China blames Jawaharlal Nehru for 1962 war

Updated on Oct 07, 2012 09:31 AM IST
Chairman Mao Zedong, in early October 1962, assembled Chinese leaders to announce the final decision, which was for war: “We fought a war with old Chiang [Kai-shek]. We fought a war with Japan, and with America.
HT Image
HT Image
Hindustan Times | BySutirtho Patranobis in Beijing, Beijing

Chairman Mao Zedong, in early October 1962, assembled Chinese leaders to announce the final decision, which was for war: “We fought a war with old Chiang [Kai-shek]. We fought a war with Japan, and with America. With none of these did we fear. And in each case we won. Now the Indians want to fight a war with us. Naturally, we don't have fear. We cannot give ground, once we give ground it would be tantamount to letting them seize a big piece of land equivalent to Fujian province... Since Nehru sticks his head out and insists on us fighting him, for us not to fight with him would not be friendly enough. Courtesy emphasises reciprocity,” Henry Kissinger, quoting Mao Zedong, wrote in his 2011 book, On China.

Fifty years later, the narrative in China continues to blame India for the war. The belief: it was Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru’s misunderstanding and miscalculation of the border situation that pushed China, then reeling under the impact of large-scale famines, into war with India.

“It was Nehru’s ‘Forward Policy’ of wanting to define the border unilaterally and go beyond the McMahon Line that really provoked China. Finally, Chinese leadership got irritated. The language used at that time (by leaders of the Communist Party of China (CPC) was something like ‘teach (India) a lesson’,” sais professor Hu Shi Sheng, head of the South Asia, South East Asia and Oceania Studies at the State Council-Affiliated China Institutes of Contemporary International Relations.

According to Hu, Nehru and his team were further misled by Tibetan refugees who had fled to India under Dalai Lama three years ago. “They gave wrong information (to the Indian administration) that China will not react. The political sanctuary given to Dalai Lama by India complicated matters; it made the situation sensitive and ticklish,” Hu said.

Experts here argue that proof of China’s defensive posture was that Mao declared a ceasefire and ordered the withdrawal of troops; they also make it a point to mention the humane treatment given to captured Indian soldiers.

“China's peaceful intentions were further testified by its unilateral ceasefire on November 22, 1962, and its withdrawal of troops a few days later to 20 kilometers from the line of actual control since November 7, 1959. China also carefully treated Indian prisoners of war. Injured Indian soldiers were given proper medical treatment and were sent back to their homeland. Chinese soldiers were even ordered by their commander to polish seized Indian weapons and return them back to the Indian army. This was unprecedented,” wrote Hong Yuan, researcher with the Center of World Politics at the Chinese Academy of Social Science, in a recent commentary.

Whether Chinese soldiers actually polished and returned seized Indian weaponry is a matter of debate, but a documentary titled ‘The Crushing Moment: China-India 1962 War’ circulating on the internet certainly hones the claims that Beijing only counter-attacked and treated the prisoners of war (POW) well.

Dismissed by some as propaganda, the footage, starting from September 8, 1962, shows the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) readying to face Indian “aggression”, setting up their own outposts and finally “wiping” out several Indian army brigades. It shows Chinese nurses feeding soup to Indian soldiers; doctors treating the wounded and the captured.

“The withdrawal (from Arunachal Pradesh which China claims to South Tibet) was also because the leaders thought that the territory anyway belonged to China," said professor Wang Dehua, director of the Institute for South Asia and Central Asian Studies at the Shanghai Municipal Centre for International Studies.

But unlike in India, which comprehensively lost the war, there seems to be little interest about it here except the rare opinion piece in the state media. One reason could be that the party is immersed in preparing for the upcoming 18th Congress in November. But even otherwise, according to diplomats posted in Beijing, there’s hardly or no mention about the event in official circles.

Mention in history books here about the war – much like in India – revolves around the same belief: India attacked, China defended.

Hong says: “fifty years ago, the Indian government was blinded by selfish interests, and wanted to force the Chinese to accept an illegal border line created by colonial powers. This was boldly rejected. Today, both countries need to learn from their ancient friendly ties and the lesson from the war. For the Chinese, they love peace but they will also firmly defend their land.” This could well be Mao speaking.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The Russian military said that Ukrainian shelling of the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant on Sunday caused a power surge and fire and forced staff to lower output from two reactors. (Russian Defense Ministry Press Service via AP)

    Kremlin accuses Kyiv of shelling nuclear power plant in Zaporizhzhia

    The Kremlin accused Ukrainian forces on Monday of firing on Europe's largest nuclear power plant in occupied Ukraine and warned that the alleged attacks could have "catastrophic consequences". Kyiv said Moscow was responsible and called for the area to be demilitarised, saying two employees had been wounded in recent attacks. Fighting continued meanwhile along battle lines stretching across eastern Ukraine, and Russia continued its crackdown on dissent at home.

  • TTP Mohmand chief Omar Khalid Khurasani, aka Abdul Wali.

    Pakistani militant with $3 million US bounty killed in Afghanistan: Report

    A senior Pakistani militant with $3 million US bounty on Abdul Wali, also known as Omar Khalid Khurasani's head has been killed along with three aides in neighbouring Afghanistan, three militant commanders and an intelligence official said on Monday. Khurasani and his aides were killed in an explosion from an apparent roadside bomb while travelling in a car in southeastern province of Paktia on Sunday, the sources told Reuters on condition of anonymity.

  • The Security Council's consultations will take place on Monday afternoon in New York.

    UN Security Council to hold emergency meeting on Monday over Gaza fighting

    The UN Security Council was to hold an emergency meeting on Monday to discuss the situation in Gaza, where a truce is holding between Islamic Jihad militants and Israel after three days of deadly conflict. China, which holds the presidency of the Security Council in August, announced the emergency meeting on Saturday, with Ambassador Zhang Jun expressing his concern over Gaza's worst fighting since an 11-day war last year.

  • File photo of cracked and dry earth on the banks of Le Broc lake, as a historical drought hits France, August 5, 2022.

    France in midst of 4th heat wave amid historic drought

    France was in the midst of its fourth heat wave of the year Monday as the country faces what the government warned is its worst drought on record. Read US Senate poised to pass Biden's cornerstone climate and health bill The high temperatures aren't helping firefighters battling a wildfire in the Chartreuse Mountains, near the Alps in eastern France, where authorities have evacuated around 140 people.

  • Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak before taking part in the BBC Conservative Party leadership debate in Stoke-on-Trent, England, Monday July 25, 2022.

    Rishi Sunak v Liz Truss: UK PM race finalists clash over this policy

    The race to elect a new Conservative Party leader, who will take charge as British Prime Minister early next month, heated up on Monday as the two finalists – Rishi Sunak and Liz Truss – clashed over their proposals to tackle the soaring cost-of-living crisis across the country. While Truss has pledged immediate tax cuts if elected, Sunak has promised more targeted support for the most vulnerable households and tax cuts further down the line.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Tuesday, August 09, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now