Live Score
Cricket Teams
Cricket Players
The big debate: Watch cricket from home or at the stadium
Opinion is divided and there are strong arguments on both sides. Obviously, those choosing the television option are in a huge majority.
It’s a question fans face all the time. What’s better : watching cricket at the ground, or on television at home?
Opinion is divided and there are strong arguments on both sides. Obviously, those choosing the television option are in a huge majority.
For them it is a matter of convenience and comfort. Cricket is best enjoyed sitting on a comfortable sofa, remote in hand, food within reach. This way the discomfort of trekking to the stadium and all its attendant problems are avoided. Watching cricket from home is hassle free fun.
Just as ‘ease of doing business’ is a myth in India’s bureaucratic jungle, the promise of a good ‘stadium experience’ for cricket fans is a fake promise. A stadium visit is punishment except for the privileged —tickets are difficult to find, getting in is a struggle, parking a nightmare, loos are filthy and the food isn’t exactly great—the list of pain points is long.
All these are avoided at home, plus there is the bonus of consuming cricket with friends and family, often using a second screen for added engagement. Watching cricket is becoming increasingly immersive, especially for young people who like to test their knowledge on fantasy platforms.
The clincher for the ‘stay at home majority’ is great television coverage with brilliant visuals, terrific slo-mo replays and experts analysing the game. What can be better, fans claim, than Sehwag’s funny gyaan and sharp insight. Spectators at the ground are denied this priceless entertainment.
But the opposite view insists nothing beats being physically present to experience the ‘thrill’ of live cricket. That action is raw and real, not a sanitised version which is electronically transmitted and home delivered. Cricket in the stadium is immediate, personal and intimate—it is a direct email, completely different from a ‘dear all’ message on which millions are copied.
It boils down to ‘feel’. Television provides stunning visuals and the best angles but the pictures don’t capture the speed and intensity of play. It’s only at the ground that you notice the ball travels faster than you imagined, batsmen have little time to react when facing rockets at 145 and they have to sprint insanely fast between wickets to beat the direct throw.
The problem with television is you only see what the cameras want you to see. But spectators at the stadium have a continuous, uninterrupted 360 degree view. They can fix their gaze at the entire ground and all players remain on their mental screen at all times. One can catch action between overs and notice interesting things not available to viewers because crucial screen time is hijacked for annoying adverts that interrupt the flow of play.
Watching the India-Pakistan match live in Dubai I noticed Shadab Khan moving fielders even as captain Babar Azam screamed instructions which nobody could hear. Kohli changed bats during a drinks break, choosing a heavier willow for a final assault. The Pakistan team went into a huddle after the India innings ended. The Indians did complicated fielding drills during the innings break. It’s unlikely the 35 television cameras covered any of this.
Watching live cricket in a packed stadium is a unique experience because you are more involved and invested. In the Pakistan game, the crowd and chaos was not much different from a sellout IPL game at the Kotla. For other matches, the stadium was deserted—looking like Kotla in a Ranji game. Instead of noise there was silence. So quiet you could almost hear batsmen chatting without the stump mike/ the sound of bat striking ball / the bowler’s groan when smashed into the stands .
Personally, I prefer stadium over home so that I can follow cricket with free, focussed attention undistracted by any surrounding noise. In Dubai, especially on a day when the stadium is without crowds, it’s almost a private viewing to a performance where you sit back and work out what the captain is doing, why long-on is taking a longer start, why point is standing so close to the bat.
Most fans feel T 20 cricket is a celebration enjoyed best collectively in the company of friends at the ground. This format is high intensity entertainment, an attractive cocktail of cricket mixed with loud music, noise and active spectator participation.
But this, as they say, is not everyone’s cup of tea. In the initial years of IPL, I invited Tiger Pataudi, a member of the Governing Council, to witness a game. On my insistence, Tiger came to the Kotla though it took him more than one hour to reach because of the evening traffic.
He watched 4 overs —and left. It is too noisy, he said, getting into his car.
