...
...
Next Story

Many threats, only 1 traced: School hoax hunt flounders in Delhi

The latest threats came on Thursday morning, when at least six Delhi schools received emails warning of bombs on their premises.

Updated on: Oct 16, 2026, 11:04:46 IST
Advertisement

Over two years and hundreds of hoax bomb threats to schools later, Delhi Police has cracked just one case, and experts, principals and parents are losing patience with a force that has yet to find an answer.

Bomb squads searched the affected schools after the emails came in around 9am and the threats were declared a hoax. (HT File Photo)
Bomb squads searched the affected schools after the emails came in around 9am and the threats were declared a hoax. (HT File Photo)

The latest threats came on Thursday morning, when at least six Delhi schools, including The British School, Mount Carmel, and Ahlcon Public School received emails warning of bombs on their premises. Bomb squads searched the schools after the emails came in around 9am, and the threats were declared a hoax — the same drill Delhi’s schools have been through hundreds of times in two years, with only one hoax perpetrator ever caught.

Experts and parents now want police to stop treating each email as a separate incident and build a system to trace repeat senders, and want schools given a common procedure that ends the routine of full evacuations every time a threat comes in.

Also Read I Delta flight bomb threat: Plane arriving from New York evacuated after landing at Tel Aviv airport – what we know so far

“Bomb hoaxes are far from harmless pranks,” said Namita Singhal, principal of Venkateshwar Global School in Rohini. “They require authorities to be called in, and the subsequent security checks and inspections consume several hours of the school day.”

Hard to trace

Officials cite technical and legal obstacles that make senders hard to trace. About 99% of the emails trace to IP addresses outside India, one official said on condition of anonymity, and requests to foreign companies for user details mostly go unanswered.

“The main struggle is the legal procedure of MLAT and LR,” an officer with the Intelligence Fusion and Strategic Operations (IFSO) unit said, referring to requests (under a mutual legal assistance treaty) and letters rogatory sent to foreign countries through the courts.

A Delhi Police investigator on one such case, who asked not to be named, said most senders route their traffic through virtual private networks (VPNs), the Tor anonymity network or proxy servers abroad, and almost never use an Indian internet provider. Even when police trace a VPN address a step further, it can lead to thousands of users with identical traffic.

HT Graphic

Cases that went cold

The Russia-linked emails of 2024 show how such cases stall. Threats to more than 250 Delhi schools in April that year came from IDs resembling those used that January, “swarim” and “swareem,” on a Russian domain, and police traced both to the same person, based in Russia, but could not make an arrest.

Foreign companies either say they keep no logs or do not respond because they do not treat a hoax as serious, a second officer said. When details are shared, it takes three to six months, and countries with and without treaties with India have responded alike.

Investigators said a 2022 directive from CERT-In, India’s cybersecurity agency, requiring VPN companies to keep user logs made matters worse, as companies with servers or offices in India shut them and moved abroad.

Email accounts are easy to create, as privacy-focused providers such as Proton and Tuta often skip phone verification. Some threats have come from hacked accounts belonging to real people, police said.

Cracked by luck

Till now, Delhi Police has cracked only one case. In January 2025, south district police zeroed in on a 17-year-old Class 12 student who, investigators said, had sent mass emails, mostly to south Delhi schools, on at least 10 to 12 occasions between July 2024 and January 2025, timed around exams or weekends.

“We were checking for the IP address each time but the sender was using a VPN. There was no way of finding who the sender was,” the investigating officer said.

In early January, a weakness tied to the free VPN the boy was using gave investigators a pool of shared addresses, which they narrowed down to two.

“It also required us to see other factors like the fact that the mails were to south Delhi schools and that they were being sent around exams and weekends ,” the officer said. Investigators finally identified the boy, who lived and studied in south Delhi.

Also Read I Bomb threat emails trigger security checks at schools in Noida and Greater Noida; nothing suspicious found

Elsewhere too, it was only a single slip that worked. In June 2025, Gujarat Police arrested Rene Joshilda, a Chennai-based engineer behind over more than 21 bomb threats across 11 states; she used VPNs and virtual numbers from an app called GetCode, but police said she was traced because she had once logged into her real and fake email accounts from the same device.

Stretched thin

Both breakthroughs depended on mistakes by the senders: a free VPN in one case, a careless login in the other. Police estimate more than half the emails are sent by students, with the rest coming from groups abroad.

“It’s all mischief but people plan and do it,” the officer said.

The cell formed in May has six officials under an assistant commissioner who reports to the deputy commissioner of IFSO, Delhi Police’s cybercrime wing, but it too juggles cases of other nature.

“We can’t have a dedicated team since there are other fraud cases, OTP scams, Chinese app scams, hacking cases and organised scams,” the officer said, adding that IFSO reported about 4,000 cases last year involving losses of ₹850 crore.

Schools left to cope

Nor is there a common procedure that would spare schools a full evacuation and sweep each time. Schools have drawn up their own protocols, and every email, however familiar its wording, still sets off the same response, with children sent home or moved to an open ground and bomb disposal and dog squads searching the premises.

Parents, many of them working professionals, have to leave work to collect their children, while schools arrange buses to take other students home, Singhal said.

Tania Joshi, principal of The Indian School in south Delhi, said the threats have become so frequent that most schools have devised their own methods to keep disruption to a minimum. Her school’s protocol involves informing government authorities and parents promptly and evacuating students safely.

“The entire school community is constantly on alert mode due to the frequency of these threats,” Joshi said. “However, the fear that the ‘cry wolf’ scenario could one day become real continues to persist.”

Rajan Bhagat, a former deputy commissioner of Delhi Police, said the failure cannot be pinned on VPNs or foreign email services alone. The real gap, he said, is that police do not quickly connect evidence across cases, from email headers and account records to intelligence from earlier incidents.

He called for centralised data and immediate preservation of electronic evidence, so that police can identify common infrastructure behind cases that appear unrelated. “Policy must now shift from incident-by-incident investigation to a permanent, intelligence-led bomb-threat attribution system,” Bhagat said.

How others do it

Other countries have mechanisms to limit disruption when obvious hoaxes come in: UK guidance for schools and public venues assumes most bomb threats are hoaxes, and lets those in charge evacuate, move people to safer areas inside, search, or take no visible action. Some US school districts let the principal order a quiet search without dismissing classes if a threat is judged a hoax, keeping police and evacuation for threats that appear genuine.

International cooperation has caught at least one prolific sender: Michael Kadar, a US-Israeli teenager accused of around 2,000 bomb threats worldwide, was arrested in Israel in 2017 after a joint operation by the FBI, Israeli authorities and police in New Zealand, Australia and Europe.

New Zealand police traced one of his first threats to an Israeli IP address, and investigators narrowed it to his apartment in Ashkelon, which was rigged to a large antenna that let him use distant wireless networks.

 
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Hemani Bhandari

Hemani Bhandari is a Special Correspondent with Hindustan Times in New Delhi, where she reports on crime, policing, governance and social issues. With over a decade of experience in journalism, she specialises in combining on-ground reporting with evidence-based storytelling to examine the human impact of public policy, law enforcement and urban governance. Over the years, she has reported extensively on major developments in the capital, including crime investigations, civic challenges, protests, and issues affecting vulnerable communities. As a Special Correspondent, she focuses on producing exclusive investigations, enterprise stories and long-form features that go beyond daily news cycles. She has a keen interest in using public records, official data and field reporting to uncover systemic issues and present complex subjects in an accessible manner. A graduate of the Asian College of Journalism, Hemani believes in rigorous, ethical and evidence-based reporting. She is passionate about investigative journalism and continuously seeks to expand her skills in data journalism, open-source investigations and digital reporting techniques.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jignasa Sinha

Jignasa Sinha is a Special Correspondent at Hindustan Times in New Delhi. With more than six years of reporting experience, she covers crime and policing in the national capital. Her beats also include Delhi prisons, the Delhi Fire Services and Delhi courts, while she regularly reports on gender, labour and social justice. Over the course of her career, Jignasa has reported on major criminal investigations, international crime syndicates, high-profile cyber fraud cases, law-and-order developments, protests, disasters and public institutions. Her reporting combines breaking news with in-depth, long form, human interest stories that examine the human impact of public policy, policing and the criminal justice system. In addition to reporting for the newspaper, she contributes to the Hindustan Times website and app, and plays an active role in coordinating on-ground coverage of major developments and breaking news across Delhi. Before joining Hindustan Times, Jignasa worked at The Indian Express newspaper in New Delhi, where she spent five years covering crime, Delhi airport, courts and health. She began her journalism career as an intern at an AI magazine in Bengaluru while pursuing her postgraduate diploma in multimedia journalism at the Indian Institute of Journalism and New Media.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Gargi Shukla

Gargi Shukla is a correspondent with Hindustan Times. She reports on schools, colleges and issues that affect students, teachers, parents, and educational institutions in India's capital. She closely tracks the political economy of education, student politics, and policy developments shaping the sector in Delhi. She earlier worked as a sub editor with Outlook Business.

Unlock a world of Benefits with HT! From insightful newsletters to real-time news alerts and a personalized news feed – it's all here, just a click away! -Login Now!
Unlock a world of Benefits with HT! From insightful newsletters to real-time news alerts and a personalized news feed – it's all here, just a click away! -Login Now!
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Notifications

Get breaking alerts directly from the newsroom

Notifications are on!You'll be notified when news breaks