The saga of Gumnami Baba lives on

Now the writer of the letter that made Sahai panel reject claims about Gumnami Baba says she doesn’t remember writing the letter(FILE PHOTO)
Now the writer of the letter that made Sahai panel reject claims about Gumnami Baba says she doesn’t remember writing the letter(FILE PHOTO)
Published on Dec 27, 2019 08:06 PM IST
Copy Link
By, Lucknow

The writer of the letter that apparently helped Justice (retired) Vishnu Sahai commission to conclude that Gumnami Baba alias Bhagwanji was not Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose has strongly contested the panel’s findings, insisting that she was a minor when the purported letter was written and that she still believed that Gumnami Baba only was Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.

“I was a minor on October 16, 1980 when the letter was written. I don’t remember writing any such letter. However, if I wrote the letter at all, it must have been at the behest of my father who strongly believed Gumnami Baba alias Bhagwanji was Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. I belived and still believe that Gumnami Baba alias Bhagwanji was Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose,” said the writer of the letter Bulbul, now Suhita Bhattacharya, when contacted on the issue.

Bulbul said she was not aware about the commission and when did it call the witnesses for examination. “The commission should have called me as a witness if it was relying on my letter. I did not appear before the commission on my own as I was not aware about its inquiry and examination of the witnesses. I am surprised and shocked to know that my letter has been used to reach a conclusion on such an important issue,” said Bulbul.

In concluding paras of the Commission’s report, Justice Sahai has observed that he came across evidence demolishing the claims of those affirming that Gumnami Baba was Netaji while inspecting documents in district treasury in the office of district magistrate of Faizabad (now Ayodhya) on June 22, 2017.

“I came across another example demolishing the claims on June 22, 2017 when I inspected ‘chhoti manjusha’ (small box) and ‘Badi Manjusha’ (big box) at the treasury that had items recovered from Ram Bhawan, Faizabad where Gumnami Baba alias Bhagwanji lived… As the letters kept in the boxes were in Bengali, I took them with me to the residence of Ronodev Ghosh (resident of 10, Gopal Nagar, Krishna Nagar, Lucknow) who was well versed in Bengali and he explained the letter to me in English…,” said Sahai.

Quoting the letter, Sahai said “This letter is dated October 16, 1980. This letter has been sent by Bulbul from Kolkata. This reads, ‘When will you come to my place. We will be very happy if you visit on the birthday of Netaji’.”

He further said Bulbul’s letter made it clear that Shricharan Kamlendu (Guruji) was Gumnami Baba alias Bhagwanji.

“As in this letter Bulbul clearly stated ‘We will be very happy if you visit on the birthday of Netaji’, it is clear that Gumnami Baba alias Bhagwanji was not Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose,” said Sahai in concluding paras, adding, “Above conversation is making it clear it cannot be ascertained from the items recovered from the part of Ram Bhawan (where Gumnami Baba lived before his death) that Gumnami Baba alias Bhagwanji was Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.”

When contacted, Sahai refused to make any comments on the observations and said he would not say anything beyond the commission’s report.

In its report, the commission, however, has referred to witness number 10 (CW-10) Ashok Tandon, who, it said, had closely examined the literature, letters and documents recovered. The commission noted that on the basis of examination of literature, letters and documents, Tandon concluded that Gumnami Baba was Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. The commission quoting Tandon said no one was allowed to call Gumnami Baba as Subhash Chandra Bose and he was addressed as Shricharnesh, Shradha Sabdesh and Swamiji.

It may be mentioned that writer duo of 2019 book “Conundrum: Subhas Bose’s life after death” Chandrachur Ghose and Anuj Dhar too has contested the commission’s conclusion saying the commission did not examine the evidence available before it scientifically and thus the report deserved to be rejected outrightly.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Umesh Raghuvanshi is a journalist with over three decade experience. He covers politics, finance, environment and social issues. He has covered all assembly and parliament elections in Uttar Pradesh since 1984.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The accident spot on the Kundli Manesar Palwal (KMP) Expressway near Asoda toll plaza in Jhajjar’s Bahadurgarh area where three labourers were run over and killed by a truck early on Thursday. Eleven labourers were injured in the accident. (Manoj Dhaka/HT)

    3 labourers killed, 11 injured as truck runs over them on KMP e-way

    Three labourers were killed and 11 injured when a truck ran over them on the Kundli-Manesar-Palwal Expressway near Asoda toll plaza in Jhajjar's Bahadurgarh area early on Thursday, police said. Eleven of them were rushed to the civil hospital in Bahadurgarh from where 10 workers were referred to Rohtak's Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, where their condition is stated to be critical. Four labourers escaped unhurt.

  • Bengaluru received around a 100 mm of rains that inundated the city when compared to other cities like Chennai and Mumbai, where it takes almost double the amount of downpour. (PTI)

    Bengaluru rains: Schools declare holidays, hungry citizens await food packets

    Several schools across Karnataka have declared holidays with the state lashed by heavy rains this week; capital Bengaluru is on 'yellow alert' for Thursday. Bengaluru reeled under heavy downpours on Tuesday and Wednesday, when more than 3,000 houses flooded and properties worth lakhs of rupees was damaged. Districts like Dakshina Kannada, Shivamogga, Mandya and Mysuru have also announced holidays for their schools and sent those who attended back home.

  • In a push towards medical education in Karnataka, an All India Institute Of Medical Science (AIIMS) will soon be established in the state.

    Karnataka to get an AIIMS: Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya

    In a move that will greatly boost Karnataka's Health and Medical Education sector, Union Minister for Health and Family Welfare Dr Mansukh Mandaviya gave a green signal for establishing an All India Institute Of Medical Science in Karnataka. The assurance was given during a meeting between Karnataka Health Minister Dr K Sudhakar and Union Minister Dr Mansukh Mandaviya in New Delhi on Wednesday.

  • SSLC students dealing with results stress can now contact a helpline designed to address mental health issues.

    Karnataka opens mental health helpline for SSLC students to cope with stress

    For the first time in the history of Karnataka, the state has opened a mental health tele-helpline for students who are in distress as they await their Secondary School Leaving Certificate (SSLC) for Class 10 results on Wednesday. "Success and failure are a part of life and they are like two faces of the same coin. SSLC students expecting results must not lose hope at all costs," said Karnataka Health Minister Dr K Sudhakar today.

  • The HC cited the General Finance Rules 2017 which does not permit unregistered entities from participating in tenders if the bidder is from a country which shares a land border with India. (AP Photo/Aijaz Rahi)

    HC shelves tender from Karnataka health dept  on national security concerns

    The Karnataka High Court has stayed all further proceedings in relation to a tender issued by the state Department of Health and Family Welfare in favour of a firm that is an agent of a Chinese company. Philips India Limited had filed an intra-court appeal after its request for a stay on the tender issued to Foress Healthcare LLP was not considered by the court earlier.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, May 19, 2022