An NSSO survey shows that in rural areas, the average trip to the water source takes 20 minutes and there is a 15­minute waiting time and it takes several trips to meet the water needs.(PTI File Photo)
An NSSO survey shows that in rural areas, the average trip to the water source takes 20 minutes and there is a 15­minute waiting time and it takes several trips to meet the water needs.(PTI File Photo)

Why clubbing employment and work in India is misleading

This lack of distinction explains the decline in women’s workforce participation rates. The decline reflects a shift from paid to unpaid work.
By Jayati Ghosh | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON SEP 07, 2018 10:33 AM IST

One of the difficulties with discussions on employment in India is the tendency to conflate employment and work. But employment is only that part of work that is remunerated, and in India a vast amount of work is actually unpaid and often not even socially recognised. Once we recognise that, a lot of what appears to be inexplicable about Indian employment trends becomes easier to understand.

This is especially true of women’s work. There has been much discussion on the evidence from recent National Sample Survey Office (NSSO) large sample surveys on employment, of the significant decline in women’s workforce participation rates.

The work participation rate of rural women aged 15+ years declined from 35 per cent in 1999-2000 to 24 per cent in 2011-12, while the rate for urban women did not change from the really low rate of 16.6 per cent. Various explanations have been offered for this, from more young women being engaged in education (which is still not enough to explain the decline) to rising real wages that have allowed women in poor households to avoid or reduce involvement in very physically arduous and demanding work with relatively low wages. Implicit in this discussion is a notion of a household-level backward bending supply curve, which allows women especially in poorer families not to “work” when their economic conditions allow it.

 

But these numbers relate to recognised employment, even if it is informal or self employment. The same survey reports also include some categories that are described as “not in the labour force”. The categories that matter are Code 92 (attended to domestic duties only) and Code 93 (attended to domestic duties and also engaged in free collection of goods like vegetables, roots, firewood, cattle feed, etc., water collection, sewing, tailoring, weaving, etc. for household use — both of which heavily involve women working in unpaid ways. There is also Code 97 (“Others”, including beggars, prostitutes, etc.) which is a strange anomaly because these activities do involve money transactions but are still not classified as work. If we include Codes 92, 93 and 97 in the definition of work, then we get quite different results. Let us call these two categories recognised workers and all workers. The chart indicates how these have moved since 1999-2000. Three striking features emerge. First, instead of a really low work participation rate, more women work in India than men! In 2011-12, the total women’s work participation rate was as high as 86.2 per cent, compared to 79.8 per cent for men. Second, the decline over the previous decade can then be explained entirely by more women in the age group 15-24 years participating in education. Third, and most important: the decline in women’s employment rates really reflects a shift from paid to unpaid work. This is a very different picture from the conventional one that sees most women in India as “not working”.

Why was there such a shift? Disaggregation shows that the increase was mainly in Code 93 (domestic and allied work), with nearly 8 percentage points increase in rural women and 2 percentage points increase in urban women falling into this category in 2011-12 compared to 1993-94. This was most marked for poor women: in the bottom 40 per cent of households according to consumption expenditure, the increase was by 12 percentage points in rural areas and around 5 percentage points in urban areas. A significant share of such unpaid women workers (40 per cent in rural areas and 22 per cent in urban areas in 2011-12) were dominantly involved in fetching water for household consumption, an activity that takes more time than before. More than half of the poorest women had to do this, as well as to collect biofuels for cooking as they did not have access to or could not afford other fuel. (Data from Shiney Chakraborty, “Gender Wage Discrimination in the Indian Labour Market 1993-94 to 2011-12” PhD thesis submitted to Jawaharlal Nehru University in 2018).

This suggests that absence of basic amenities was an important factor driving the increase in unpaid work. Another NSSO survey (69th round in 2012) found that in rural areas, the average trip to the water source took 20 minutes, with an additional waiting time of 15 minutes at the water source, and that several trips were required in order to meet the water needs for household consumption.

In urban areas the time for travel to the source was 15 minutes and the time spent waiting per trip was 16 minutes. Similarly, significant time was spent by women on collecting fuelwood and fodder for animals. The Ujjwala scheme providing a free first cooking gas cylinder to BPL women is superficially successful, but has nevertheless failed to overcome this problem, because most households have found that they cannot afford to buy the subsequent cylinders.

What is more, nearly two-thirds of these unpaid women workers reported that they had to perform these necessary tasks because there was no one else in the household to do them. Nevertheless, a significant majority said they would be willing to accept paid work, pointing to the overall inadequacy of productive employment generation in the economy.

In addition to these extended domestic tasks, there are the various activities associated with the “care economy”: care of the young, the old, the sick and the differently abled; cooking, cleaning and generally looking after healthy adults – all of which are dominantly seen as the responsibility of women in the household. When these services are outsourced and provided commercially, the providers are seen as workers in India; but when they are performed by women within households, such women are classified as “not in the labour force”.

This lack of recognition of a significant part of the work dominantly provided by women has several important economic and social implications. The unpaid-paid continuum of women’s work serves to devalue both women and the work they do. Thus, when women do enter labour markets, their wages tend to be lower than those of men – not only because they are willing to work for lower wages but because so much of their work is available for free. India has one of the largest gender gaps in wages to be found anywhere in the world, with women’s wages on average only around two-thirds that of men’s wages.

Related to this, the occupations in which women dominate tend to be lower paid – and the wage penalty extends even to men doing similar work, such as in the low paid care sector. This is certainly true of private employers. But in India, even the government has used these gender-segmented labour markets to provide public services on the cheap, by employing anganwadi workers and helpers and ASHAs as “volunteers” who are paid only a fraction of the official minimum wages. Similarly, women are disproportionately employed by state governments as parateachers and ANMs (auxiliary nurses and midwives) and paid far less than regular employees. Third, all this unpaid work provides a huge subsidy to the recognised economy and to the “formal sector”, which rely both directly and indirectly on the goods and services produced by these unsung and unrewarded workers. Because this contribution is not recognised, it enables self-satisfied perceptions of rising aggregate labour productivity in the economy, which may be quite misplaced. And it means that public policy can continue to ignore the need to reduce and redistribute such unpaid labour, and can persist in the mistaken belief that GDP growth will simply generate enough “good jobs” for everyone.

(The author is Professor of economics, Jawaharlal Nehru University)

This is the fourth in a five-part series on India’s employment challenge. The third part examined why India’s job problem is easier to solve than its battle for wages. The next and final part will look at the role of caste-discrimination in labour markets.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
INS noted that there is a huge distinction between editorial content from quality publications and fake news that is spreading on other information platforms.(AP file photo. Representative image)
INS noted that there is a huge distinction between editorial content from quality publications and fake news that is spreading on other information platforms.(AP file photo. Representative image)

‘Pay for news’: Indian Newspaper Society in a letter to Google

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 04:26 AM IST
President of INS, L Adimoolam, said in a letter addressed to Google India’s country manager Sanjay Gupta that Google should “pay for news generated by newspapers which employ thousands of journalists on the ground at considerable expense”, the body said in a statement, adding that it is in discussions with the tech giant.
Close
Police clarified that the material found was not an assembled explosive device.(ANI Photo)
Police clarified that the material found was not an assembled explosive device.(ANI Photo)

Car with explosives found near Mukesh Ambani’s residence

By Vijay Kumar Yadav, Manish Pathak
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 04:01 AM IST
Police said the vehicle — a green Scorpio with a wrong number plate had around 20 Gelatin sticks in it — was about 600 metres away from the house of Reliance Industries Limited chairman Mukesh Ambani on Altamount Road.
Close
Karbi Anglong: Union Home Minister Amit Shah addresses the 'Unity, Peace and Development Rally' at Dengaon in Karbi Anglong, Thursday, Feb 25, 2021. (PTI Photo) (PTI02_25_2021_000183B)(PTI)
Karbi Anglong: Union Home Minister Amit Shah addresses the 'Unity, Peace and Development Rally' at Dengaon in Karbi Anglong, Thursday, Feb 25, 2021. (PTI Photo) (PTI02_25_2021_000183B)(PTI)

BJP has stopped entry of illegal immigrants, says Amit Shah in Assam

By Utpal Parashar, Guwahati
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:46 AM IST
“There was a time when Assam was known for agitations and violence. The biggest contribution of the Narendra Modi government at the Centre is to establish peace in Assam, ensure development, give corruption-free administration, rid the state of agitations and put the brakes on the entry of illegal immigrants,” Shah said at a rally in Batadrava Than
Close
Around 40,000 trade associations have extended their support to the call for the bandh.(Ravindra Joshi/HT file photo)
Around 40,000 trade associations have extended their support to the call for the bandh.(Ravindra Joshi/HT file photo)

Farm unions, traders to join Bharat Bandh today

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 03:21 AM IST
Issuing a statement, the Confederation of All India Traders (CAIT) — the umbrella body which has called for the strike — said that all commercial markets across the country will remain closed on February 26 against rising fuel prices, the new e-way bill and the goods and services tax (GST).
Close
Altogether, HT is aware of five NIC domain addresses – four with @gov.in suffixes and the fifth an @nic.in one – that have been used to launch cyber attacks.(File photo. Representative image)
Altogether, HT is aware of five NIC domain addresses – four with @gov.in suffixes and the fifth an @nic.in one – that have been used to launch cyber attacks.(File photo. Representative image)

Officials targeted in new phishing bid via govt IDs

By Anisha Dutta, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 01:30 AM IST
The attack, which took place on Monday, prompted the government’s IT departments to send out an alert the following day to large groups of officials, according to emails seen by HT.
Close
Tandav is facing at least 10 FIRs for hurting religious sentiments, intending to disturb caste and communal amity – charges punishable under Sections 153A and 295 of Indian Penal Code (IPC) with a maximum jail term of three years.(MINT_PRINT)
Tandav is facing at least 10 FIRs for hurting religious sentiments, intending to disturb caste and communal amity – charges punishable under Sections 153A and 295 of Indian Penal Code (IPC) with a maximum jail term of three years.(MINT_PRINT)

Tandav controversy: Amazon Prime executive’s bail plea rejected by Allahabad HC

By JItendra Sarin, Prayagraj
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:57 AM IST
A single-judge bench of justice Siddharth rejected the application of Amazon Prime Video’s Aparna Purohit in connection with the ongoing investigation against Tandav for allegedly outraging religious feelings and showing Hindu gods in poor light.
Close
The deceased are yet to be identified after a blast in a a firecracker factory in Tamil Nadu killed five people. (Getty Images).
The deceased are yet to be identified after a blast in a a firecracker factory in Tamil Nadu killed five people. (Getty Images).

5 dead, 19 injured in blast at firecracker factory near Tamil Nadu's Sivakasi

PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:18 AM IST
  • Fire engines and rescue teams were pressed into service and the injured are being treated at the Sivakasi government hospital.
Close
Karnataka chief minister BS Yediyurappa despite the threat to his own chair, has taken it upon himself to bring the BJP back to power with an absolute majority in the 2023 assembly elections. (FILE PHOTO).
Karnataka chief minister BS Yediyurappa despite the threat to his own chair, has taken it upon himself to bring the BJP back to power with an absolute majority in the 2023 assembly elections. (FILE PHOTO).

CM Yediyurappa, the recalcitrant conformist, turns 78

By Sharan Poovanna
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:57 AM IST
  • A Bengaluru-based political analyst said that Yediyurappa's supporters may want to go in for low-key birthday celebrations even though detractors may post as many ads as possible to remind everyone of his age.
Close
Whale sharks are protected under the Wildlife Protection Act and are ‘endangered’ species in the International Union for Conservation of Nature. (HT PHOTO).
Whale sharks are protected under the Wildlife Protection Act and are ‘endangered’ species in the International Union for Conservation of Nature. (HT PHOTO).

Huge whale shark washes up on Odisha coast; locals push it back into the sea

By Debabrata Mohanty
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 11:42 PM IST
  • Officials said some local youths spotted the big fish lying lifeless on the Sonapur coast on Thursday afternoon.
Close
The depth of the earthquake was 30-km, the NCS said.(File photo. Representative image)
The depth of the earthquake was 30-km, the NCS said.(File photo. Representative image)

Earthquake of 3.6 magnitude jolts Assam's Guwahati

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | PTI
UPDATED ON FEB 26, 2021 12:07 AM IST
The earthquake took place at 10.33 pm and the epicentre was in Kamrup district near Guwahati, the National Center for Seismology said.
Close
The highest maximum day temperature in February in the last 10 years was recorded on February 20, 2016 when the mercury climbed to 40.9 degree Celsius. (HT FILE PHOTO).
The highest maximum day temperature in February in the last 10 years was recorded on February 20, 2016 when the mercury climbed to 40.9 degree Celsius. (HT FILE PHOTO).

Bhubaneswar records maximum day temperature pan-India for 2nd consecutive day

By Debabrata Mohanty
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:56 PM IST
  • Officials in Bhubaneswar's Regional Meteorological Centre said the maximum temperature of 38 degrees Celsius in Bhubaneswar on Wednesday too was highest on that day.
Close
World's highest railway bridge over Chenab river in Reasi district will provide all-weather connectivity.(ANI File Photo)
World's highest railway bridge over Chenab river in Reasi district will provide all-weather connectivity.(ANI File Photo)

'Infrastructural marvel' Chenab bridge completes important milestone

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:47 PM IST
The length of the Chenab bridge will be 1,315 metres with 17 spans, of which the span of the main arch across Chenab river will be 467 metres. The viaduct portion comprises a straight and curved portion.
Close
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan addresses a press conference through video conferencing.(ANI)
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan addresses a press conference through video conferencing.(ANI)

MP CM Shivraj Singh Chouhan urges people to avoid travelling to Maharashtra

PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:36 PM IST
  • In MP, the positivity rate increased to 2.3% on Thursday and there are 2,435 active cases in the state.
Close
Indian children wearing face masks as a precaution against Covid-19. (AP)
Indian children wearing face masks as a precaution against Covid-19. (AP)

'375 mn Indian children may suffer due to Covid-19 pandemic': CSE report

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 11:00 PM IST
  • CSE’s director general Sunita Narian said Covid-19 had made the world’s poor poorer.
Close
Baba Ramdev releases the scientific research papers on the Patanali medicine for COVID-19, during a press conference in New Delhi,(PTI/ File photo)
Baba Ramdev releases the scientific research papers on the Patanali medicine for COVID-19, during a press conference in New Delhi,(PTI/ File photo)

Coronil row: Patanjali condemns IMA for seeking explanation from Health min

ANI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 10:27 PM IST
The Indian Medical Association (IMA) on Monday demanded an explanation from Union Health Minister Dr Harsh Vardhan for promoting Patanjali's Coronil Ayurvedic medicine.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP