The Supreme Court was hearing a plea by five people -- Navtej Johar, Sunil Mehra, Aman Nath, Ritu Dalmia and Ayesha Kapoor.(Mujeeb Faruqui/HT File photo)
The Supreme Court was hearing a plea by five people -- Navtej Johar, Sunil Mehra, Aman Nath, Ritu Dalmia and Ayesha Kapoor.(Mujeeb Faruqui/HT File photo)

SC to reconsider Section 377 that criminalises homosexuality

The Delhi High Court had read down the law in 2009, but the Supreme Court overruled it.
By Bhadra Sinha | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 08, 2018 08:35 PM IST

The Supreme Court said on Monday it will revisit its 2013 verdict upholding Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code that bans homosexual sexual acts, and referred a petition against the controversial colonial law to a larger bench.

A three-judge bench of the SC led by Chief Justice Dipak Misra said the 2013 judgment, which overturned a 2009 Delhi high court verdict that decriminalised consensual same-sex acts, was guided by the perception of majority and concept of social morality.

“Concept of consensual sex may have more priority than a group right and may require more protection. A section of people or individual who exercise their choice should never live in a state of fear,” the court said.

“What is natural to one may not be natural to the other.”

The petition, which challenges the legal validity of Section 377 on the ground that it is not a reasonable restriction because the law has the potential to destroy an individual’s choice and sexual orientation, was filed by five prominent members of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender (LGBT) community.

“The determination of order of nature is not a constant phenomenon. Societal morality also changes from age to age. Law copes with life and accordingly change takes place,” the SC said, asking the petitioners to provide a copy of the petition to the central government’s office so that the Centre can be represented in the case.

Read | SC refers Article 377 to larger bench: A timeline of legality of homosexuality in India

The petitioners – bharatnatyam dancer Navtej Johar, culture expert Aman Nath, restaurateurs Ritu Dalmia and Ayesha Kapur and mediaperson Sunil Mehra – had said they lived in fear because of Section 377 and the 2013 judgment ignored harassment and problems arising out of the law.

“It is a small victory but it has brought back some hope, for the first time. I am very happy about the development and have full faith in the court, the judiciary system and the Constitution,” Dalmia told Hindustan Times. “I think it (repealing of Section 377) is just a matter of time now.”

Section 377 punishes “carnal intercourse against the order of nature with man, woman or animal” with life imprisonment, though formal prosecution is rare. But activists allege the law forces LGBT people to live in fear and face blackmail, intimidation and pervasive discrimination.

The court noted it will not judge that portion of the law that criminalises intercourse with an animal. It also specified the discussion would be restricted to consenting adults so that children remain protected. “Consent between two adults has to be primary pre-condition otherwise children would become prey, which the constitution does not allow. Protection of children in all spheres has to be guided,” it said.

In 2009, Section 377 was read down by the Delhi high court, which decriminalised consensual adult same-sex relationships. But this was overturned in December 2013 by the top court, which asked Parliament to bring a law.

A two-judge bench headed by justice GS Singhvi had said “a miniscule fraction of the country’s population constitutes lesbians, gays, bisexuals or transgenders”.

A review petition against the decision was dismissed but a curative petition, the last available judicial recourse against an apex court decision, is pending in the SC. The top court has said that the curative will be decided on the limited grounds as raised in the petition. But the petition by the eminent LGBT personalities raised larger issues that needed consideration, it added.

Monday’s order holds out hope for LGBT activists as arguments in the case will be heard afresh and petitioners can draw support from last August’s right to privacy judgment that had upheld the right to sexual orientation and choice of sexual partners. A nine-judge bench of the court had observed that the chilling effect of Section 377 “poses a grave danger to the unhindered fulfillment of one’s sexual orientation, as an element of privacy and dignity.”

The CJI’s bench said natural and sexual orientation and choice could not be allowed to cross the boundaries of law. “But the confines of law cannot trample or curtail the inherent right embedded in an individual under article 21 (right to dignity),” the top court added.

While the court noted that Section 377 punishes “carnal intercourse against order of nature”, it added that “the determination of order of nature is not a common phenomenon. Individual autonomy and individual natural inclination cannot be atrophied unless the restrictions are determined as reasonable.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Immigrants walk across the Gateway International Bridge into Mexico after being sent out of Texas by US. (AFP)
Immigrants walk across the Gateway International Bridge into Mexico after being sent out of Texas by US. (AFP)

Undocumented Indian immigrants hold USD15.5 billion in spending power

PTI, Washington
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:48 AM IST
There are 4.2 million immigrants from Mexico who lack documentation. Together, they make up more than 40.8 percent of the 10.3 million undocumented immigrants in the United States.
Close
Chief principal secretary to the CM, K Kailashnathan, respectively, to oversee the re-development of the iconic Sabarmati Ashram and its precincts.(AP/Ajit Solanki)
Chief principal secretary to the CM, K Kailashnathan, respectively, to oversee the re-development of the iconic Sabarmati Ashram and its precincts.(AP/Ajit Solanki)

Guj cm, his aide in charge of Gandhi ashram revamp panel

By Darshan Desai, Ahmedabad
UPDATED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:46 AM IST
  • The order also said that Kailashnathan will head an executive council set up for the purpose,
Close
Addressing all the national officials of the Youth Congress, Rahul Gandhi hailed the workers as the “real power” of the party(ANI Photo)
Addressing all the national officials of the Youth Congress, Rahul Gandhi hailed the workers as the “real power” of the party(ANI Photo)

