...
...
Next Story

Review:Kurbaan

Kurbaan's script seems what they call man ghadant. The speeches are merely political, their pains are personal, not a work of indoctrination. They appear at best a rag-tag cottage firm out to bomb and bleed America to death. Here's Mayank Shekhar's full review.

Updated on: Nov 21, 2009, 15:21:11 IST
Hindustan Times | By , New Delhi
Prefer HTon Google
Advertisement
kurbaan
kurbaan

No police. I’m gonna deal with them myself," says Vivek Oberoi’s Ayaaz, I suspect, to his audience’s gentle snigger. This gent, who can slip in and out of an American accent at free will, is a TV reporter. And evidently, part-Rambo in his head as well. He gets a fine lead into a major case: massive mid-air bombing of a UN plane, which had carried with it his girlfriend (Diya Mirza). The huge American security establishment could benefit from this inside info, unearth a crucial terror network.

Ayaaz, for some reason, doesn’t trust the FBI. He’s no one’s moll (unlike Neil Nitin Mukesh’s character in a similar but much superior film New York, earlier this year). He launches himself instead into a secret, self-funded, one-man mission; plants himself within a sleeper terror cell; becomes one of them; almost kills another man to preserve his identity. This movie is actually not so much about this lunatic move.

It could then be about a well-educated professor of Psychology (Kareena Kapoor) at a New York university, who’s just moved back from India. She’s married to one (Saif Ali Khan, mid-age showing) who turns out to be a terrorist himself. The two had met as colleagues at an Indian college. He had wooed her for her US passport alone: a rather poor one of the many possible plans to sneak into America. The girl’s father had disapproved of their inter-faith marriage initially.

This father has a terrorist for house-guest. The daughter’s an upwardly mobile woman of the world. A few text messages to the right sources, contact with friends and acquaintances, or calls to colleagues at work, could help ease her problem. She largely remains locked up mute; prefers the occasional well-executed snog with a husband she never had.

The script, with hardly a seamless quality, seems pretty much, what they call ‘man ghadant’ (a perennially reworked spinning a yarn of sorts). The lead couple lives in a Muslim neighbourhood in suburban New York. Each of the neighbours in this ‘Arlington Road’ — Afghans (Kirron Kher), Pakistanis (the gray-hero Saif) — has a bone or the other to pick with Americans. There is some honesty in the picture’s wordy purpose: to put into some perspective the junoon (passion) for jihad.

There’s a reason America hasn’t witnessed even a half-scale attack within its shores since September 11, 2001: the date being an anomaly to world history. That’s because it’s all never as simple as this film makes it seem: Saif’s Riyaz escaping crackling street shootouts with FBI; relentless crossfires inside trains; bombs being disposed off at various corners of New York City; hardcore exchange of fire at tube stations…

This, when for the most part the film retains its quiet, somber tone; each frame sensitively lit and tightly photographed to a near calm, visual perfection. What you may brave through then is a flick neither real or serious enough to be a meditation on global terror, nor sweetly suspended and adequately brain-dead to be Die Hard. It’s hard to be both. The hardship shows.

mayank.shekhar@hindustantimes.com

 
Get the latest India News, breaking headlines and real-time updates from across the country. Stay informed about politics, government policies, crime, weather and major national developments.
Get the latest India News, breaking headlines and real-time updates from across the country. Stay informed about politics, government policies, crime, weather and major national developments.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Hindustantimes wants to start sending you push notifications. Click allow to subscribe