The eight hours of intense bidding war that unfolded during the IPL 2024 auction was dominated by bowlers. Look no further than Mitchell Starc and Pat Cummins, the Australian pace-bowling duo that created history. Cummins broke Sam Curran's record of ₹18.5 crore from last year to become the first man to breach the ₹20 crore mark before Starc beat him as the most expensive buy in IPL history. Not often do two players from the same country emerge as the top two buys, but such has been Cummins and Starc's domination this year that both lived up to the hype inside Dubai's Coca-Cola arena.
2023 has belonged to Cummins, first winning the World Test Championship, and then retaining the Ashes. Just last month, he led Australia to a record-extending sixth World Cup title and capped the year by hitting the IPL jackpot. As for Starc, he was always expected to break the bank and rake in the moolah he did. That Cummins and Starc fetched a collective price of more than ₹40 crore is pretty earth-shattering, and one that left several former India cricketers surprised.
But perhaps the most interesting point was made by India's greatest Test bowler of all time Anil Kumble, who questioned whether franchises should be allowed to spend a fortune on overseas players. Reasserting that the tournament, after all, is called the Indian Premier League for a reason, Kumble pointed out how teams should set a cap on the money that needs to be shelled out on foreign cricketers.
Also Read: Full list of sold, unsold players, IPL Auction: 72 cricketers find takers, ₹230.45 crore spent
{{/usCountry}}Also Read: Full list of sold, unsold players, IPL Auction: 72 cricketers find takers, ₹230.45 crore spent
{{/usCountry}}"That's where I think you seriously need to look at a seperate purse for the overseas because otherwise, you will have players not coming into the big auction, especially the foreign players who are in demand. They will choose the smaller auction where you know that you're going to go for a double-digit or even more and today was a classic example. Yes, those two are exceptional players but Starc hasn't played in the IPL since 2015. He isn't the youngest of the lot, and Pat Cummins doesn't have a great T20 record as a bowler. He is the captain of Australia, he's done exceptionally for them," Kumble said while speaking on Jio Cinema.
"To go for ₹45 crore on Starc and Cummins at an auction like this - yes this was unprecedented and we never thought that the 20 crore barrier will be broken - but I certainly believe that since only four players can play in the Playing XI and you have 8 out of the 25, I think it's only fair that you have a 40 or 45 percent salary of the overall cap for overseas guys. You have really high-quality Indian players. Virat Kohli, Jasprit Bumrah, who will be looking at this and thinking what's going on."
How has Starc fared in IPL?
Kumble makes a valid point. Starc has picked 170 wickets from 121 T20 matches at an economy rate of 7.45 and has played only two seasons of the IPL – way back in 2014 and 2015 – taking 34 wickets from 27 matches. Not only has he not featured in the IPL in eight years, Starc has never played a T20I in India. In fact, even in Asian conditions (UAE, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh), Starc he has picked 39 wickets in 25 matches at 19.17 and an economy rate of 7.69, which doesn't exactly make Starc a T20 behemoth.
Kumble's former teammate Zaheer Khan weighed on Cummins and Starc's record-breaking day, and added that although he expected the bowlers to have a field day, two players going past the ₹20-crore mark was something he didn't see coming. Even during the mock auction that was conducted a day before, the maximum amount anyone came up with was ₹18.5 crore, which incidentally happened to be for Starc.
"This is a great point by Anil because look at how IPL started. It began with icon players having 10-15 percent of the top players which you will have in the franchise. It meant that value and weightage was being given to Indian players. We don't know how the dynamics is going to pan out if all the Indian players are put into the auction and their quality. At some stage, I think the franchises will look at it. You don't want players thinking that 'It's the Indian Premier League. I am the most premier player - doing well for the country and my IPL team - and not getting the value which the market is deciding. It will be interesting to see how much Bumrah will command in this type of a scenario, who has been a consistent performer over the years and a premier fast bowler," the ex-India quick pointed out.
RP Singh agrees with Kumble
Starc has a second chance with KKR. He was picked at the IPL 2018 auction but couldn't take part due to an injury. Still, seeing the potential Starc possesses, KKR staved off a formidable challenge from Gujarat Titans. After Mumbai Indians and Delhi Capitals, the first two teams to target Starc, pulled out of the race at the 9.6 crore mark, KKR and GT produced quite possible the tensest 10 minutes of the auction. After a lot of thinking, going back-and-forth on decisions, getting on calls with directors, owners, it turns out that KKR were willing to go just that extra mile as GT withdrew. But again, ₹20 crore? Is Starc really worth so much? No, says RP Singh.
"I am a little surprised with the money KKR spent on Starc. I didn't feel that anyone would cross the ₹20 crore mark. The second thing is Mitchell Starc will be playing the IPL after a long time. It's not that he has put up outstanding performances consistently. He has not played the IPL for eight years," the 2007 T20 World Cup-winning pacer highlighted.
"And it's not that he has played say five T20s and won three matches on the back of his own abilities. If they spend so much money on a player, then the captain may expect him to win 40 percent of the matches and ensure that the player has a solid impact on games. So, if I am born again, I should be born in Australia (laughs) and I should be a left-arm fast bowler again."