Sign in

‘Vulgar, propaganda’: IFFI’s jury head on The Kashmir Files

The closing ceremony of the 53rd International Film Festival of India stoked a controversy on Monday with festival jury chair Nadav Lapid saying that members of the jury were disturbed and shocked by the Kashmir Files, a movie he described as “vulgar propaganda”

Updated on: Nov 29, 2022, 00:53:23 IST
Share
Share via
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
Copy link
  • copy link

The closing ceremony of the 53rd International Film Festival of India stoked a controversy on Monday with festival jury chair Nadav Lapid saying that members of the jury were disturbed and shocked by the Kashmir Files, a movie he described as “vulgar propaganda”.

‘Vulgar, propaganda’: IFFI’s jury head on The Kashmir Files
‘Vulgar, propaganda’: IFFI’s jury head on The Kashmir Files

The Kashmir Files, which deals with the 1990 exodus of Kashmiri Pandits, was part of the pool of 15 films competing in the international section for the golden peacock, the festival’s top prize.

But Lapid, an Israeli screenwriter and director who has won awards at the Cannes and Berlin film festivals, said that while members of the jury had vivid discussions about the other 14 films in the competition, the 15th left them shocked. “We were all of us disturbed and shocked by the 15th film by the movie Kashmir Files that felt for us like a vulgar propaganda movie inappropriate for an artistic competitive section of such a prestigious film festival,” he said from a lectern in the televised closed ceremony.

Also read: Expect freezing nights, haze in Kashmir till Dec 7: IMD

“I feel totally comfortable to share these feelings with you on stage since the feeling we felt at this festival can truly accept a critical discussion, which is essential for art and for life,” Lapid added.

The Kashmir Files was screened at IFFI while actor Anupam Kher, director Vivek Agnihotri and producer were present at the festival. The Hindi language drama was a top grosser this year and received support from some members of the Bharatiya Janata Party but was derided by some scholars for inaccuracies.

Also read: You can’t jail an idea: Mehbooba on resolution of Kashmir issue

Director general of Press Information Bureau and one of IFFI’S organisers, Monideepa Mukherjee, said that chairman of the jury was entitled to his comments. “The jury, which addressed a press conference, earlier during the festival, said that at every festival you will have a wide range of films. He is entitled to his opinion,” Mukherjee said.

  • Gerard de Souza
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Gerard de Souza

    Gerard de Souza is a Special Correspondent based in Goa and has been reporting on and about issues concerning the state and the wider western coast of India for over 18 years. His wide range of stories covers politics, crime, environment and tourism-related concerns emerging from India’s smallest state. Born and brought up in Goa, he has a deep understanding of the former Portuguese enclave’s evolution from a laidback collection of idyllic villages that first drew flower power generation of counter culture enthusiasts to its shores to one that has become synonymous in Indian popular culture with an aspirational holiday, seeing the best (and worst) that holidayers have to offer. He also keenly follows criminal trials. Most notably, he covered the trial surrounding the killing of Scarlett Keeling, a British teenager found dead on Anjuna beach, and that of Danielle McLaughlin similarly killed in south Goa, among others. He authored the book ‘Crimes of Passion: When Desire Turns Deadly,’ chronicling cases of romance turning to rage and murder. A graduate of Goa University, he learnt the trade on the job and has experience on both the reporting and editorial sides of the profession. When not sniffing around for a worthy headline, he likes to spend time outdoors to help ensure his heart is always in the right place.Read More