Delhi HC dismisses plea seeking memorial for army personnel at Red Fort

New DelhiThe Delhi High Court on Wednesday dismissed a petition seeking the establishment of a dedicated memorial at the Red Fort for the personnel of the Indian National Army (INA) who died in the line of duty, saying that it could not direct the government to set aside land for such a purpose

New Delhi

A bench of chief justice DK Upadhyaya and justice Tejas Karia observed that establishing a memorial was not linked to an enforceable duty or legal right. (Representative photo)

The Delhi High Court on Wednesday dismissed a petition seeking the establishment of a dedicated memorial at the Red Fort for the personnel of the Indian National Army (INA) who died in the line of duty, saying that it could not direct the government to set aside land for such a purpose.

A bench of chief justice DK Upadhyaya and justice Tejas Karia observed that establishing a memorial was not linked to an enforceable duty or legal right. It added that announcements made through Press Information Bureau (PIB) releases, by themselves, could not form the basis for claiming a legal right.

“Is this a justiciable issue? Nobody berates those martyrs in whose honour and respect you want to erect the memorial but can that become a subject matter of a writ petition? Erection of a memorial is not linked to any duty or right. How can we pass such a direction? How can we direct the government to allocate a land in Red Fort and erect a memorial,” the bench said.

It added, “The announcements made through PIB press releases, in our opinion, do not itself, can form the basis of seeking any right.”

In its petition, the trust asserted that the Centre, in its written reply in the Lok Sabha on August 2, 2021, had approved several proposals related to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, including a proposal to construct a memorial at Red Fort for INA martyrs, and despite the same, no memorial had been established. It contended that the government’s failure violated the fundamental right to equality and the right to life and personal liberty.

The court, however, granted the trust liberty to approach the relevant government ministry by way of a representation. It said that in case the trust filed a representation, the government must pass a reasoned order.