Booked for homosexuality in 2009, man discharged by Bombay High Court

The Bombay High Court has discharged a man, who was booked under IPC Section 377 by a woman 10 years ago for having homosexual relationship with her husband.
A constitution bench of the Supreme Court partially struck down section 377 in September 2018.(AFP File)
A constitution bench of the Supreme Court partially struck down section 377 in September 2018.(AFP File)
Updated on Jan 31, 2019 11:55 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times, Mumbai | ByKanchan Chaudhari, Mumbai

Observing that while consensual same-sex and extramarital relationship may be considered grounds for divorce, the Bombay High Court (HC) on Wednesday discharged an accused charged under Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) ruling that homosexuality is no longer an offence under the said law. The accused, who got relief from the court, had been charged with having a relationship with the complainant’s husband.

Originally targeted as homosexuality, Section 377 was partially struck down by the Supreme Court in 2018 following which the law applies only in the cases of sexual intercourse with minors, non-consensual sexual acts and bestiality.

The Bombay High Court bench of Justice Mridula Bhatkar was hearing a case against a Kalwa resident, who had been booked under Section 377 in 2009, after a woman alleged he was involved in an extramarital affair with her husband.

Justice Bhatkar discharged the accused and said, “In the present case, both [the Kalwa resident and the complainant’s husband] were having an extramarital, consensual, sexual relationship. Though it may be a ground for divorce available to the complainant, it does not constitute an offence under Section 377 because both are adults and had sexual relationship by consent.”

The Kalwa resident’s discharge plea had been previously rejected by a metropolitan magistrate at Girgaum in January 2012 and this decision was upheld by an ad-hoc additional sessions judge nine months later.

Bhatkar further added that as homosexuality had been decriminalised in a landmark ruling by a constitutional bench of the Supreme Court in 2018, the complainant couldn’t be considered a victim in this case. “The complainant wife is an aggrieved person, but she cannot be called a victim under Section 377 of the IPC,” the judge said.

In 2009, the wife of a Peddar Road resident and businessman had accused her husband of having an extramarital relationship with the Kalwa resident. The couple got married in December 1994, had a child who was seven years old in 2009 and according to the woman, her husband began his relationship with the Kalwa resident in 2007.

She also accused her husband of resorting to domestic violence. On February 26, 2009, Gamdevi police booked the businessman and the Kalwa resident under sections 498 (A) (cruelty at matrimonial home), 323 (voluntarily causing hurt), 504 (intentional insult with intent to provoke breach of peace), Section 377 (carnal intercourse against the order of nature) and 34 (common intention) of the Indian Penal Code. At the time, Section 377 had not yet been struck down by the Delhi High Court.

In July 2009, the Delhi High Court ruled that Section 377 violated fundamental rights of citizens guaranteed under the Constitution of India. However, the Supreme Court reversed this decision in December 2013.

In 2016, the apex court agreed to review its judgment and a five-member constitutional bench delivered a landmark ruling in September 2018 holding that the application of Section 377 to consensual sexual relationships between adults was unconstitutional, irrational and manifestly arbitrary.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The hoax caller who threatened that a bomb has been planted in Bengaluru's Kempegowda International Airport has been arrested. (HT FILE PHOTO.)

    Bengaluru: Fake bomb threat caller arrested; he wanted revenge on his in-law

    A man from Bengal has been arrested in Bengaluru for making a fake bomb threat call to the Kempegowda International Airport in the early hours of Friday morning, triggering heightened security throughout the day. Security officials combed through the airport for over three hours, deploying Central Industrial Security Force troops, and the bomb and dog squads. Gupta reportedly made the call in hopes of vengeance against his brother-in-law, who had recently divorced his sister.

  • Two women wanted in two states were arrested by railway police in Bengaluru on May 11 for allegedly stealing valuables worth over <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>10 lakh at train stations.

    Bengaluru: Two women held for stealing valuables worth over 10 lakh

    It has now come to light that a gang of three, including two women aged 33 and 28, were at large stealing valuables from unsuspecting train passengers across Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka. The two women, identified by several names like Roopa, Anitha, Gayathri or Lavanya, and Saranya, Lavanya, Sandhya or Jamuna were arrested by railway police in Bengaluru on May 11. The women then confessed to their crimes and were arrested.

  • The Calcutta high court ordered on Friday, May 20, 2022 that the post of West Bengal minister's daughter Ankita Adhikary will remain vacant and shall be earmarked for the petitioner.

    HC dismisses Bengal minister's daughter from govt job, asks her to return salary

    The Calcutta high court has barred West Bengal minister Paresh Chandra Adhikary's daughter Ankita from entering the school premises until further orders. She was ordered to pay the first instalment of her salary by June 7, and the second by July 7 this year. The HC further said Ankita's post will remain vacant and shall be earmarked for the petitioner.

  • The mohalla clinics will be set up in both urban and rural areas of Punjab in a phased manner on the Delhi pattern. Chief minister Bhagwant Mann reviewed the plans for the launch of the AAP government’s flagship programme on Friday. (HT file photo)

    Punjab to open 75 mohalla clinics in first phase on Independence Day

    Punjab chief minister Bhagwant Mann on Friday announced the launch of his government's flagship programme of mohalla clinics with the opening of 75 clinics in the first phase to mark the 75th Independence Day on August 15. The chief minister also gave his nod to converting non-functional sewa kendras across the state into mohalla clinics, refurbishing such complexes on a uniform pattern with basic interior components, including doctor's room and pharmacy.

  • The Supreme Court previously directed all states and UTs in the country to hold their respective local body polls within 2 weeks. (HT Photo)

    SC gives Karnataka an 8-week deadline to solve issues delaying BBMP polls

    The Supreme Court on Friday said that necessary notifications regarding delimitation of wards and determining reservation percentage for the Other Backward Classes (OBCs) in the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP), Bengaluru's local administrative body, be notified within eight weeks. The top court was hearing a plea related to conducting polls for the BBMP, whose term ended on September 10, 2020.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, May 20, 2022