Despite having gathered a group of critically appreciated actors, Madhur Bhandarkar fails to make the best use of them.
Despite having gathered a group of critically appreciated actors, Madhur Bhandarkar fails to make the best use of them.

Indu Sarkar movie review: Confused between criticising the sarkar and championing it

Indu Sarkar movie review: Madhur Bhandarkar’s latest film starring Kriti Kulhari and Neil Nitin Mukesh has a confused narrative and melodrama that dethrones the attempt to champion the cause of democracy.
By Sweta Kaushal | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JUL 28, 2017 06:28 PM IST

Indu Sarkar
Director: Madhur Bhandarkar
Cast: Kriti Kulhari, Neil Nitin Mukesh, Anupam Kher, Tota Roy Chowdhury, Sheeba Chaddha, Ankur Vikal and Zakir Hussain
Rating: 2/5

With the kind of publicity and controversies it attracted, almost everyone knows the basic premise of Madhur Bhandarkar’s film. Indu Sarkar, that hits theatres on Friday, is a political drama set against the backdrop of the Emergency.

Indu Sarkar opens with the announcement of the Emergency blaring from radio sets and glaring on front pages of newspapers. It then takes us to a fictitious village in Delhi-Haryana border area, Mubipura, where people are gearing up for a wedding. Suddenly, cops reach the place looking for men to be sterilized. When the men try to hide, the cops hunt them down and drag them even as a 70-year-old and a 13-year-old male ask policemen to consider the futility of including them in the government-ordered drive.

Indu Sarkar soon moves to the central character, Indu (Kriti) - an orphan who wants to become a poet but is told she must only dream to become a good wife and make a family. Following the advice, she marries Navin Sarkar (Tota Roy Chowdhury) who dreams of money, power and fame, while Indu’s dream is only to be a good wife. For almost half of the fiIm, Indu Sarkar remains the story of a docile, humble and meek orphan who surrenders to every whims and fancies of her husband even as she fights her own stammering and a lack of confidence.

How this rather “homely” woman stumbles upon victims of a police raid in a slum, decides to fight for them and eventually becomes one of the most powerful voices of dissent during the Emergency, form the rest of the narrative.

Neil Nitin Mukesh in a still from the film.
Neil Nitin Mukesh in a still from the film.

While the film was publicised as a film “on Emergency”, it actually oscillates between a political drama and a typical Bollywood film about a couple. Unfortunately, the transition between the two narratives is neither smooth nor convincing.

One of the saddest moments in the movie comes when Indu, after she has left her husband’s house for the sake of a couple of lost orphan kids, decides to sign the divorce papers Navin sends. When asked why she agreed for the divorce, she says, “Saath reh kar acchi biwi nahi ban payi, ho sakta hai alag ho kar sukh de paun. (I could not be a good wife, maybe I can give him some comfort by staying away).” As if, all the protest and fight for freedom from a dictatorial government was nothing but a tool to pacify the husband.

The background score of Indu Sarkar is too loud and misplaced. At times when a rather emotional moment is approaching, what you hear is the loud melodramatic sound usually used in Bollywood suspense dramas.

Anupam Kher in a in a still from the film.
Anupam Kher in a in a still from the film.

Despite having gathered a group of critically appreciated actors, Madhur Bhandarkar fails to make the best use of them. Neil Nitin Mukesh is one of the most wasted talents in the movie. He has given some of his best performances as a mean, high-on-power person but his act as “chief” in Indu Sarkar appears too superficial. Anupam Kher and Kriti Kulhari take the lead in acting department and stay true to their characters for most of the part. The supporting casts including Sheeba Chaddha, Ankur Vikal and Zakir Hussain, among others appear genuine in their roles.

Neil Nitin Mukesh in a still from the film.
Neil Nitin Mukesh in a still from the film.

However, the over-dramatic tone of the film kills their performances and leaves us with dialogues like “Ek goli ne mere jawan, 6 foot ke bete ko 6 inch ki tasveer bana diya.”

Trying to find logic in Indu Sarkar often becomes a task. For example, why does Indu keep roaming around in a rickshaw/auto in the Turkman Gate area every time she needs to witness an eye-opener about the Emergency when she is otherwise driven around in her husband’s car? Or, for that matter, why do the protesters (led by Anupam Kher as ‘Nanaji’) keep naming each other when they meet inside a cinema hall to avoid getting caught by the cops? Isn’t the entire purpose of disguise defeated if they use the real names? What is the reason, do you ask? Well, Bollywood is the only word that comes to our mind.

Kriti Kulhari in a still from the film.
Kriti Kulhari in a still from the film.

For those interested in the politics of films, there are two ways to look at Madhur Bhandarkar’s Indu Sarkar.

One is to look it as a propaganda film against the Congress party, aims at showcasing the atrocities inflicted upon various communities during the Emergency. There is a subtle, yet, extremely clear attempt to highlight Muslims forming a major portion of the victims. We have Neil Nitin Mukesh channelling Sanjay Gandhi as the prime minister’s son who is only referred to as the “chief” while the PM is referred to as “mummyji”. The unofficial ban on Kishore Kumar from radio and television after he refused to sing for Sanjay Gandhi also gets a mention in the film.

On the other hand, you can see Indu Sarkar as a double-edged sword. While it depicts the Emergency and the Gandhi family as the perpetrators of cruelty and injustice inflicted upon the masses, the film actually shows the misuse of power. If Madhur Bhandarkar wanted to patronise the ruling party, the irony of his own film is lost on him. The irony of Indu Sarkar is that it is so indulgent in highlighting the importance of free speech and democracy that you could change a few names, few other situations and it could well have been a film about the crisis India is facing today: People with allegiances to the ruling party exploiting the masses and even politicians at their own will.

So, in the sheer hope that Madhur actually aimed for the latter political purpose, two stars for Indu Sarkar.

Follow @htshowbiz for more

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Tiger Shroff turned 31 on Tuesday.
Tiger Shroff turned 31 on Tuesday.

Watch baby Tiger Shroff calling for world peace, in throwback video on birthday

UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 09:38 PM IST
  • Here's a video of almost-baby Tiger Shroff, taking to the stage with his father, Jackie, back in the early 1990s.
Close
Kishwer Merchant and Suyyash Rai have also appeared on Bigg Boss together.
Kishwer Merchant and Suyyash Rai have also appeared on Bigg Boss together.

Kishwer-Suyyash announce first pregnancy with special post: 'Coming in August'

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 08:21 PM IST
  • Kishwer Merchant and Suyyash Rai announced on Tuesday that they are expecting their first child. Check out their Instagram posts.
Close
Armaan Malik is known to be quite vocal on social media about the issues pertaining to the music industry.
Armaan Malik is known to be quite vocal on social media about the issues pertaining to the music industry.

Armaan Malik: I do not believe in talking about religion or politics on social media

By Sugandha Rawal
UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 08:21 PM IST
Singer Armaan Malik says he has his own beliefs and way of thinking, but he doesn’t feel the need to voice that, because someone or the other will take offence to it.
Close
Actor Saif Ali Khan headlines Ali Abbas Zafar’s web show Tandav.(HT_PRINT)
Actor Saif Ali Khan headlines Ali Abbas Zafar’s web show Tandav.(HT_PRINT)

Tandav row: Amazon issues fresh apology, says 'we respect viewers' beliefs'

PTI
UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 08:26 PM IST
  • Amazon Prime Video has issued a new apology over the legal cases surrounding the political drama Tandav. Read it here.
Close
Deepika Padukone, in a still from the ad.
Deepika Padukone, in a still from the ad.

Deepika's ad called out for plagiarism by Yeh Ballet director Sooni Taraporevala

UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 08:29 PM IST
  • The creatives behind an apparel advertisement featuring Deepika Padukone have been accused of plagiarism by Yeh Ballet filmmaker Sooni Taraporevala, who has called the incident 'intellectual theft'.
Close
BTS singer V and his friend Peakboy worked on Snow Flower, which released in December 2020.
BTS singer V and his friend Peakboy worked on Snow Flower, which released in December 2020.

BTS's V drops vlog featuring his workout session, his friend Peakboy and more

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 07:01 PM IST
  • BTS singer V released his vlog on YouTube, which featured a few behind-the-scenes glimpses at his song Snow Flower with Peakboy, his workout session, and more.
Close
The Heropanti 2 and Hitman movie posters, side-by-side.
The Heropanti 2 and Hitman movie posters, side-by-side.

Fans aren't fooled by Tiger's Heropanti 2 look, point out similarities to Hitman

UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 07:00 PM IST
  • Fans have once again spotted similarities between Tiger Shroff's character in Heropanti 2, and Agent 47 in the Hitman video game series. A new poster for the film debuted on Tuesday.
Close
BLACKPINK singer Rose in her solo debut poster.
BLACKPINK singer Rose in her solo debut poster.

BLACKPINK's Rosé solo debut release date out, see teaser poster

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 06:27 PM IST
  • BLACKPINK member Rosé shared posters to confirm that she will make her solo debut on March 12. Her fellow BLACKPINK members Jisoo, Lisa and Jennie extend their support.
Close
Devi featured an ensemble cast including Kajol, Neha Dhupia, Shruti Haasan among others.
Devi featured an ensemble cast including Kajol, Neha Dhupia, Shruti Haasan among others.

Kajol's Devi turns 1, she says the film brings 'a lump to my throat till today'

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 06:27 PM IST
  • Kajol celebrated the completion of one year of her short film, Devi. She mentioned how the film could still make her emotional.
Close
Parineeti Chopra plays Saina Nehwal in the biopic.
Parineeti Chopra plays Saina Nehwal in the biopic.

Twitter fact-checks Parineeti's Saina biopic for incorrect serve on poster

UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 06:15 PM IST
  • Several Twitter users pointed out that the poster for the upcoming Saina Nehwal biopic, starring Parineeti Chopra, appears to show an incorrect serve action.
Close
Disha Patani and John Abraham on sets of Ek Villain Returns.(Instagram)
Disha Patani and John Abraham on sets of Ek Villain Returns.(Instagram)

John Abraham, Disha Patani on Ek Villain Returns sets. See pics

UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 06:06 PM IST
  • John Abraham and Disha Patani have begun working on their upcoming film, Ek Villain Returns. See pics.
Close
Tiger Shroff and Disha Patani spotted after dinner on Monday night. (Varinder Chawla)
Tiger Shroff and Disha Patani spotted after dinner on Monday night. (Varinder Chawla)

Tiger Shroff, Disha Patani, his mom Ayesha step out for quiet dinner, see pics

UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 05:37 PM IST
  • Tiger Shroff, who turned a year older on Tuesday, was spotted with rumoured girlfriend Disha Patani and his mother Ayesha Dutt on a dinner outing.
Close
Ankita Lokhande parties with Rashami Desai.
Ankita Lokhande parties with Rashami Desai.

After calling out Sushant's fans, Ankita Lokhande parties with Rashami Desai

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 05:03 PM IST
  • Ankita Lokhande has shared several pictures and videos from a house party she had with Rashami Desai on Monday.
Close
Shaza Morani and Priyaank Sharma had a court marriage in February.
Shaza Morani and Priyaank Sharma had a court marriage in February.

Shaza Morani, Priyaank Sharma's Hindu wedding postponed with just days to go

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 04:30 PM IST
  • Shaza Morani and Priyaank Sharma's Hindu wedding ceremony has been postponed, in light of the increase in Covid-19 cases in Maharashtra. The couple and their families and friends are currently in the Maldives.
Close
Sharmila Tagore met her granddaughter Inaaya after more than a year.
Sharmila Tagore met her granddaughter Inaaya after more than a year.

After reunion with grandma Sharmila in Pataudi, Inaaya goes on walk with Soha

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 04:29 PM IST
Soha Ali Khan has shared new pictures and videos with her daughter Inaaya, as they took a walk around their ancestral home in Pataudi.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP