Painting Mughals as looters to hailing ‘Indian’ heroes: How to rewrite history

From pushing leaders such as Mahatma Gandhi to the margins to painting Mughal rulers as looters and celebrating ‘India’ heroes, the attempts to rewrite school history textbooks have multiplied in recent years.

Uttar Pradesh deputy chief minister Dinesh Sharma said that Mughal rulers played no role in Indian history except plundering the country – reason, according to him, to rewrite history text books. Sharma added that the state government was working towards introducing a new school syllabus. Sharma is not alone. His counterparts in BJP-ruled states have been finding ‘faults’ in history (see accompanying stories) time and again.

Mohit Suneja/HT

The RSS has been publicising what it thinks is the appropriate version of history through its Saraswati Shiksha Mandir Prakashan and Vidya Bharti Publications. The recent trend is to use the state government resources and institutions to rewrite history, omit important figures, promote a communal angle. “They are doing it in the pursuit of a Hindu Rashtra,” said historian Harbans Mukhia, whose area of specialisation is medieval India. “The idea is to present an ‘Indianised’ version of history. Indian, in this case, equals Hindu, which equals Hindutva. And Muslim is the common enemy in this scheme of things.” Other than the criticism that history textbooks create heroes out of ‘Muslim rulers,’ a frequent charge is that Marxist historians have enjoyed a monopoly over history writing. But assertions without solid research cannot replace scholarship.

The positive thing, Mukhia said, is that the discipline of history has moved beyond the binaries of Hindu and Muslim. “This is not the Stone Age. We are now talking about the history of ecology, habitats and different sciences,” he said.