Two years later, in 2018, the evidence of its effectiveness was questioned by a research institute.(Reuters Photo)
Two years later, in 2018, the evidence of its effectiveness was questioned by a research institute.(Reuters Photo)

In China, questions raised over efficacy of smog towers

Within months, China’s state-controlled media had trashed the tower, calling it an “eyewash” and ineffective in a megacity with more than 20 million people like Beijing.
By Sutirtho Patranobis | Hindustan Times, Beijing
UPDATED ON NOV 14, 2019 07:30 PM IST

Beijing: China’s experiment with installing giant outdoor “smog-free towers” in its polluted cities haven’t had the desired results despite generating interest when first talked about in 2016.

Instead, emission control remains the only effective way to control pollution, experts told HT.

A seven metre high anti-smog tower, designed by Dutch designer Daan Roosegaarde, was the first to be put up in an art district in Beijing in 2016.

It was the last.

Within months, China’s state-controlled media had trashed the tower, calling it an “eyewash” and ineffective in a megacity with more than 20 million people like Beijing.

A larger, skyscraper-sized smog-tower was also built in Xi’an, the capital of northwest China’s Shaanxi province, another heavily polluted city, the same year.

Two years later, in 2018, the evidence of its effectiveness was questioned by a research institute.

“A skyscraper-sized air purifier curbed pollution by about 15% in a 10-square kilometer area over two years in one of China’s most polluted cities,” the state-controlled tabloid, Global Times said in a report.

“It would take about 1,000 to do the same for the entire city of Xi’an,” the tabloid quoted Cao Junji, from the Institute of Earth Environment at the Chinese Academy of Sciences as saying.

The 60-meter-high air purifier cost 12 million yuan ($1.91 million) when it was installed in 2016.

About 1,000 such structures could handle 10,000 square kilometers, Cao said.

“It is costly and works for a limited area like 100 metres, and the pollutants can be easily transported to clean air (area) again. It is not practical to use these (smog-towers) to control air pollution,” Hongliang Zhang from the Department of Environmental Science and Engineering from Shanghai’s Fudan University told HT.

“People build it for reasons but no one academia thinks it is effective,” Hongliang added.

“The haze towers in Chinese cities have not been used much; their effectiveness is limited to 100 metres (in the immediate surrounding areas). It has a limited effect on the environment,” a Liping Zhang, a consultant on pollution based in eastern China’s Hangzhou said.

“The economic feasibility of such towers is relatively poor for improving the environment on a large scale. They could have an impact on the environment at a very local level,” Liping added.

“Emission is the only way to control pollution,” Hongliang, the first expert, said.

In March, Beijing announced that it will allocate 25 billion yuan or $3.73 billion to prevent and control air pollution, an increase by 25% year on year.

As for the towers, they could probably work as anti-pollution symbols but the cost involved in building such structures in the first place puts a question mark on the projects.

The one already put up in Beijing, for example, has since been renamed as “smog reminder” instead of the more ambitious “smog tower”, state media reported, adding that the structure was retained for educational purposes.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam, right, talks with fellow delegates after the opening session of China's National People's Congress (NPC).(AP)
Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam, right, talks with fellow delegates after the opening session of China's National People's Congress (NPC).(AP)

Hong Kong reforms prevent 'dictatorship of the majority': Pro-Beijing lawmaker

Posted by Kunal Gaurav | Reuters, Beijing
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 08:02 PM IST
The Chinese parliament is discussing plans to overhaul Hong Kong's electoral system to ensure Beijing loyalists are in charge.
Close
His aggressive behaviour prompted the flight's commander to seek an emergency landing in Sofia.(Reuters)
His aggressive behaviour prompted the flight's commander to seek an emergency landing in Sofia.(Reuters)

Unruly Indian man forces Air France flight to make emergency landing in Bulgaria

Reuters, Sofia
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:56 PM IST
The passenger, an Indian citizen, began to act up soon after take-off, quarrelling with other passengers, assaulting a flight attendant and pummelling the cockpit's door.
Close
William Burns, nominee for CIA director, testifies during his Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington.(via REUTERS)
William Burns, nominee for CIA director, testifies during his Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington.(via REUTERS)

US senator Cruz puts hold on Biden's CIA pick Burns over Nord Stream 2 pipeline

Posted by Kunal Gaurav | Reuters, Washington
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:47 PM IST
The Senate Intelligence Committee this week backed William Burns, a former ambassador to Russia, by a unanimous vote.
Close
Egypt's President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi(Reuters)
Egypt's President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi(Reuters)

Egypt's Sisi visits Sudan with dam diplomacy, security on the agenda

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:44 PM IST
Sisi was also due to discuss Red Sea security and developments on Sudan's borders during his visit to Khartoum, Egypt's presidency said in a statement.
Close
Anti-government protesters gesture, outside the Criminal court during a protest in Bangkok, Thailand.(AP)
Anti-government protesters gesture, outside the Criminal court during a protest in Bangkok, Thailand.(AP)

Hundreds of Thai protesters rally to demand leaders' release

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:43 PM IST
  • A youth-led protest movement sprang up last year calling for the resignation of Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha, a former junta leader, and reform of the powerful monarchy. Thai courts have denied recent requests for bail for some of the jailed protest leaders.
Close
The EMA launched an investigation with Dutch and European law enforcement authorities, but has so far provided no details on who may have carried out the attacks.(Getty Images/iStockphoto)
The EMA launched an investigation with Dutch and European law enforcement authorities, but has so far provided no details on who may have carried out the attacks.(Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Russian, Chinese hackers targeted Europe drug regulator: Reports

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:40 PM IST
  • The Amsterdam-based European drug regulator in December reported a cyberattack in which documents relating to COVID-19 vaccines and medicines were stolen and leaked on the internet.
Close
Stephen Cornish, general director for the operational Center of MSF demonstrates outside the WTO to waive intellectual property rights on Covid-19.(REUTERS)
Stephen Cornish, general director for the operational Center of MSF demonstrates outside the WTO to waive intellectual property rights on Covid-19.(REUTERS)

World divided on India’s waiver proposal to WTO on Covid. What are the arguments

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Kunal Gaurav
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 06:55 PM IST
  • Last month, commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal expressed hope that the global pharmaceutical industry will show "big heart" and support India’s proposal.
Close
German Chancellor Angela Merkel attends a news conference.(AP)
German Chancellor Angela Merkel attends a news conference.(AP)

Pandemic risks undoing gains for women, Germany's Merkel warns

AFP
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 06:27 PM IST
  • "We have to make sure that the pandemic does not lead us to fall back into old gender patterns we thought we had overcome," Merkel said in a video message ahead of International Women's Day on March 8.
Close
Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak(Reuters)
Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak(Reuters)

UK takes step that may impact tax loophole favored by big tech

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 06:27 PM IST
  • Sunak’s plan repeals legislation that means companies based in European Union member states could stop benefiting from tax exemptions on intra-group interest and royalties payments.
Close
American poet Amanda Gorman recites a poem during the Inauguration of US President Joe Biden at the US Capitol in Washington.(AP)
American poet Amanda Gorman recites a poem during the Inauguration of US President Joe Biden at the US Capitol in Washington.(AP)

‘One day, an icon, next day, a threat’: Amanda Gorman on being racially profiled

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 06:36 PM IST
  • Gorman made the response to her own tweet from February in which she had shared a profile done by Washington Post on her and talked about the disparity between herself and "everyday Black girls."
Close
Police have recovered murder weapons including a knife and an axe.(Representational )
Police have recovered murder weapons including a knife and an axe.(Representational )

5-member Hindu family killed in Pakistan

ANI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:54 PM IST
  • The members of the family were found dead with their throats slit with some sharp-edged weapon in their house in Abu Dhabi Colony, Chak No 135-P, 15-kilometre away from Rahim Yar Khan city, reported The News International.
Close
There’s also a chance that China could be waiting for global climate talks in November to upgrade its goals.(Reuters file photo. Representative image)
There’s also a chance that China could be waiting for global climate talks in November to upgrade its goals.(Reuters file photo. Representative image)

China’s top leaders leave tough climate decisions to bureaucrats

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:44 PM IST
The world’s second-biggest economy said Friday it plans to lower emissions per unit of gross domestic product by 18% by 2025—the same level it targeted in the previous five-plan.
Close
A large rescue operation early Saturday involved dozens of firefighters, paramedics and helicopters to transport the injured to hospitals. (Representative Image)(AP)
A large rescue operation early Saturday involved dozens of firefighters, paramedics and helicopters to transport the injured to hospitals. (Representative Image)(AP)

Bus accident in Poland kills six Ukrainians, injures 41

AP
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:18 PM IST
The accident occurred around midnight on the A4 motorway near the town of Jaroslaw, which is in southeastern Poland near the border with Ukraine.
Close
China has planned a fundamental overhaul of the city's normally contentious politics, the New York Times reported.(REUTERS)
China has planned a fundamental overhaul of the city's normally contentious politics, the New York Times reported.(REUTERS)

EU warns Beijing to tread carefully on Hong Kong electoral reform

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | ANI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:14 PM IST
On March 4, the National People's Congress in China announced that it would deliberate on amending the electoral system of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, according to a statement from the bloc dated Friday.
Close
Large protests have occurred daily across many cities and towns. Security forces responded with greater use of lethal force and mass arrests. At least 18 protesters were shot and killed last Sunday and 38 on Wednesday, according to the UN Human Rights Office.(AP)
Large protests have occurred daily across many cities and towns. Security forces responded with greater use of lethal force and mass arrests. At least 18 protesters were shot and killed last Sunday and 38 on Wednesday, according to the UN Human Rights Office.(AP)

Myanmar: Protests reported in Myitkyina, Myeik and Dawei, tear gas fired

AP, Yangon
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:06 PM IST
Fresh protests were reported Saturday morning in the biggest city of Yangon, where stun grenades and tear gas were used against protesters.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP