Madhya Pradesh assembly election 2018: Chief minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan and other leaders flag off the election campaign 'Rath' at state party office in Bhopal on October 21.(PTI File Photo)
Madhya Pradesh assembly election 2018: Chief minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan and other leaders flag off the election campaign 'Rath' at state party office in Bhopal on October 21.(PTI File Photo)

Madhya Pradesh assembly election 2018: Will corruption, rural anger hurt BJP in the state?

Madhya Pradesh assembly election 2018: Arithmetic shows that the Congress has a lot of ground to make up vis-à-vis the BJP. The latter won 165 seats in the 2013 elections, with an extraordinary strike rate of 72%.
By Neelanjan Sircar and Roshan Kishore | Hindustan Times, Bhopal
UPDATED ON NOV 28, 2018 09:00 AM IST

The 2013 Madhya Pradesh elections were part of the poll-cycle which marked the beginning of the Modi wave. The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) got two-thirds majority in the state. That is not the case anymore. Takkar (contest) has replaced hawa (wave) as the one-word descriptor for the November 28 election. However, most BJP workers we spoke to in Madhya Pradesh are confident that the party will be able to pull off a Gujarat-2017 like performance, where the BJP’s seats came down but the party retained its majority, in Madhya Pradesh 2018. There are good reasons, rooted in both arithmetic and chemistry, why this might or might not happen.

Arithmetic shows that the Congress has a lot of ground to make up vis-à-vis the BJP. The latter won 165 seats in the 2013 elections, with an extraordinary strike rate of 72%. The average vote share of the BJP was 45% compared to 36% for the Congress.

Shivraj Singh Chouhan is also relying on positive chemistry. Entrenched memories of poor provision of public goods such as electricity and roads under the Digvijaya Singh-led Congress government between 1998 and 2003 continue to haunt the opposition. Even Congress supporters across the states agreed that Singh’s tenure was a disaster for the party. That 15 years of BJP rule have led to development is a common view across the state.

These two factors not withstanding, the BJP will do well not to be complacent. There is a broad narrative among voters, Congress and BJP supporters alike, that the BJP government has been infiltrated by highly corrupt and non-performing local actors including MLAs. Shivraj agar jaroori hai to vidhayak majboori hai (The MLA is a compromise, if you want to see Shivraj as the chief minister) is the common narrative among BJP workers across the state. That the BJP has dropped 53 of its sitting MLAs (from a house of 230) this time corroborates this narrative. Widespread rural distress in the state, similar to what was seen in Gujarat, is likely to add to the headwinds from local level anti-incumbency for the ruling party.

In Gujarat, 2017, the Congress actually won a majority in rural areas, winning 67 out of the 126 rural seats in the state. It was urban seats which saved the BJP in the state. Even in MP, the BJP has had a better foothold in urban seats. Statistics provided by the Trivedi Centre for Political Data (TCPD) at Ashoka University, show that the BJP had a strike rate of 93% in urban seats in Madhya Pradesh compared to just 69% in rural seats in the 2013 elections. These figures were 7% and 28% for the Congress. Using data from the 2011 census, we classify an AC as urban if it has less than 100,000 rural voters. The rural distress factor could have a much bigger electoral impact in Madhya Pradesh than it had in Gujarat. According to the 2011 census, Madhya Pradesh had only 28% urban population. The figure is 43% for Gujarat. Only 27 out of the 230 ACs in MP fulfil the urban criterion described above.

See Chart: Rural Urban Seats Region-Wise

 

Another factor which should worry the BJP is the high level of electoral volatility in the state even in what was otherwise a wave election. The BJP lost one-third of the 143 ACs it had won in the 2008 elections in the 2013 polls. The pattern was not uniform across the state. The party did exceedingly well in the Malwa region, with a strike rate of 90%, while it suffered reverses in the Kymore Plateau region.

A region-wise analysis of swing in vote shares and seat shares shows that regions such as Malwa can see a disproportionate swing in seat shares for a given swing in vote share. If the twin grievances of corruption and rural distress align with such electoral volatility, the Congress may just pull off a victory in Madhya Pradesh.

See chart: region-wise change in seat share and vote share

 

(Neelanjan Sircar is an assistant professor at Ashoka University)
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Congress leader Kamal Nath would induct 20 ministers into his cabinet over a week after he took over as the Madhya Pradesh chief minister.(PTI)
Congress leader Kamal Nath would induct 20 ministers into his cabinet over a week after he took over as the Madhya Pradesh chief minister.(PTI)

CM Kamal Nath to induct 20 ministers in Madhya Pradesh cabinet today

UPDATED ON DEC 25, 2018 12:01 AM IST
The names of the ministers have been finalised keeping in view regional and caste equations as well as national polls due next year, Congress leaders said.
Close
In a major reshuffle in Madhya Pradesh’s administrative services, newly-appointed chief minister Kamal Nath shifted 42 officers, 23 of whom were district magistrates.(Mujeeb Faruqui/HT Photo)
In a major reshuffle in Madhya Pradesh’s administrative services, newly-appointed chief minister Kamal Nath shifted 42 officers, 23 of whom were district magistrates.(Mujeeb Faruqui/HT Photo)

42 officers, including 23 district magistrates, transferred in Madhya Pradesh

By Indo Asian News Service | Bhopal
PUBLISHED ON DEC 21, 2018 07:55 PM IST
According to the list which was released late on Thursday, Bharat Yadav has been appointed district magistrate for Gwalior, Deepak Arya for Balaghat, Ganesh Shankar Mishra for Sehore, Bhaskar Lakshkar for Guna and Chhote Lal Singh for Bhind.
Close
On Monday, Kamal Nath through an order waived outstanding short-term crop loans of farmers up to Rs 2 lakh per head.(PTI)
On Monday, Kamal Nath through an order waived outstanding short-term crop loans of farmers up to Rs 2 lakh per head.(PTI)

Govt staff, income tax payees not eligible for farm loans waiver in Madhya Pradesh

By Shruti Tomar | Hindustan Times, Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 19, 2018 07:41 AM IST
Government employees, public representatives from panch-sarpanch to MP and income tax payees cannot avail the crop loan waiver scheme announced by chief minister Kamal Nath on Monday in his first decision after assuming office, officials said.
Close
The e-tendering scam was an election issue for the Congress.(PTI)
The e-tendering scam was an election issue for the Congress.(PTI)

Hard disks seized in Madhya Pradesh e-tendering row, clerk test on radar

By Punya Priya Mitra and Shruti Tomar | Hindustan Times, Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 19, 2018 07:42 AM IST
A day after Kamal Nath took over as Madhya Pradesh chief minister, the police informed the state government on Tuesday that the Centre’s Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT) has seized 11 hard disks related to the e-tendering scam.
Close
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Kamal Nath signs on the files for farm loan waiver(ANI Photo)
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Kamal Nath signs on the files for farm loan waiver(ANI Photo)

‘1 done. 2 to go’: Rahul Gandhi on Kamal Nath waiving farm loans in MP

By HT Correspondent | Hindustan Times, Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 17, 2018 05:33 PM IST
Earlier on Monday, Kamal Nath took the oath as Madhya Pradesh chief minister in the presence of top Congress and opposition leaders who flew to Bhopal from Jaipur where they had watched Ashok Gehlot and Sachin Pilot take charge as Rajasthan chief minister and deputy chief minister respectively.
Close
There was, however, no reason cited for Mamata Banerjee not going to Bhopal for Kamal Nath’s swearing-in ceremony on Monday, an official of the Chief Minister’s Office said.(AFP/File Photo)
There was, however, no reason cited for Mamata Banerjee not going to Bhopal for Kamal Nath’s swearing-in ceremony on Monday, an official of the Chief Minister’s Office said.(AFP/File Photo)

Mamata Banerjee not to attend swearing-in ceremony of Kamal Nath as Madhya Pradesh chief minister

By Press Trust of India | Kolkata
UPDATED ON DEC 17, 2018 10:46 AM IST
West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee will not attend the swearing-in ceremony of Congress leader Kamal Nath as Madhya Pradesh CM, official sources said. Trinamool Congress MP Dinesh Trivedi will be representing the party at the event.
Close
Madhya Pradesh chief minister-designate Kamal Nath raised suspicion on EVMs.(PTI/File Photo)
Madhya Pradesh chief minister-designate Kamal Nath raised suspicion on EVMs.(PTI/File Photo)

Post poor show in MP’s Vindhya, Congress to conduct ‘forensic examination’ of voting pattern

By Press Trust of India | Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 16, 2018 05:00 PM IST
The Congress will get experts to conduct a forensic examination of the voting pattern in Madhya Pradesh’s Vindhya region, from where it won just six out of 30 seats in the recently concluded assembly polls, as it has “suspicion” on EVMs used there.
Close
Kamal Nath, a nine-time MP from Chhindwara seat and currently president of the state Congress unit, will take oath at a grand function to be held at Jamboree Maidan in BHEL area in Bhopal.(PTI)
Kamal Nath, a nine-time MP from Chhindwara seat and currently president of the state Congress unit, will take oath at a grand function to be held at Jamboree Maidan in BHEL area in Bhopal.(PTI)

Mamata Banerjee, Chandrababu Naidu, Mayawati, Akhilesh Yadav invited for Kamal Nath swearing-in

By Press Trust of India | Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 15, 2018 06:10 PM IST
The Congress has invited leaders from across the political spectrum for the swearing-in ceremony of party stalwart Kamal Nath taking charge as chief minister of Madhya Pradesh on December 17.
Close
Thousands of Congress supporters participate in a rally to celebrate Congress' victory in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Chattisgarh Assembly Elections, at Esplanade, in Kolkata on December 12.(Samir Jana/HT PHOTO)
Thousands of Congress supporters participate in a rally to celebrate Congress' victory in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Chattisgarh Assembly Elections, at Esplanade, in Kolkata on December 12.(Samir Jana/HT PHOTO)

94 MLAs with criminal cases, 187 multi-millionaires in new MP assembly: ADR

By Indo Asian News Service | Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 14, 2018 11:30 PM IST
The Congress, which won the Assembly polls, leads the list with 56 MLAs having criminal antecedents, followed by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) with 34 while the Bahujan Samaj Party has two such lawmakers.
Close
Congress leader Kamal Nath meets Madhya Pradesh Governor Anandiben Patel who invited him to form the new government in the state at Raj Bhawan in Bhopal on Friday.(PTI)
Congress leader Kamal Nath meets Madhya Pradesh Governor Anandiben Patel who invited him to form the new government in the state at Raj Bhawan in Bhopal on Friday.(PTI)

Will deliver farm loan waivers, it was not a jumla: Kamal Nath

By Harinder Baweja | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON DEC 17, 2018 10:48 AM IST
Madhya Pradesh chief minister-designate Kamal Nath plans to deliver on the Congress’ election promise to waive loans for farmers within ten days of taking office.
Close
Senior Congress leader Kamal Nath will be the new Chief Minister of Madhya Pradesh (HT File Photo)(HT Photo)
Senior Congress leader Kamal Nath will be the new Chief Minister of Madhya Pradesh (HT File Photo)(HT Photo)

Kamal Nath to be chief minister; Congress says era of change upon MP

By HT Correspondent | Hindustan Times, Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 13, 2018 11:57 PM IST
The Congress legislature party began its meeting at around 10.30 pm, many hours after Gandhi told reporters early on Thursday that a decision on the party’s three chief ministers would be taken soon.
Close
Bhopal, India - Dec. 12, 2018: Madhya Pradesh chief minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan addressing a press conference at state BJP office after his resignation in Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India, on Wednesday, December 12, 2018. (Photo by Mujeeb Faruqui/Hindustan Times)(HT Photo)
Bhopal, India - Dec. 12, 2018: Madhya Pradesh chief minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan addressing a press conference at state BJP office after his resignation in Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India, on Wednesday, December 12, 2018. (Photo by Mujeeb Faruqui/Hindustan Times)(HT Photo)

Will live and die in Madhya Pradesh, says outgoing CM Shivraj Singh Chouhan

By HT Correspondent | Hindustan Times, Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 14, 2018 07:54 AM IST
Shivraj Singh Chouhan, who was ruling the state since 2005, said he will not move to the Centre following the BJP’s loss in Madhya Pradesh, which it was ruling since 2003.
Close
Assembly elections 2018: Congress party supporters hold a cut-out of party President Rahul Gandhi and celebrate outside the party headquarters in New Delhi.(AP)
Assembly elections 2018: Congress party supporters hold a cut-out of party President Rahul Gandhi and celebrate outside the party headquarters in New Delhi.(AP)

Assembly elections 2018: NOTA was the spoiler for BJP in 13 Madhya Pradesh seats

By Vijdan Mohammad Kawoosa | New Delhi
UPDATED ON DEC 13, 2018 09:22 AM IST
Assembly elections 2018: Early trends safely established how the final seat tally would be in Chhattisgarh, Telangana, Rajasthan and Mizoram.
Close
Outgoing chief minister Shivraj Singh chouhan addressing press conference at state BJP office in Bhopal.(Mujeeb Faruqui/HT Photo)
Outgoing chief minister Shivraj Singh chouhan addressing press conference at state BJP office in Bhopal.(Mujeeb Faruqui/HT Photo)

Madhya Pradesh assembly election results 2018: ‘Couldn’t get desired result, I’m responsible for defeat’, says Shivraj Singh Chouhan

By HT Correspondent | Hindustan Times, Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 13, 2018 10:06 AM IST
“I decided that we don’t have the numbers so we shouldn’t try to make the government. I called Kamal Nath to congratulate him and wished him all the best,” said Shivraj Singh Chouhan, who was the chief minister for 13 years.
Close
Congress state president Kamal Nath (R), party leader and MP Jyotiraditya Scindia (L) during the release of Madhya Pradesh assembly election manifesto, at PCC headquarters in Bhopal on November 10.(PTI File Photo)
Congress state president Kamal Nath (R), party leader and MP Jyotiraditya Scindia (L) during the release of Madhya Pradesh assembly election manifesto, at PCC headquarters in Bhopal on November 10.(PTI File Photo)

Suspense over next MP chief minister; new Congress MLAs say Rahul Gandhi to decide

By HT Correspondent | Hindustan Times, Bhopal
UPDATED ON DEC 12, 2018 07:14 PM IST
The two names that the party leadership is believed to be deciding between are that of Kamal Nath and State Congress campaign committee chairman Jyotiraditya Scindia.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP