HT Image
HT Image

The hypocrisy of misplaced activism

Bans are the bane of any free society; hypocrisy, the biggest deterrent to social reform. We have a large share of bans, and a fairly large share of hypocrisy too. When it comes to cruelty against animals, the list of bans is ever lengthening. Arefa Tehsin and Raza H Tehsin write.
By Arefa Tehsin and Raza H Tehsin
UPDATED ON NOV 07, 2013 01:08 AM IST

Bans are the bane of any free society; hypocrisy, the biggest deterrent to social reform. We have a large share of bans, and a fairly large share of hypocrisy too. When it comes to cruelty against animals, the list of bans is ever lengthening. Most people fighting for this 'cause' don't understand the real issues of conservation and end up garnering attention for themselves by appealing to what Slavoj Žižek terms as 'ethical redemption' from our acts of consumerism.

The recent ban on animal dissection in schools reflects a misconceived notion where a purely scientific pursuit is confused with cruelty. Dissecting an animal first hand helps children discover their natural bent for surgery and understand anatomy. On the computer, it may just be another video game. This delays identifying the natural flair of a student. The greatest ornithologist of our times, Salim Ali, says in his autobiography Fall of a Sparrow that his interest in birds was kindled with hunting a sparrow.

Similarly, the ban in the name of cruelty on madaaris and circuses has led to the sad demise of the age-old art of animal training in our country. If we've to ban circuses and zoos, there should also be a ban on ponies, buffaloes, cows, horses. The original homes of our pet dogs and cats were jungles. Hunting is now illegal in India and rightly so. An abundance of poachers kill for commercial gain. But that doesn't justify using the cruelty argument on the disciplined hunters of the old days. 'Cruelty against animals' also extends to non-vegetarianism. Consuming milk that belongs to the calf, killing trillions of insects/worms by pesticides to provide us vegetables, death of birds due to shortage of food caused by pesticides…all this is not considered cruel. Tikiri Dissanayaka says, "When the puritan Devadatta wanted to enforce vegetarianism on the Bhikkus, the 'ism'-free Buddha turned the proposal down…The true intellectually free man can never be a purist in this mixed, never wholly pure world."

We tend to superimpose human emotions on animal welfare. Cruelty against animals should be seen in a broader, practical perspective of long term coexistence with nature, which has diminished as Man leaves nature behind in his great walk. Development has had a staggering environmental impact. Robinson Jeffers said that, "cruelty is a part of nature, at least of human nature, but it is the one thing that seems unnatural to us." Cruelty towards animals is highly objectionable. But what is cruelty? We need to re-examine our hypocritical approach. Loss of habitat is the greatest cause of wildlife destruction. Cities have replaced jungles and we go on banning the few remaining links with the wild. The creatures we value commercially or for entertainment have not become extinct - cattle, dogs, silk worms, hens. If the trading of tiger skin becomes legal, there will be funds from all quarters to breed them.

We put on leather shoes made from cattle skin, get into the car drilling a hole in the ozone, switch on the AC drilling the ozone hole deeper, sip on tea made of milk belonging to the calf, pat the pet dog and sigh about the 'cruel' madaaris, zoos, hunters and rat dissections.

The drive against bans should begin with banning our purist approach. Let's provide forested corridors connecting the jungles for migration of animals whose ancient routes have been cruelly cut off by our cities and highways. That, perhaps, would be a worthy start in our fight against cruelty towards animals.

Arefa Tehsin is honorary wildlife warden, Udaipur, and Raza H Tehsin is a former member, Wildlife Advisory Board, Government of Rajasthan
The views expressed by the authors are personal

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
File photo: Army soldier patrol near Line of Control (LoC) at Poonch.(ANI)
File photo: Army soldier patrol near Line of Control (LoC) at Poonch.(ANI)

Infiltration across LoC down by 70%, says Chinar Corps commander

PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 08:50 PM IST
  • Chinar Corps commander Lt Gen BS Raju said the Line of Control remains fairly active because of Pakistan's attempts to push in terrorists.
Close
The ministry is hopeful that with such pace it should be able to cross construction target of 11,000 km by March 31.(PTI)
The ministry is hopeful that with such pace it should be able to cross construction target of 11,000 km by March 31.(PTI)

Record construction of 534 km of national highways in one week, says govt

PTI, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 08:53 PM IST
In total, projects of 8,948 km of roads were awarded in 2019-20 while 10,237 km of roads were constructed.
Close
Actor Rajinikanth.(PTI)
Actor Rajinikanth.(PTI)

Rajinikanth's 'Makkal Mandram' office-bearers join DMK

PTI, Chennai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 08:30 PM IST
The Rajini Makkal Mandram, (Rajini People's Forum) was previously considered the political launch vehicle of Rajinikanth.
Close
A long row of tractors on Western Peripheral Expressway headed towards Singhu Border on January 7. The march came a day before the government and the farmers’ unions were slated to hold their next round of talks. (Vipin Kumar / HT Photo)
A long row of tractors on Western Peripheral Expressway headed towards Singhu Border on January 7. The march came a day before the government and the farmers’ unions were slated to hold their next round of talks. (Vipin Kumar / HT Photo)

SC to hear plea of Delhi Police to stay tractor rally by farmers on Republic Day

By Abraham Thomas
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 08:25 PM IST
  • The Delhi Police in its application seeking injunction against farmers taking out a tractor rally had said that the tractor rally could cause law and order problems and embarrass the country.
Close
Farmers leave from Ludhiana for Delhi to participate in a tractor march, on Sunday. (ANI Photo)
Farmers leave from Ludhiana for Delhi to participate in a tractor march, on Sunday. (ANI Photo)

Farmers stage protest rally against new farm laws in Jammu

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 08:23 PM IST
The tractor rally was led by District Development Council (DDC) member Taranjit Singh Tony who defeated senior BJP leader and former minister Sham Choudhary in the recently held elections, officials said.
Close
Shyam Saran Negi, 102, independent India’s first voter who has participated in all elections since 1951, looks out from his house ahead of the final phase. The election was also being seen as a referendum on Prime Minister Narendra Modi, after losses to regional parties in key state elections indicated waning support and a possibility of serious completion in this election. (Cheena Kapoor / REUTERS)
Shyam Saran Negi, 102, independent India’s first voter who has participated in all elections since 1951, looks out from his house ahead of the final phase. The election was also being seen as a referendum on Prime Minister Narendra Modi, after losses to regional parties in key state elections indicated waning support and a possibility of serious completion in this election. (Cheena Kapoor / REUTERS)

At 103, India's first voter casts vote in Himachal Pradesh panchayat polls

PTI, Shimla
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 08:17 PM IST
Shyam Saran Negi, who had made a special appearance in a Hindi film, “Sanam Re”, said he never missed casting his vote.
Close
Farmers demonstrate during the nationwide strike called by Farmers' Unions at the Delhi-Ghazipur border, in New Delhi. (ANI Photo)
Farmers demonstrate during the nationwide strike called by Farmers' Unions at the Delhi-Ghazipur border, in New Delhi. (ANI Photo)

Farmers' union seeks Delhi police commissioner's nod to sit-in at Ramlila Maidan

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 08:14 PM IST
The application was filed by Dr AP Singh, a lawyer on behalf of the farmer union--Bhartiya Kisan Union Lokshakti (BKUL).
Close
Home Minister Amit Shah addresses during the inauguration of the Ethanol projects of M/S Kedarnath Sugar and Agro products at Karakalmatti village in Bagalkot on Sunday. (ANI Photo)
Home Minister Amit Shah addresses during the inauguration of the Ethanol projects of M/S Kedarnath Sugar and Agro products at Karakalmatti village in Bagalkot on Sunday. (ANI Photo)

Surgical strikes in Pak gave public confidence borders safe under BJP govt: Shah

PTI, Belagavi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 07:59 PM IST
Amit Shah said a determined government had responded fiercely to the terror attacks in Uri and Pulwama in Kashmir between 2014 and 2019.
Close
The Maha Kumbh in Haridwar is being held after twelve years.(Reuters)
The Maha Kumbh in Haridwar is being held after twelve years.(Reuters)

Haridwar painted in colours of folk tradition, culture during Maha Kumbh Mela

ANI, Haridwar
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 07:42 PM IST
The Maha Kumbh Mela in Haridwar had begun on Makar Sankranti on January 14 will continue till April.
Close
Farmers from Ludhiana head for Delhi on Sunday to participate in a tractor march, (ANI)
Farmers from Ludhiana head for Delhi on Sunday to participate in a tractor march, (ANI)

Will hold peaceful Republic Day parade in Delhi, say farm unions

By Zia Haq
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 07:34 PM IST
  • The Samyukt Kisan Morcha, a platform of farm unions spearheading the farmers’ agitation, said farmers all over the country would also take out similar parades in state capitals and district headquarters.
Close
The call for the strike came after Congress chief in Tripura was attacked on Sunday allegedly by supporters of the ruling BJP.(Representative image/HT PHOTO.)
The call for the strike came after Congress chief in Tripura was attacked on Sunday allegedly by supporters of the ruling BJP.(Representative image/HT PHOTO.)

Tripura Congress calls for dawn-to-dusk strike to protest attack on party chief

By Priyanka Deb Barman
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 07:37 PM IST
  • The BJP has denied any involvement in the attack on Sunday.
Close
PM Modi remembered him as "a doyen of music, a stalwart of creativity".(@narendramodi/Twitter)
PM Modi remembered him as "a doyen of music, a stalwart of creativity".(@narendramodi/Twitter)

'Leaves our cultural world poorer': PM condoles Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan's loss

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Deepali Sharma, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 07:10 PM IST
The sudden demise of Khan has left many, including his family, in shock as the musician was keeping well and was about to turn 90 on March 3.
Close
Rakesh Tikait and other members of a delegation speaking to the press. (Sanjeev Verma/ Hindustan Times)
Rakesh Tikait and other members of a delegation speaking to the press. (Sanjeev Verma/ Hindustan Times)

Farmers forced to agitate as opposition in country is weak: Tikait

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 17, 2021 07:04 PM IST
The next meeting between farmers demanding the repealing of the farm laws and representatives of the government is scheduled for January 19.
Close
Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut announced the party will contest in West Bengal Assembly Election 2021(HT PHOTO)
Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut announced the party will contest in West Bengal Assembly Election 2021(HT PHOTO)

'Reaching Kolkata soon': Shiv Sena will contest in West Bengal election

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 07:36 PM IST
In 2019 Lok Sabha election, Shiv Sena had contested from West Bengal.
Close
Some people decided not to turn up at the last moment, Satyendar Jain has said. (ANI)
Some people decided not to turn up at the last moment, Satyendar Jain has said. (ANI)

Why many in Delhi skipped 1st-day vaccine, explains Satyendar Jain

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 17, 2021 06:36 PM IST
In Delhi, a total of 4,319 healthcare workers — 53.3 per cent of those registered — got the vaccine shots on the first day of the Covid-19 vaccination drive on Saturday. The vaccine drive in the city will be held four times a week.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP