RTI users say the first roadblock in most cases are the information officers, who either don’t respond or provide incomplete information.(HT File Photo)
RTI users say the first roadblock in most cases are the information officers, who either don’t respond or provide incomplete information.(HT File Photo)

How RTI Act is dying a slow death in India

A 6% fall between 2015-16 and 2016-17 was reported in RTI applications filed with the 1,950 public authorities of the Central government, which receives maximum information applications followed by Maharashtra and Karnataka.
By Chetan Chauhan | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAY 03, 2018 10:02 AM IST

The right to information law meant to empower Indians and bring transparency in governance appeared to be losing steam with the number of queries going down mainly because of stone-walling of information by officials and slow disposal of appeals, studies based on government data show.

The trend, activists say, is a blow to the concept of a “vibrant democracy”.

The information watchdog, the Central Information Commission (CIC), in a report released in March, said the number of applications seeking information from Central government departments has gone down for the first time since the groundbreaking law was enacted in 2005.

A 6% fall between 2015-16 and 2016-17 was reported in RTI applications filed with the 1,950 public authorities of the Central government, which receives maximum information applications followed by Maharashtra and Karnataka.

“This trend is worrying because people are increasingly finding that getting information from the government is becoming difficult,” said Shailesh Gandhi, a former central information commissioner. There are multiple reasons for the trend.

RTI users say the first roadblock in most cases are the information officers, who either don’t respond or provide incomplete information.

“Earlier, we were scared,” said an information officer with a Central government department, adding they have realised now that taking action against them for not providing information is a “long drawn” process.

The applicant will first have to file an appeal with the first appellate authority, an officer senior to the information provider in the same department. Only after the authority had decided on appeal, a second appeal can be lodged with the information commission. The RTI users say by the time information commissions decided on an appeal — average of two to five years — the information officer is transferred out.

Government data from the CIC and other information commissions show that penalty imposed on errant officers for not responding on time or providing incomplete information was going down.

“Our analysis shows that penalty is imposed in just 4% of appeals where it can be done,” said Venkatesh Nayak, a programme coordinator with the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI).

The total penalties collected by commissions were Rs 1.29 crore till 2016-17.

Another concern highlighted by activists are the commissions, set up to safeguard RTI, as the pendency of cases are rising and quality of the orders going down primarily because many posts of commissioners remaining vacant for long periods.

“Appointments to SICs have become highly politicised and mostly retired bureaucrats are being selected for these posts, shows our latest rapid review,” Nayak said. The latest example is Kerala, where there is only the chief information commissioner.

Governor and former chief justice of India P Sathasivam had rejected the names for information commissioners twice citing complaints against the names proposed by the state government.

About one-third of positions in the CIC are vacant, according to an analysis done by CHRI in March 2018, which also said that 25% of information commissioners’ posts in state information commissions was also vacant.

Andhra Pradesh has no information commission since 2014 when Telangana was carved out as a separate state. The Gujarat Information Commission is headless since this January and Nagaland since October last year. There are huge vacancies in the information commissions of Haryana, Karnataka, Punjab and Uttar Pradesh.

Anjali Bhardwaj of the National Campaign for People’s Right to Information (NCPRI) said the result of this is that a majority of the cases are being disposed off with a single-line order instead of a speaking order, which provides legal justification for the decision.

A speaking order gives detailed legal reasons for the decision.

As a result, in the 23 information commissions, including the central, over two lakh appeals and complaints were pending till November 2017.

A NCPRI study said that at the present pace of disposal, the West Bengal information commission will take 43 years to hear all cases, Kerala 6.5 years and Maharashtra five years.

The study said the CIC in 2018 was hearing appeals filed in 2016 and pendency was rising.

“My appeals in the central information commission on some important policy matters are pending and still they are not listed for hearing,” said Lokesh Batra, a Noida-based RTI activist.

Former defence secretary and present CIC chief RK Mathur did not respond to a text message seeking his comments.

CIC joint secretary, Anil Gehlot, in an email response said the number of pending cases has fallen in the last one year from 26,449 in 2016-17 to 23,259 in 2017-18. But the data provided by him showed that during this period registration of cases have also gone down.

He, however, did not comment on the activists’ claim that the quality of orders was going down and that there were vacant posts in the commission.

An information commissioner of the southern state, who was not willing to be quoted, admitted that the government “recognises” that if the information commissions are “weak”, implementing an ‘effective” RTI law will become difficult.

There are also many positives of the RTI law even though there are emerging difficulties, said Vinson M Paul, Kerala’s chief information commission.

“I believe that 60-70% of the RTI applicants benefit from the law which has also improved transparency in the government. Yes, there is misuse, but it is not by more than 2-3% of the applicants,” Vinson M Paul said.

Former National Advisory Council member and member of the committee that drafted the RTI law, Aruna Roy, said there are many empowering success stories about RTI which the governments should emulate to strengthen the law rather than making attempts to weaken it. She was referring to the latest government proposal to dilute the status of the central information commissioners by downgrading their equivalence from that of Supreme Court judges to that of secretary, government of India.

Last year, the Centre had proposed new RTI rules allowing an applicant to withdraw his appeal and abatement of an appeal if the applicant dies.

This is dangerous considering that RTI applicants are regularly attacked by those whom they intend to expose. Till March this year, 67 RTI activists have died and 385 cases of assaults have been reported, Nayak said.

Despite increasing hurdles for RTI users, both the government and activists agree that the RTI has changed governance in a big way.

“RTI has helped in improving transparency and accountability,” prime minister Narendra Modi said while inaugurating a CIC meeting last month.

Roy said the RTI is a success story of Indian democracy and a celebration of its people, who understood and struggled to make constitutional principles come alive in practice and added that any attempt to make the law “ineffective” will “weaken the democratic pillars” of India.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
The ships' crew will participate in professional and cultural exchanges as well as friendly sports fixtures with their counterparts in the Bangladesh Navy(PTI File Photo/Representative Image )
The ships' crew will participate in professional and cultural exchanges as well as friendly sports fixtures with their counterparts in the Bangladesh Navy(PTI File Photo/Representative Image )

Indian Navy Ships to visit Bangladesh on 50th anniversary of 1971 Liberation war

ANI, Dhaka
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:42 AM IST
India and Bangladesh are celebrating 50 years of the liberation war in which the Pakistan Army was thrown out of Bangladesh and 90,000 of their troops were made to surrender.
Close
India on Monday reported a fresh surge in cases after 18,599 infections were reported in the lat 24 hours. (HT Photo)
India on Monday reported a fresh surge in cases after 18,599 infections were reported in the lat 24 hours. (HT Photo)

India's Covid-19 tally rises after 18,599 fresh cases recorded in last 24 hours

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Arpan Rai, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:55 AM IST
India’s total active caseload stood at 1.88 lakh after six states across the country reported a surge in daily Covid-19 cases.
Close
Kolkata: Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses a public meeting ahead of West Bengal Assembly Polls, at Brigade Parade Ground in Kolkata, Sunday, March 7, 2021. (PTI Photo/Swapan Mahapatra)
(PTI03_07_2021_000175A)(PTI)
Kolkata: Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses a public meeting ahead of West Bengal Assembly Polls, at Brigade Parade Ground in Kolkata, Sunday, March 7, 2021. (PTI Photo/Swapan Mahapatra) (PTI03_07_2021_000175A)(PTI)

On International Women’s Day, PM Modi salutes ‘indomitable Nari Shakti’

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:49 AM IST
Defence minister Rajnath Singh also hailed the role of women in strengthening the foundations of the nation.
Close
Since job requirements are not uniform, the ministry will bilaterally work out the details of skilling needs with the destination countries. (File photo)
Since job requirements are not uniform, the ministry will bilaterally work out the details of skilling needs with the destination countries. (File photo)

Healthcare to generate jobs, govt to focus on skilling for employment abroad

UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:32 AM IST
The work of imparting skills is carried out by the ministry of skill development and entrepreneurship (MSDE), which has identified 300,000 jobs in the health sector alone in countries such Australia, Germany, Canada, Japan, Sweden and Singapore
Close
The Trivandrum airport will remain closed due to Cyclone Burevi.(www.trivandrumairport.com/)
The Trivandrum airport will remain closed due to Cyclone Burevi.(www.trivandrumairport.com/)

SC to hear Kerala's plea against leasing of Trivandrum airport to Adani

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:05 AM IST
The plea was filed in the Supreme Court after the Kerala high court dismissed the state government's plea over the issue last year. It said that this a dispute between Centre and state and can be decided only by the Supreme Court under Article 131 of the Constitution.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi.(PTI)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi.(PTI)

PM-led panel to commemorate 75 years of India's Independence to meet today

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 08:52 AM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
Parliament House(HT_PRINT)
Parliament House(HT_PRINT)

Parliament LIVE: Second leg of Budget session begins as Rajya Sabha reconvenes

By hindustantimes.com, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 10:00 AM IST
As the Parliament session is being held amid the Covid-19 pandemic, vaccination centres were established for the members of Parliament and their family.
The committee of 259 members is headed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
The committee of 259 members is headed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Panel to commemorate 75 years of India's Independence to hold 1st meeting today

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 08:23 AM IST
The celebrations are proposed to be launched 75 weeks prior to August 15, 2022, on March 12, 2021, which is the 91st anniversary of the historic Salt Satyagraha led by Mahatma Gandhi.
Close
Representational Image. (HT file)
Representational Image. (HT file)

Light rain, thunderstorms likely over parts of NW India till Tuesday

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Smriti Sinha
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 08:22 AM IST
Maximum temperatures are in the range of 35-39°C over most parts of the country except over Indo-Gangetic plains where temperatures are in the range of 30-32°C and over Northeast India where temperatures are in the range of 22-25°C
Close
Malls and cinema halls will be shut during the weekends while eateries and hotels have been allowed to operate at 50% of their seating capacity. (HT File photo)
Malls and cinema halls will be shut during the weekends while eateries and hotels have been allowed to operate at 50% of their seating capacity. (HT File photo)

Maharashtra’s Aurangabad in ‘partial lockdown’. Here’s a look at all curbs

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 08:16 AM IST
The central government has also sent a high-level team to Maharashtra to review the surveillance, control and control measures in place in view of the rising cases.
Close
A nurse carries coolers with vials of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine against Covid-19 as elderly people are being inoculated.(AFP Photo )
A nurse carries coolers with vials of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine against Covid-19 as elderly people are being inoculated.(AFP Photo )

Covid-19 LIVE: India's sees 18,599 fresh cases, 97 deaths in last 24 hours

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Arpan Rai, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:33 AM IST
India's vaccination drive is being conducted in full swing as 2,09,22,344 people have been inoculated so far, health ministry data on Sunday showed.
A low-intensity device exploded outside the Israel embassy on January 29.(HT Photo/Sanjeev Verma)
A low-intensity device exploded outside the Israel embassy on January 29.(HT Photo/Sanjeev Verma)

Iran guided Israeli embassy blast through local module, upsets India: Officials

PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 07:02 AM IST
The bomb that went off outside the Israeli embassy on January 29 was not a crude device. Investigators have found that it was triggered by a local module using a remote and could have been put together using the deadly PETN or ANFO. The final lab reports are awaited.
Close
A senior citizen lost his life on Tuesday in a road accident. The victim, identified as Vasudev Anandram Chijwani (65) was a resident of Kumar Prasanna society, Wanowrie.(REPRESENTATIVE PHOTO)
A senior citizen lost his life on Tuesday in a road accident. The victim, identified as Vasudev Anandram Chijwani (65) was a resident of Kumar Prasanna society, Wanowrie.(REPRESENTATIVE PHOTO)

Truck collides autorickshaw in Maharashtra; 5 killed, eight injured

PTI, Beed
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 06:43 AM IST
All the deceased, including two children, were travelling in the autorickshaw to Beed from Wadvani tehsil when the truck rammed into it around 8 pm, a police official said.
Close
Shri Ram Janmbhoomi Teerth Kshetra Trust has been entrusted with the task of Ram temple construction in Ayodhya.(REUTERS file photo)
Shri Ram Janmbhoomi Teerth Kshetra Trust has been entrusted with the task of Ram temple construction in Ayodhya.(REUTERS file photo)

Ram Temple likely to be ready in 3 years, says Trust

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 06:27 AM IST
Earlier on Saturday, Rai, had said the door-to-door collection drive for Ram temple construction in Ayodhya has stopped, but devotees who missed the contribution drive can still make their contributions through the trust website.
Close
He said that in light of recent developments, the CM had lost credibility and he is not fit to continue in power.(ANI Photo)
He said that in light of recent developments, the CM had lost credibility and he is not fit to continue in power.(ANI Photo)

Amit Shah attacks CM over gold smuggling case

By Ramesh Babu, Hindustan Times, Thiruvananthapuram
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 03:40 AM IST
  • Addressing the concluding session of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) state president K Surendran’s “Vijay Yatra” in the state capital, Shah posed five questions to the CM.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP