling looks fertile, but Dholera farmers not reaping benefits

Unlike land acquisition in which the owner has no right over the land, land pooling implies that farmers have a share in its development. So why are the farmers of Dholera in Gujarat unconvinced?
By Namita Kohli | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2016 06:50 PM IST

A little over a 100 kms south from the city of Ahmedabad, in the lush green cotton fields, speckled with creamy white cotton buds, locals will regale you with stories of farmers who sold their land and got rich. There is one about a few farmers in a nearby village, who sold their land to a corporate and bought the “chaar bangle waali car” (referring to the Audi logo). Another one concerns a farmer near the Jamnagar district, who sold his land, bought a bike, and even hired a driver to take him around town.

If you were willing to listen, farmers in Dholera will tell you more: of those who sold their land for a “good price”, refurbished their houses and bought shiny new Altos and Scorpios.

So why wouldn’t they do so too? “Because if you lost your land, you would only end up as someone’s slave. Those who sold their land to the companies are now doing majoori (manual labour) on other people’s farms, or working in factories. The farmer who was once a malik (owner), is now taking a dabba (lunch box) and going to work every day,” says Roop Sang Bhai of Sarasla village in Dholera.

Labourers work on Togubha Dilubha Chudasmas land holding where they earn ₹200 per day. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)
Labourers work on Togubha Dilubha Chudasmas land holding where they earn ₹200 per day. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)

Money cannot be eaten, residents of Sarasla insist. The cars are standing stationary, the bike chauffeurs have turned unaffordable, and the promised jobs either didn’t come, or didn’t pay well, they lament. “Villages nearby are full of those who have been ruined after selling their land to industries. The khet (fields) has always given us enough to eat. So why should we give it away?” asks Roop Sang, echoing the sentiment of the group in the Sarasla cotton field.

In the 22 villages of Dholera, the site for the Dholera Special Investment Region (DSIR), it’s a question that farmers want to pose to the authority in charge of acquiring land for this project.

Like the rest of the country, in the town of Dholera too, land has become the flash point of conflict between its owners and the government. But what makes Dholera different — and a test case for alternative models of acquiring land for industry — is the state government’s land pooling policy, as opposed to the contentious one on acquisition.

Announced in 2007, the ambitious DSIR project was pitched as a “global manufacturing and trading” hub, with a smart city and an international airport to boot. It is the first industrial node — there are 24 planned along the Delhi Mumbai Industrial Corridor — that was taken up for development. Touted to be PM Narendra Modi’s pet project (the CM of Gujarat when it was announced) the DSIR didn’t see much activity until last year, when the project received a sanction of 2,784 crore from the central government.

Watch | Farmers explain the problem in Dholera

The funds, or the lack thereof, however, seem to be not the only hurdle that the project is up against. In December 2015, the state High Court ordered a status quo on land acquisition in the DSIR, in response to a petition by a group of farmers under the aegis of the NGO Gujarat Khedut Samaj (GKS) and a local organization, Bhal Bachao Samiti, who are contesting the government’s land pooling policy on grounds that it limits the powers of the Panchayat.

It’s a conflict that DSIR Development Authority (DSIRDA) planners were only hoping to avoid. With the Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation and Resettlement (LARR) Act, 2013, turning into the proverbial political hot potato and the messy processes of acquisition leading to a face-off between the owners and the government (or, the corporate) in several projects across the country, the alternative of pooling held much promise, policy experts and planners argued.

A Smart City hoarding in Dholera. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)
A Smart City hoarding in Dholera. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)

Land pooling -- at least on paper -- offers the new module of partnership between the owner and the developer. Here, the owner does not lose his property, as opposed to land acquisition, where the sale of land implies loss of all rights for the original owner.

Typically, after acquisition, a change in land use (from agricultural to commercial) leads to a rise in the price of the land, often creating enough ground for discontent and resentment among the original owners. For instance, in places such as Gurgaon and Faridabad, where the state government acquired land and transferred it to private developers, there’s widespread discontent among land owners who lament that while the developers made huge gains off the land, the farmers were left with a compensation that was incommensurate with the market price of the property anyway.

In pooling, however, the premise is that the owners are ‘willing’ partners who give up their land, and accrue the benefits of development. After the industries come in, roads, schools and hospitals are built up, the owner gets a portion of their land, the price of which has gone up now. The owner can either sell it, or build something of his own on it. “Gujarat has always had a progressive policy of acquisition, where farmers get a share in the benefits of industrial development,” says noted economist Yoginder K Alagh.

So what went wrong in Dholera? The answer lies in the Gujarat SIR Act, 2009, under which the state government can take 50% of the farmers’ land without compensation, and return the other half at a different site after “readjustment”. The logic here is that after development of the site, the price of the farmer’s land would increase, and he would be a direct beneficiary of it. “We are only taking barren land anyway, and also planning to give compensation for the 50% land that we are deducting,” a senior official from the DSIRDA says.

Bhagwanbhai has sold his land holdings and distributed the proceeds from the sale among his children. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)
Bhagwanbhai has sold his land holdings and distributed the proceeds from the sale among his children. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)

But farmers in Dholera are far from convinced. “The best quality of wheat in the country, the Bhaliya, grows here; if it rains moderately, there’s good cotton too. We also grow gram and cumin here. How can they say it’s barren?” says Bhagwanbhai, 65, a resident of Sarasla village.

The draft Environmental Impact Assessment report for the DSIR maintains the authority’s position on the fertility of the land in the region -- about 40% of land in Dholera is classified as“agricultural fallow land”, and only 7% is crop land, the report states.

However, activists such as Sagar Rabari of GKS refute this claim: “More than 60% of land in Dholera is fertile. Agricultural yield in the region amounts to 600-700 kg wheat per acre, and 400-500 per acre in cotton. Here, agriculture is still a profitable enterprise,” he insists.

Sagar Rabari of Khedut Samaj – Gujarat talks about farmer issues in Ahmedabad. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)
Sagar Rabari of Khedut Samaj – Gujarat talks about farmer issues in Ahmedabad. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)

Farmers in the region second his opinion, and add that if the state government resolved the water scarcity issue, they could plan multiple crops on the same land and enhance their yield by two-fold. The fact that there has been a delay in making that a possibility –the delay in the completion of the canal network that will deliver the waters of the Narmada to their fields — is also being perceived by the farmers as a “ploy” by the government to ensure that they would not hold on to their land.

Resistance to the project is further complicated by the mess of land records in the region, an issue that plagues several regions in the country. Take the case of Faljibhai Nagjibhai Bauliya , 38, of Haibatpur village, who claims to have 96 acres of land, of which not even one half is finds mention in the computerised land records of the area.

On a crisp cotton sheet spread on a wooden cot in his home in the village of Haibatpur, Faljibhai spreads out a stack of sepia-toned documents to substantiate his claim: land that his father received from the state in 1968 is still not in the computerised land records of the village.”The talathi (village revenue secretary) wouldn’t do it until we paid up,” says Faljibhai.

The mess of records can be traced to land reforms in the state, where landless families such as those of Faljibhai’s father received land under several schemes such as the Land Ceiling Act, the state tenancy law and the central government’s Santhani scheme (where government wastelands were redistributed to the landless), explains GKS’ Sagar.

However, he explains that the names of the new owners never made it to the records because of illiteracy, fragmentation of landholdings through the years and corrupt officials.

Now, with the DSIRDA planning to take their land for the project, farmers such as Faljibhai are only left wondering how the planners would allot them their rightful share of land after deduction.

Armed with information on the SIR Act by NGOs such as GKS, those such as Faljibhai argue that the policy doesn’t seem to be working in their favour.

For instance, Dholera’s farmers argue that shifting to a new plot would imply fresh investments be made on farm infrastructure such as tubewells, and brings with it the question of viability of agriculture in a new place. “Some villagers from nearby areas have told us that the new plots for us are being craved out of the saline area near the sea. We are not even educated enough to do much else; if agriculture fails, what are we going to do?” asks Faljibhai.

The fear of being given fallow and saline plots is predominant among the farmers of Dholera, who trace it to the emergence of real estate brokers in the area. These brokers deal in the sale and purchase of land, often a murky process involving the rich and powerful in the region, and beyond.

Faljibhai shows documents of his land which are not acknowledged in the computer records of the authorities. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)
Faljibhai shows documents of his land which are not acknowledged in the computer records of the authorities. (Saumya Khandelwal/ HT Photo)

It is in this trade and its underlying skewed power equations that farmers such as Faljibhai feel they might lose out. “Playing in real estate is not for farmers like us; it’s for the dalaals (middlemen),” he says.

Land pooling as a scheme rests on the logic that owners can become entrepreneurs in their own right, but residents of Dholera point to the clause in the SIR Act stating that aside of the development charge that they would have to pay on the new plot, they would need permission from the authority to build something. The new plots that would be given to the farmers would be in specific zones such as IT, entertainment, recreation sports, and if the farmer wanted to build a structure that didn’t fall in the zone of his new plot, he would need permission from the development authority.

The official from the DSIRDA told HT that in light of the resistance to the project, the authority is willing to negotiate with the farmers and even pay compensation in the lieu of the land deducted to address their concerns: “This project will increase job opportunities for the locals, and ensure that they benefit from the development of the region.”

But in the cotton fields of Sarasla, farmers say that for them, “development” implied better irrigation facilities for a robust yield. “ We don’t want the industries at the cost of our livelihood. We will resist this acquisition of our land. Jaan de denge par zameen nahi (we will give up our lives, but not the land),” says Roop Sang, as the group standing in his cotton field nods in agreement.

But Bhagwanbhai, who is landless now and depends on the trade in cattle feed procured from the fields, stops to correct them: “Jaan bhi mat do, aur zameen bhi mat do (Don’t give your lives, or your land)”, he tells them.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
File photo of Congress MP Karti Chidambaram.(PTI)
File photo of Congress MP Karti Chidambaram.(PTI)

Karti again raises demand that Priyanka Gandhi must contest Kanyakumari bypoll

By hindustantimes.com | Reported by Divya Chandrababu | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
UPDATED ON MAR 05, 2021 04:19 PM IST
This is the second time that Chidambaram, the Congress MP from Sivaganga, has made this demand. In November last year, he tweeted to say that Congress needs a 'bold move' and demanded that Priyanka Gandhi Vadra should contest the Kanyakumari bypoll.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi during virtual summit with Swedish PM Stefan Löfven.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi during virtual summit with Swedish PM Stefan Löfven.

At virtual summit with Sweden, PM Modi says ‘climate change a priority’

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 05, 2021 04:24 PM IST
Modi put spotlight on the nation’s achievements in the power sector in the recent years, and said, “India's renewable power capability has increased by 162% in the last five years.”
Close
A protest scene in Andhra Pradesh.
A protest scene in Andhra Pradesh.

Andhra observes bandh against privatisation of Visakhapatnam Steel Plant

By Srinivasa Rao Apparasu, Hindustan Tim, Es, Hyderabad
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 04:06 PM IST
Except the Bharatiya Janata Party, all the political parties, including the YSR Congress Party, the ruling party in the state, took part in the state bandh.
Close
An encounter between Maoists and the elite security force was underway, reports said. File Photo/Representational(HT Photo)
An encounter between Maoists and the elite security force was underway, reports said. File Photo/Representational(HT Photo)

Elite commando injured in landmine blast by Maoists in Maharashtra’s Gadchiroli

By Pradip Maitra | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Nagpur
UPDATED ON MAR 05, 2021 04:15 PM IST
  • On February 23, a Maoist camp was destroyed and an ambush against security forces was foiled by police in Gadchiroli district.
Close
Chennai secured the first spot under the quality of life category in the Ease of Living Index 2020 (AP (File))
Chennai secured the first spot under the quality of life category in the Ease of Living Index 2020 (AP (File))

Chennai fourth best city to live in, Coimbatore secures seventh spot

By Divya Chandrababu, Hindustan Times, Chennai
UPDATED ON MAR 05, 2021 04:04 PM IST
  • Centre releases 2020 ‘Ease of Living Index’, experts cite women safety, transportation to explain outcome
Close
Tamil Nadu chief minister Edappadi K Palaniswami and deputy CM O Panneerselvam figure in the first list of candidates released by AIADMK.
Tamil Nadu chief minister Edappadi K Palaniswami and deputy CM O Panneerselvam figure in the first list of candidates released by AIADMK.

TN CM, Dy CM to fight from strongholds as AIADMK releases 1st list of candidates

By Divya Chandrababu, Chennai
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 03:43 PM IST
  • A single-phase election to 234 assembly seats is scheduled for April 6 in Tamil Nadu.
Close
OTT platforms in India reach around 40 million customers and make up a market worth around Rs.3000 crore.(MINT_PRINT)
OTT platforms in India reach around 40 million customers and make up a market worth around Rs.3000 crore.(MINT_PRINT)

No provision in regulations to take action against digital platforms: SC

PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 03:38 PM IST
A bench comprising justices Ashok Bhushan and RS Reddy also issued notice to the Uttar Pradesh government on Purohit's plea for anticipatory bail in FIRs on Tandav series.
Close
Farmers shout slogans as they take part in a three-hour "chakka jam" on a highway.(REUTERS file photo)
Farmers shout slogans as they take part in a three-hour "chakka jam" on a highway.(REUTERS file photo)

Farmers to mark 100 days of stir by blocking key highway near Delhi

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Shivani
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 03:30 PM IST
  • The protesting farmers will block the six-lane Western Peripheral Expressway, also known as Kundli–Manesar–Palwal (KMP) Expressway for five hours, from 11 am to till 4 pm, Samyukta Kisan Morcha (SKM) announced on Wednesday.
Close
Goa BJP president Tanavade said the party would sort out all internal differences.(AP File Photo)
Goa BJP president Tanavade said the party would sort out all internal differences.(AP File Photo)

Goa: BJP relieves state spokesperson as dissension deepens in Panaji unit

By Gerard de Souza | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Panaji
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 03:10 PM IST
  • Former Goa CM and BJP stalwart Manohar Parrikar's son Utpal admitted he was breaking ranks with the party but stopped short of saying he was rebelling.
Close
The Supreme Court. (HT archive)
The Supreme Court. (HT archive)

Bar on transgender persons, others from donating blood: SC seeks govt’s response

By Abraham Thomas
UPDATED ON MAR 05, 2021 03:38 PM IST
Petitioner Santa Khurai, a Manipur-based Nupi Maanbi (traditional identity with the trans umbrella), challenged the constitutionality of clauses 12 and 51 of the guidelines that bar persons of gender and sexual minority groups as well as female sex workers from donating blood
Close
Apart from these, a special permit will also be required to visit any place that falls in the protected or restricted or prohibited areas.(HTPHOTO)
Apart from these, a special permit will also be required to visit any place that falls in the protected or restricted or prohibited areas.(HTPHOTO)

OCI card-holders need permit for 'Tabligh or journalistic activities': Centre

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Deepali Sharma, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 02:47 PM IST
Additionally, they will need permission if they want to undertake research, internship or employment in any foreign diplomatic missions, foreign government organisations in India.
Close
External affairs minister S Jaishankar. (File photo)
External affairs minister S Jaishankar. (File photo)

EAM Jaishankar receives Nigerian NSA Babagana Monguno

ANI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 02:36 PM IST
The information about the Babagana Monguno's arrival to India was shared by Jaishankar through his Twitter handle.
Close
In picture - Leader of Opposition Mukesh Agnihotri along with other Congress MLAs stages a protest outside the HP assembly. (PTI)
In picture - Leader of Opposition Mukesh Agnihotri along with other Congress MLAs stages a protest outside the HP assembly. (PTI)

Suspension of 5 Congress MLAs from Himachal Pradesh Assembly revoked

PTI, Shimla
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 02:34 PM IST
A resolution moved by Parliamentary Affairs Minister Suresh Bhardwaj for the revocation of their suspension was passed unanimously in the House.
Close
The entire incident happened when the flight was on the runway and about to take off to Pune.(REUTERS)
The entire incident happened when the flight was on the runway and about to take off to Pune.(REUTERS)

Chaos on Pune-bound IndiGo flight after passenger claims of being Covid positive

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 02:22 PM IST
The passenger, who claimed that he was Covid-19 positive, was handed over to the airport medical authority and his result came out positive.
Close
Lieutenant General Madhuri Kanitkar is the third woman in the Indian Armed Forces to be promoted to a three star rank. (Photo: Gokul VS/ HT)
Lieutenant General Madhuri Kanitkar is the third woman in the Indian Armed Forces to be promoted to a three star rank. (Photo: Gokul VS/ HT)

Didn’t expect a bed of roses, but the armed forces groomed me: Lieutenant General Madhuri Kanitkar

By Aprajita Sharad, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 05, 2021 03:47 PM IST
Lieutenant General Madhuri Kanitkar, the senior most woman officer in the Indian Army, talks about how the armed forces are now gradually seeing an increase in the presence of female youngsters.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP