Covid-19 patients are not untouchables: Bombay HC fumes at hospital’s refusal to examine pregnant woman

The woman had pleaded before the court that her doctor was of the opinion that there was substantial risk after the delivery, as the newborn could suffer from physical and mental abnormalities
Bombay high court.(HT Archive)
Bombay high court.(HT Archive)
Published on Oct 14, 2020 12:59 PM IST
Copy Link
ByKanchan Chaudhari

Coronavirus disease (Covid-19) patients are not untouchables, a Nagpur bench of the Bombay high court (HC) has said while expressing displeasure over a state government-run hospital’s refusal to clinically examine a woman, who had moved court in a bid to get her advanced pregnancy terminated after she was found to have contracted SARS-CoV-2, which causes the viral disease.

“We fail to understand as to how the Covid-19 patient cannot be clinically examined by doctors,” said the two-member division bench, comprising Justices Ravi Deshpande and Pushpa Ganediwala.

The court made the observation while noticing that the Chandrapur-based government medical college had not clinically examined the pregnant woman after she had tested Covid-19 positive.

“As we understand, day in and day out Covid-19 patients are being treated in hospitals. There is no question of them being untouchables,” the bench added.

Also Read: Covid-19: ICMR studying reinfections; identifies 3 cases

The petitioner had moved the HC seeking permission to medically terminate her 23-week pregnancy while contending that the scan report has revealed that the foetus was suffering from several deformities.

She had pleaded before the court that her doctor was of the opinion that there was substantial risk after the delivery, as the newborn could suffer from physical and mental abnormalities.

The bench on October 7 had directed the government medical college authorities to constitute an expert panel to examine the petitioner and submit a report in a bid to determine whether her plea for medical termination of her 23-week pregnancy could be upheld.

An additional government pleader submitted the report before the bench on Monday (October 12).

However, the judges were annoyed after the government lawyer informed them that the petitioner would have to be clinically examined to ascertain, if she was fit to undergo the termination of her pregnancy.

The bench directed the expert panel to clinically examine the petitioner and to take a decision on the mode and manner in which the termination of the pregnancy could take place.

The bench also ordered the panel to decide whether the termination of pregnancy could be done when the patient was yet to recover from the viral infection and submit a report before the court.

The bench will give its verdict on Thursday on the basis of the panel’s report.


Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Chief minister Yogi Adityanath at a press conference after the presentation of the Uttar Pradesh budget in Lucknow on Thursday. (ANI PHOTO)

    Uttar Pradesh budget in sync with aspirations of 25 crore people of state: Yogi Adityanath

    Chief minister Yogi Adityanath on Thursday called the Uttar Pradesh Budget 2022-23 the state's biggest ever. He said it was an example of efficient financial management in sync with the aspirations of 25 crore people of the state. Describing it as all-inclusive and integrated-development oriented, he said the budget would pave the way for making the state a trillion dollar economy in five years and transform it into the country's biggest economy.

  • Uttar Pradesh finance minister Suresh Khanna presenting the Uttar Pradesh budget for 2022-23 in the state assembly in Lucknow on Thursday. (Deepak Gupta/HT Photo)

    Uttar Pradesh budget: 276.66 crore earmarked for Uttar Pradesh Special Security Force set up on lines of CISF

    The Uttar Pradesh budget for 2022-23 has earmarked 276.66 crore for the newly constituted Uttar Pradesh Special Security Force on the lines of the Central Industrial Security Force. Besides, the state government has proposed 730.88 crore for strengthening the police emergency management system. The Uttar Pradesh budget has also earmarked 250 crore for the purchase of safety equipment, arms and ammunitions for district police stations.

  • A view of the state assembly during the presentation of the Uttar Pradesh budget in Lucknow on Thursday. (Deepak Gupta/HT Photo)

    Uttar Pradesh budget: Ongoing minority welfare schemes get 1782 crore; mixed response from clerics

    The Uttar Pradesh budget for 2022-23 has allocated 1782 crore for the ongoing minority welfare schemes that aim to bring development to the minority institutions and minority inhabited areas. The budget has earmarked 600 crore for the pre-matric scholarship programmes for students belonging to the minority community. It has also allocated 195.50 crore for the post-metric scholarship programme and 479.07 crore for the modernisation of Arbi-Farsi madarsas here in state.

  • The five-member commission headed by former chief secretary Jayant Banthia was constituted on March 11 to collate the empirical data (Bhushan Koyande/HT Photo)

    Banthia commission OBC report expected in June first week, state cabinet told

    Mumbai: The state cabinet was on Thursday told that the report of the Banthia commission has collated 99% of the information it needed from the local level and the report is expected to be submitted in the first week of June. Food and civil supplies minister and OBC leader Chhagan Bhujbal told the cabinet that the government closely coordinating with the Banthia commission to ensure that the process was track.

  • The family has also contacted the Mumbai Police Commissioner for help in the search operation. (HT PHOTO)

    Mumbai man goes missing during solo trip to Azerbaijan

    Mumbai: A 28-year-old travel enthusiast from Mumbai, Manikanth Kondaveeti, has gone missing during a solo trip to Azerbaijan. His family members said they haven't heard from him since May 12. According to his brother Dharan, Manikanth, who worked with Tech Mahindra as a French language expert, left Delhi for Azerbaijan via a connecting flight from Sharjah and reached Baku on April 26.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, May 26, 2022