...
...
Next Story

Suffer little children to come unto me

Children’s Day is a meaningless farce and best discontinued if, after all these decades, an educated girl feels she must thank a violent father for letting her live.

Updated on: Nov 16, 2014 01:49 PM IST
Hindustan Times | By , New Delhi
Prefer HTon Google
Advertisement

One day a man approached another man who was sitting with his companions and told him what he had done. He had a little daughter once who was greatly attached to him. But yielding to social pressure, he decided to take her away from home and kill her as others did when a girl was born to them.

A-still-from-The-World-Before-Her-a-2014-documentary-that-explores-the-many-faces-of-the-modern-Indian-woman
A-still-from-The-World-Before-Her-a-2014-documentary-that-explores-the-many-faces-of-the-modern-Indian-woman

I have heard two versions of how he killed her. One version is that he pushed her into a well and as she fell, she cried out, “Father! Father!” The other one goes that he dug a pit to bury her in, as his people usually did, and while he dug, the little one lovingly wiped the sweat from his brow. She cried aloud in confusion when he proceeded anyway to bury her and he went home to receive the approval of his neighbours and relatives.

A news story in modern India amplified around the world by the foreign press to our further shame? No, though it could be, couldn’t it?

This incident happened in seventh century Arabia. The man this deed was disclosed to was the Prophet of Islam. He is said to have wept so bitterly that his beard was soaked with tears. He consoled the father that God would forgive him for acting out of ignorance but warned him never to do so again.

This powerful verse sprang to mind of its own accord when I happened to see a very disturbing YouTube video this week about Prachi Trivedi, a Durga Vahini camp leader. The hardest heart will surely melt in pity for her. Her father says he branded her foot with a heated bar of iron when he caught her telling a lie in Class 7. She says she hates Gandhi; that she herself will not attack anyone but will kill to defend if attacked. She obeys her father implicitly as her mentor. The video ends with her expressing gratitude to her father for not killing her at birth like so many girls are killed in our society. “He let me live,” she says.

This is not about taking sides or putting down my own faith. It is to say that ‘Children’s Day’ is a meaningless farce and best discontinued if, after all these decades, an educated girl feels she must thank a violent father for letting her live— and such a life. If this is not jahiliyat, I don’t know what is.

 
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Renuka Narayanan

Renuka Narayanan is a commentator and columnist on religion and culture.

Explore Lifestyle stories on Fashion,Health, Relationships, Festivals, Travel, recipe Fitness and Happy Eid 2026 Wishes. Get expert tips, trending updates, and practical ideas to improve your daily routine on Hindustan Times.
Explore Lifestyle stories on Fashion,Health, Relationships, Festivals, Travel, recipe Fitness and Happy Eid 2026 Wishes. Get expert tips, trending updates, and practical ideas to improve your daily routine on Hindustan Times.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON