The logo of the the American online social media and social networking service, Facebook and Twitter on a computer screen in Lille. (AFP)
The logo of the the American online social media and social networking service, Facebook and Twitter on a computer screen in Lille. (AFP)

Facebook, Twitter: Platforms or media companies?

The companies, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and others, base their characterisation as technology platforms on two main pillars: that the content they host is not generated by them, and that code – not human intervention – determines how it is displayed.
By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 05, 2021 06:04 AM IST

Twitter’s decision to take down several posts in relation to the farm protests and its criticism has brought the spotlight back on a crucial debate relating to how social media companies are classified: they claim to be technology platforms, but how they moderate – and curate by way of algorithmic prioritisation — their content is similar to editorial decisions exercised by media companies.

On Thursday for instance, the social media company took down tweets of Bollywood actor Kangana Ranaut. Earlier in the week, it temporarily blocked some accounts in India before unblocking them on the grounds that the company believes in “protecting public conversation and transparency”, according to a person familiar with the matter who asked not to be named. “We have taken action on tweets that were in violation of the Twitter rules in line with our range of enforcement options,” a Twitter spokesperson said in a statement.

Growing intervention by tech ‘platforms’

The classification of social media companies is crucial because they are at present beyond the regulatory scope that extends to media companies, requiring the latter to follow guidelines on speech and expression — a structure that experts have long held is crucial since mass media has large influence on politics and culture.

Not only do these companies decide who gets to post what, they influence and regulate which content is amplified and which isn’t.

The companies, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and others, base their characterisation as technology platforms on two main pillars: that the content they host is not generated by them, and that code – not human intervention – determines how it is displayed. Their moderation is based on self-drawn guidelines meant to combat hate speech and unlawful media.

At the core of this characterisation is Section 230 of Communications Decency Act in the United States, which has physical jurisdiction over the world’s biggest tech companies. It lays down that internet companies will not be held liable for the content they host, and that they cannot be held liable for good-faith efforts to hide, remove or filter user-generated content. This law has been regarded as the bedrock for an open, free internet.

Too much or not enough

But increasingly, their moderation has been debated. One such example is the decision by Facebook and Twitter in 2020 to block access to a news article about then presidential candidate (and current President) Joe Biden’s son Hunter Biden. Critics condemned the companies for blocking a report that a news organisation deemed fit to publish, while the companies cited rules against carrying material obtained through hacking or illegal sourcing.

At the same time, the platforms – particularly Facebook – have been criticised for not doing enough in some other circumstances: They were criticised for not curtailing conspiracy theory groups such as QAnon and hate collectives such as the Proud Boys, which were among those that laid siege to the US Capitol on January 6.

In a 2017 paper published in First Monday, a peer-reviewed open access journal for research on the Internet, public and tech policy experts Philip Napoli and Robyn Caplan write that treating social media companies as tech firms ignores the social aspects and influence of their reach, as also the fact that their main revenue source is content, the same as media companies.

“The framing of social media platforms and digital content curators purely as technology companies marginalises the increasingly prominent political and cultural dimensions of their operation, which grow more pronounced as these platforms become central gatekeepers of news and information in the contemporary media ecosystem” they write.

In the paper, Napoli and Caplan argue that traditional media roles of “1) production (exemplified by content creators such as news outlets and television studios); 2) distribution (the process of moving content from producers towards consumers); and, 3) exhibition (the process of providing content directly to audiences)” have now merged and evolved due to digitization of media.

They also target the defence that computer code is responsible for editorial functions, and that there is no human intervention. “The asserted absence of direct human editorial involvement helps to further this perception of distance from, and/or neutrality in, the content selection process — a model that is presumably fundamentally different from the kind of direct (and human) editorial discretion that has been a defining characteristic of traditional media companies.”

But, they add, “simply because the mechanisms for exercising editorial discretion — for gatekeeping — have changed doesn’t mean that the fundamental institutional identity of the gatekeepers should be recast”.

A crucial similarity between these social media companies and media companies is the centrality of advertising as a revenue source, Napoli and Caplan write.

Changing nature of media, technology

The debate, however, also needs to account for the changing nature of media and communications and the centrality of user-generated content – a factor the authors of the paper also recognise. “One could just as easily argue that it is necessary and appropriate for our understanding of media companies to evolve to fully encompass the structure and operation of these platforms”.

But regulatory parity may be necessary, and appears to have been identified in some manner by big tech leaders. In December, 2016, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg described Facebook as “not a traditional media company”. Google in a 2005 regulatory filing stated, “We began as a technology company and have evolved into a software, technology, Internet, advertising, media company”.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Pre-litigation settlement in cheque bounce cases is also under consideration by the court.(Pratik Chorge/HT Photo)
Pre-litigation settlement in cheque bounce cases is also under consideration by the court.(Pratik Chorge/HT Photo)

Are you willing to create more courts for cheque bounce cases: SC asks Centre

By Abraham Thomas, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 10:02 AM IST
  • The law prescribes a six-month deadline for trial to complete but an analysis showed that on an average, a case of cheque bounce under Section 138 NI Act remained for three years and eight months in the judicial system.
Close
BJP national president JP Nadda. (File photo)
BJP national president JP Nadda. (File photo)

BJP chief Nadda to be in Varanasi on two-day visit beginning Feb 28

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Smriti Sinha
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 09:50 AM IST
Nadda is also likely to address a rally in Rohania where he would be inaugurating party’s regional office, BJP leaders said. They added there could be some last-minute changes in Nadda’s itinerary.
Close
The number of active cases of Covid-19 has gone up further and now stands at 155,986. (Bloomberg)
The number of active cases of Covid-19 has gone up further and now stands at 155,986. (Bloomberg)

India’s active Covid-19 cases climb to 155,986; tally over 11.06 million

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Meenakshi Ray, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 09:40 AM IST
The recoveries from the viral disease have gone up to 10,750,680 and the national recovery rate is now at 97.17%.
Close
The Supreme Court. (HT archive)
The Supreme Court. (HT archive)

Supreme Court to hear contempt plea on tigress Avni killing today

By Abraham Thomas
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 09:33 AM IST
Earlier this month, the top court had issued notices on the contempt petition which claimed that Maharashtra government officials violated the SC order to declare no reward for killing the man-eater tigress
Close
Indian Air Force's Sukhoi 30 plane (PTI).
Indian Air Force's Sukhoi 30 plane (PTI).

2 years of Balakot: Rajnath Singh, Amit Shah lead tributes to Indian Air Force

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Karan Manral, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 09:33 AM IST
On February 26, 2019, the IAF had struck a Jaish-e-Muhammed camp in Pakistan’s Balakot in retaliation to February 14’s Pulwama suicide attack.
Close
Jammu: A BSF personnel keeps vigil along the International border in Jammu, Thursday. (PTI)
Jammu: A BSF personnel keeps vigil along the International border in Jammu, Thursday. (PTI)

India, Pakistan armies announce ceasefire: All you need to know

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Sameer
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 09:29 AM IST
Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan’s adviser on security affairs, Moeed Yusuf, said in an audio statement that the agreement on the ceasefire was the outcome of “behind-the-scenes” contacts
Close
Nirav Modi. (HT file)
Nirav Modi. (HT file)

UK court clears Nirav Modi’s extradition: All you need to know about case, what follows

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Sameer
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 09:23 AM IST
The court dismissed Modi’s claims that he would not get a fair trial at home as the Central Bureau of Investigation and Enforcement Directorate provided detailed evidence against the billionaire diamond merchant
Close
Nirav Modi. (HT archive)
Nirav Modi. (HT archive)

Nirav Modi’s extradition: CBI, ED submitted over 40,000 docs to prove conspiracy

By Neeraj Chauhan
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 09:17 AM IST
The UK court clearing Modi’s extradition praised the evidence the CBI and the ED submitted before it while dismissing claims that he would not get a fair trial
Close
An Indian Air Force Apache helicopter flies over the Ladakh region. (REUTERS)
An Indian Air Force Apache helicopter flies over the Ladakh region. (REUTERS)

IAF strengthened capabilities after Balakot, deployed new acquisitions in Ladakh

PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 08:57 AM IST
Front-line platforms, inducted over the last two years, form a critical part of IAF’s force projection in eastern Ladakh, and have demonstrated its capability to carry out combat missions in the sensitive theatre
Close
A photographer has a cloth wrapped around his head to beat the heat at India Gate in New Delhi. (HT file)
A photographer has a cloth wrapped around his head to beat the heat at India Gate in New Delhi. (HT file)

Early onset of summer in NW India despite La Nina’s cooling effect?

By Jayashree Nandi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 08:56 AM IST
According to an IMD, higher temperatures over the north-western plains is mainly attributed to absence of any weather system, and prevalence of south-westerly surface winds which is causing advection of heat from West Rajasthan towards the region.
Close
Congress spokesperson Randeep Surjewala.
Congress spokesperson Randeep Surjewala.

News updates from HT | Congress asks DMK for 54 seats in assembly polls

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 08:52 AM IST
  • Here are today’s top news, analysis, and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
The traders’ body has said that all commercial markets across the country will remain shut. (HT File Photo )
The traders’ body has said that all commercial markets across the country will remain shut. (HT File Photo )

Transport, trade unions call for ‘Bharat Bandh’; farmers' unions to join

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 08:34 AM IST
The participants will stage sit-in demonstrations in more than 1,500 towns and cities across states. Several services across the country are likely to be affected as more than 40,000 traders' associations are taking part in the bandh.
Close
The Bank of Maharashtra has around 1,900 branches all over India.(Bloomberg/Picture for representation)
The Bank of Maharashtra has around 1,900 branches all over India.(Bloomberg/Picture for representation)

Bank holidays in March 2021: Banks to remain closed for 11 days, check dates her

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shivani, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 08:28 AM IST
  • However, bank holidays are not observed by all states and it may vary as per the specific state or region. Only gazetted holidays are observed by banks all over the country.
Close
The Supreme Court struck down the life imprisonment punishment awarded to the man and referred his case for fine to the local juvenile court.(HT photo)
The Supreme Court struck down the life imprisonment punishment awarded to the man and referred his case for fine to the local juvenile court.(HT photo)

Juvenile convict to be let off with fine in 22-years old murder case

By Abraham Thomas, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 08:02 AM IST
  • The question before the Supreme Court was whether the accused should be tried as a juvenile as under the Juvenile Justice Act, 1986 as it then prevailed when the crime was committed as those under 16 years were termed juvenile under the act.
Close
Under the UK Extradition Act, 2003, the judge will now send his findings to the UK secretary of state for home affairs, Priti Patel. (HT Photo)
Under the UK Extradition Act, 2003, the judge will now send his findings to the UK secretary of state for home affairs, Priti Patel. (HT Photo)

Nirav Modi's extradition to India cleared: What next

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Meenakshi Ray, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 07:57 AM IST
The district judge at the Westminster Magistrates' Court Samuel Goozee said that there is no evidence to suggest Nirav Modi would not receive a fair trial in India.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP