Delhi health minister Satyendar Jain bats for plasma therapy

Updated on Oct 22, 2020 06:41 AM IST
ICMR had conducted a pan-India study to determine the role of plasma therapy, and the Union health ministry had added it as one of the investigational therapies in the national protocol for treating Covid-19 patients.
Delhi health minister Satyendar Jain.(PTI)
Delhi health minister Satyendar Jain.(PTI)
Hindustan Times, New Delhi | By

New Delhi: Delhi health minister Satyendar Jain on Wednesday said that over 2,000 people have benefitted from plasma therapy in Delhi, a day after reports that Centre was considering to remove it from clinical management protocol for the coronavirus disease (Covid-19),

“A study done by ICMR and AIIMS did not see any breakthrough maybe. But our trial is underway and it is of course being done with the permission of ICMR. We have seen benefits of the therapy, with over 2,000 people having received convalescent plasma from our bank at ILBS. I have myself benefited from the therapy,” said Jain in an interaction with media.

ICMR had conducted a pan-India study to determine the role of plasma therapy, and the Union health ministry had added it as one of the investigational therapies in the national protocol for treating Covid-19 patients.

However, Dr Balram Bhargava, director general, India Council of Medical Research (ICMR) had said on Tuesday, “We have had discussions at the National Task Force (NTF) and we are discussing further with the Joint Monitoring Committee. This (plasma therapy) may be deleted from the national guidelines.”


The trial conducted by the Indian Council of Medical Research across 39 sites for the effectiveness of the therapy in Covid-19 patients, showed that there were no difference in the proportion of patients who progressed to severe disease and those who died between the group that received convalescent plasma and the other who received standard care without plasma.

Convalescent plasma therapy is a well-established method used to treat infections and autoimmune diseases. For Covid-19, a blood component called plasma that is rich in virus-fighting antibodies is taken from patients who have recovered and given to those still fighting the infection.

AAP national spokesperson Raghav Chadha said the removal of the therapy from the protocol would be a “perfunctory act”. “To remove Convalescent Plasma Therapy from Clinical Management Protocol based on a single study (i.e. ICMR Trial) in which even antibody titers of the plasma were not taken into account is a perfunctory act — in a situation where no definitive therapy exists till date,” Chadha tweeted.

Click here for full Covid-19 coverage

“The world’s largest observational study on Convalescent Plasma Therapy conducted on 35,322 Covid patients by Mayo Clinic reported favorable outcomes with lower mortality in patients who received the therapy early in the course of disease with higher levels of antibodies,” he tweeted.

The study by Mayo clinic shows that the seven-day mortality rate reduced in patients transfused within three days of diagnosis as compared to those who were given the therapy later, especially if the donor had high levels of antibodies.

Reviewing the effectiveness of the therapy, Dr Manish Soneja, additional professor in the department of medicine at AIIMS, said, “The PLACID trial from India shows that the results were pretty similar in the group that received plasma therapy and the group that was given standard care. There were some limitations of the study such as many of the patients who were given the therapy already had high levels of neutralising antibody (that prevents the spread of a particular virus, Sars-CoV-2 in this case) at admission. However, this replicates the real-life situation with the facility for testing for neutralising antibodies not available in most places.”

“As for globally, a Chocrane (a library of collated medical evidence) that has looked at 19 studies shows that the therapy is not effective in reducing the all cause mortality. Improvement in clinical symptoms wasn’t really there,” he said.

However, after ICMR had released the data from its trial Dr SK Sarin, director of Institute of Liver and Biliary Sciences (ILBS) which is coordinating Delhi’s plasma trial said, “The ICMR study actually reconfirms the findings of our small study – it shows that the oxygen requirement went down in the patients who received plasma therapy, the duration for which they remained breathless reduced, and the group that received plasma tested negative for the virus quicker than the control group. What needs to be factored in is that the therapy was administered late, after two days of symptoms in most trial participant; it works best when given early. Also, many of the donors in the study did not have a high titre (concentration) of the neutralising antibodies,” Dr Sarin had said.

“For the study, the all-cause mortality at 28-days has been considered, I think a shorter duration has to be chosen because mortality could be because of other complications as well,” he said.

A large-scale study of 400 participants is currently underway at Lok Nayak hospital and Rajiv Gandhi Super Speciality hospital in collaboration with ILBS.


    Anonna Dutt is a health reporter at Hindustan Times. She reports on Delhi government’s health policies, hospitals in Delhi, and health-related feature stories.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • HP chief minister Jai Ram Thakur flagging off a Tiranga rally to commemorate 75 years of Independence from Shimla Railway Station on Sunday. (HT Photo)

    HP cabinet gives nod for setting up 76 model wellness centres

    Himachal Pradesh cabinet has given the nod for setting up 76 model health wellness centres. The state cabinet met on Saturday evening wherein it decided to open patwar circle Spilo in Pooh tehsil of Kinnaur district to facilitate the people of the area. It also decided to create patwar circle Shikroha under Sadar Bilaspur tehsil. It gave its approval to create Kanungo circle Kelodhar under Chachiot tehsil of Mandi district.

  • Farmers in Himachal, where apples account for 13.5% of the state gross domestic product, fear that the opening prices offered by Adani Agri Fresh Limited may impact the fruit’s prices in the local market. (Aqil Khan /Hindustan Times)

    HP apple growers dissatisfied with opening prices announced by Adani

    Sanyukt Kisan Manch, an umbrella organisation of different farmers' unions, have rejected the prices announced by Adani Agri Fresh – a company that imports fruit. Sourced from farmers in Himachal Pradesh and Kashmir. The fruit supply chains in Himachal have announced a marginal increase in the opening price for A-grade premium apples for Rs 76 per kilogram against Rs 72 it offered last year.

  • A gunfight erupted between militants and security forces in Kandra Hill area of Rajouri, officials said on Sunday. (ANI image for representational purpose)

    Gunfight breaks out with terrorists in Rajouri

    A gunfight erupted between militants and security forces in Kandra Hill area of Rajouri, officials said on Sunday. Defence spokesperson Lt Col Devender Anand said, “Today, around 7.30pm, an operational contact was established by troops of Indian Army, Rashtriya Rifles and SOG with terrorists at Kandra Hill in Rajouri.” A senior police officer said that a team of police and army launched a cordon and search operation in Kandra Hill on a specific input.

  • Final touches being given to a multiplex ahead of its opening, in Srinagar on Sunday. (PTI)

    Kashmir’s first multiplex set to open early next monthin Sonawar

    Come September and film aficionados in Kashmir will be able to watch the latest movies on the big screen as the Valley's first multiplex is set to open in the Sonawar area here. The multiplex, being developed in collaboration with leading theatre chain INOX, will have three movie halls with a total capacity of 520 seats, its owner Vijay Dhar told PTI. It will house several food courts, where Dhar plans to promote local cuisine.

  • The Clock Tower at Lal Chowk illuminated on the eve of 75th Independence Day in Srinagar on Sunday. (Waseem Andrabi / Hindustan Times)

    J&K enthusiasm breaking all records: LG Manoj Sinha on Har Ghar Tiranga drive

    A walkathon was organised on the banks of Dal Lake in Srinagar on Sunday in which Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha, along with many senior civil, security officials and hundreds of security personnel, besides people marched holding Tricolour in hands. The walkathon, a part of the 'Har Ghar Tiranga' campaign, was organised by the Border Security Force from the Lalit Ghat to the Botanical Garden.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 15, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now