Help raise voice of the weak: Rahul to cadres

By Saubhadra Chatterji, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 04:57 AM IST
  • Congress is like an ocean, Gandhi said in the national executive meeting of the IYC, and if anyone wants to return can be allowed to do so.
Close
Narendra Modi.(PTI)
Narendra Modi.(PTI)

PM to visit B’desh on March 26

By Shishir Gupta, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 04:34 AM IST
  • The two-day trip to Dhaka will be Modi’s first foreign visit in 15 months
Close
Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla conducts proceedings during the second part of the Budget session on Monday. PTI
Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla conducts proceedings during the second part of the Budget session on Monday. PTI

Rising fuel prices rock Parliament

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 04:29 AM IST
  • Parties urge Speaker, Chairman to reduce sessions amid polls; both Houses to begin at 11 am from Tuesday
Close
Policemen outside the house in Batla House where inspector Mohan Chand Shama was killed during a shootout. HT Archive
Policemen outside the house in Batla House where inspector Mohan Chand Shama was killed during a shootout. HT Archive

Batla House: Ariz Khan held guilty of killing inspector

By Richa Banka, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 03:26 AM IST
  • Additional sessions judge Sandeep Yadav convicted 35-year-old Khan, also known as Junaid, Salim and Anna
Close
Farm subsidies worth thousands of crores — including cheap insurance, fertilisers, credit and income transfers — still suffer from leakages because very little information about individual farmers is centrally available.(Bloomberg file photo)
Farm subsidies worth thousands of crores — including cheap insurance, fertilisers, credit and income transfers — still suffer from leakages because very little information about individual farmers is centrally available.(Bloomberg file photo)

Govt building ‘agri stack’ to give unique ID to every Indian farmer

By Zia Haq, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:43 AM IST
  • The database uses Aadhaar-based data generated from key farm sector programmes such as PM-KISAN.
Close
Passengers queue to get their documents verified before entering the IGI Airport amid the lockdown in New Delhi on May 30, 2020.(Sanjeev Verma/HT Photo)
Passengers queue to get their documents verified before entering the IGI Airport amid the lockdown in New Delhi on May 30, 2020.(Sanjeev Verma/HT Photo)

Prominent warnings at IGI against carrying bullets soon

By Anvit Srivastava, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 02:33 AM IST
  • Police data shows that some of the 522 passengers nabbed in last 5 years while carrying live bullets in their bags claimed they had done so unknowingly
Close
The Act mandates all private establishments in Haryana to provide 75% of new jobs to local candidates.(Representational photo)
The Act mandates all private establishments in Haryana to provide 75% of new jobs to local candidates.(Representational photo)

Is the Haryana Act legal?

By Utkarsh Anand, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 09, 2021 02:23 AM IST
  • Private firms will likely claim that the law interferes with their constitutional rights to carry on trade freely
Close
The apex court has agreed to re-examine the 50% ceiling on reservations in India while hearing a case on the validity of 10% separate reservations for Marathas(Amal KS/HT PHOTO)
The apex court has agreed to re-examine the 50% ceiling on reservations in India while hearing a case on the validity of 10% separate reservations for Marathas(Amal KS/HT PHOTO)

Why reservation may fail in levelling the field

By Roshan Kishore, Abhishek Jha
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 01:58 AM IST
  • From SC-ST social groups, reservations have expanded to OBCs, economically weaker sections
Close
Rohingyas at Kiryani Talab in Jammu on Monday (HT Photo)
Rohingyas at Kiryani Talab in Jammu on Monday (HT Photo)

Fearing expulsion, Rohingyas in Jammu plead for protection

UPDATED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:04 AM IST
Over the weekend, police rounded up the 169 people from the city and took them to the Hiranagar jail detention centre
Close
The recovery in GST collections reflects the larger revival in the economy.(PTI)
The recovery in GST collections reflects the larger revival in the economy.(PTI)

Record GST collections expected in March, set to hit 1.30 lakh crore

By Rajeev Jayaswal, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:37 AM IST
  • The revenue in March may cross the record Rs.1,19,875 crore collected in January by at least Rs.10,000 crore.
Close
DU officials said that Tyagi was the first V-C in the university’s 100-year history to be suspended.(HT file)
DU officials said that Tyagi was the first V-C in the university’s 100-year history to be suspended.(HT file)

Report on probe against DU V-C Tyagi likely today

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 01:18 AM IST
  • Officials said that an inquiry committee, constituted by the Visitor of Delhi University (DU), the President of India, held its final meeting.
Close
Home minister Narottam Mishra tabled the bill in the legislative assembly.(PTI)
Home minister Narottam Mishra tabled the bill in the legislative assembly.(PTI)

MP assembly nod to anti-conversion bill

By Shruti Tomar, Bhopal
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 01:13 AM IST
  • BJP MLAs supported the bill and called it a gift for women on the occasion of Women’s Day
Close
According to BloombergQuint, in the case of one prominent private bank, only 25-30% of the OTPs were being delivered.
According to BloombergQuint, in the case of one prominent private bank, only 25-30% of the OTPs were being delivered.

Anti-spam tech halts OTP texts for some

PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 12:46 AM IST
  • The technology requires telecoms companies to scrub messages to verify if the text being sent has been approved and it is only being sent to someone who has consented to receive such a message.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP